More than 25 per cent of sharks in the north-east Atlantic are at risk of extinction, a new study warns.
Paul Eccleston, The Telegraph 10 Nov 08;
Another 20 per cent have been put in the near-threatened category, according to research for the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
And the figures may be an underestimate as there is insufficient data to assess more than a quarter – 27 per cent – of species.
The IUCN Shark Specialist Group (SSG) who drew up the report said it should serve as a dire warning that more needs to be done to protect sharks.
Most of the damage is inflicted by overfishing and by sharks caught as a by-product either in nets or on long-lines. But sharks are being increasingly targeted by commercial fishermen for their fins which can fetch as much as £400 per kilo on the Asian food market.
Because sharks are long-lived and slow to mature they are not prolific breeders which makes them even more vulnerable to over-exploitation.
Because of their position at the top of the food chain they have a critical role in maintaining the balance of ocean ecosystems.
The SSG study looked at the 116 species of shark, closely related rays and chimera (from two different species) in the north-east Atlantic.
It found that 26 per cent are threatened with extinction – much higher than the comparable global figure of 18 per cent.
Seven per cent are critically endangered, seven per cent are endangered and 22 per cent are vulnerable. A further 20 per cent are near threatened.
Two sharks most at risk – spiny dogfish and porbeagle – are the most sought after in Europe for their meat. Both are subject to EU fishing quotas that are well above the zero catch mark recommended by scientists with the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (ICES).
The spiny dogfish often ends up on the menu bill as Rock Salmon or in fish and chips and the migratory porbeagle as swordfish. It is also much prized for its fins.
Claudine Gibson, lead author of the report, said: "From angel sharks to devil rays, north east Atlantic populations of these vulnerable species are in serious trouble, more so than in many other parts of the world.
"Most sharks and rays are exceptionally vulnerable to over fishing because of their tendency to grow slowly, mature late and produce few young.
"Those at greatest risk in the north east Atlantic include heavily fished large sharks and rays, like porbeagle and common skate, as well as commercially valuable deep water sharks and spiny dogfish."
Sonja Fordham, Policy Director for Shark Alliance, a coalition of conservation and scientific groups, said she had no doubt that some fishing nations were deliberately targeting sharks because of their value despite claiming they were being caught only as a by product.
She said only four species – basking shark, great white shark, dogfish and porbeagle have legal protection under EU law while only the UK and Sweden provided full protection for certain shark and ray species. Apart from some agreements between the EU and Norway there are no international catch limits on north east Atlantic sharks.
But with several important fishing related conferences over the next few months there is a great opportunity to improve the protection status of sharks.
"Never before have European countries had more reason or opportunity to safeguard the beleaguered shark and ray species of the northeast Atlantic," she said.
"Country officials should heed the dire warnings of this report and act to protect threatened sharks and rays at national, regional and international levels. Such action is immediately possible and absolutely necessary to change the current course toward extinction of these remarkable ocean animals."
The report recommends:
*Improving scientific data on shark species to determine their true conservation status.
*Scientific advice on catch limits should be heeded.
*Minimising catches through better technology and more selectivity.
*An end to finning by ensuring sharks caught legally are landed with their fins intact.
Some other threatened species:
Angel sharks and common skate: Classed as critically endangered. ICES has called for an end to the fishing of common skate and for angel sharks to be given the highest possible protection.
Gulper shark: Critically endangered. One of se veral deep water species sought for its rich liver oil that is used in cosmetics. ICES has recommended a zero catch limit for deep water species.
Sawfish: Two types are listed as critically endangered but may already be extinct.
Guitarfish: Two species are classified as endangered. They are rays whose fins are highly prized for use in shark fin soup. There are no European limits on catches of guitarfish.
Basking shark: Officially described as endangered in the north east Atlantic. The world's second largest fish is now protected in EU waters but remains vulnerable because of the value of its huge liver and fins.
Bigeye thresher: Listed as vulnerable and at the greatest risk of over fishing by open ocean long line fisheries.
Tope: Data deficient but England and Wales have brought in precautionary bans on targeted fishing.
Blue shark: The dominant species taken in longline fisheries considered near threatened. No subject to any EU or international catch limit.
Quarter of Atlantic sharks and rays face extinction
New figures show 26% of all sharks, rays and related species in the north-east Atlantic are threatened with extinction
Jessica Aldred and Ian Sample, guardian.co.uk 10 Nov 08;
More than a quarter of sharks and rays in the north-east Atlantic face extinction from overfishing, conservationists warned today.
A "red list" report from the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) found that 26% of all sharks, rays and related species in the regional waters are threatened with extinction. Seven per cent are classed as critically endangered, while a fifth are regarded as "near-threatened".
The total number of at-risk species may well be higher because scientists lack of sufficient information to assess the populations of more than a quarter (27%) of them, the report adds. Many are slow-breeding fish that are especially vulnerable to fisheries.
Two species of shark that are highly prized for their meat, the spiny dogfish (rock salmon) and porbeagle, are critically endangered. They are among the few species that are subject to EU fishing restrictions, although these quotas are well above the zero-catch levels proposed by scientists at the International Council for Exploration of the Sea (Ices).
Angel sharks and common skates are also critically endangered in the north-east Atlantic, prompting Ices scientists to call for greater restrictions on fisheries that target them or land them as bycatch. The basking shark, the world's second largest fish, was listed as vulnerable.
Sonja Fordham, policy director at the Shark Alliance, and co-author of the report said: "The north Atlantic is one of the most overfished regions in the world and yet only four species of sharks and rays are protected. This is a clear consequence of overfishing, whether these species are targeted or taken as bycatch."
Another species listed as critically endangered is the deep-water gulper shark, sought for its rich liver oil, which is used by the cosmetics industry. In 2005, Ices urged the EU to effectively ban deepwater shark fishing, but current quotas allow more than 800 tonnes to be taken next year.
The percentage of sharks and rays in the north-east Atlantic region classified as threatened is higher than the figure for species globally (18%), the IUCN found. It said the decline in numbers was due to the activity of fishing nations such as Spain, Portugal, France and Britain.
"North-east Atlantic populations of these vulnerable species are in serious trouble, more so than in many other parts of the world," said Claudine Gibson, former programme officer for the IUCN's shark specialist group and lead author of the report.
"Most sharks and rays are exceptionally vulnerable to overfishing because of their tendency to grow slowly, mature late, and produce few young. Those at greatest risk of extinction in the northeast Atlantic include heavily fished large sharks and rays like porbeagle and common skate, as well as commercially valuable deepwater sharks and spiny dogfish."
Marine conservationists urged EU fisheries ministers, who are due to agree fishing quotas in December, to impose tighter restrictions in line with scientific advice.
"Country officials should heed the dire warnings of this report and act to protect threatened sharks and rays at national, regional and international levels. Such action is immediately possible and absolutely necessary to change the current course toward extincction of these remarkable ocean animals," said Fordham.
