Harrabin's Notes, BBC News 21 Oct 09;
BBC environment analyst Roger Harrabin reports on the tower block under construction in China which could lead the way in green building technology.
THE GREEN TOWER OF GUANGZHOU CITY
Rising high through the polluted air of Guangzhou City in southern China is a 71-storey tower block which, according to its designers, will be the most energy-efficient in the world.
Among a host of features designed either to make or save energy, the one that caught my eye was the shape of the Pearl River Tower itself.
It is built in a curve, facing the prevailing winds. And it has been deliberately sculpted to increase the speed of that wind and force it through slots in the building where wind turbines will be located.
Now, on many buildings, wind turbines are a waste of space because there's so much turbulence in cities. I heard an apocryphal story about a Japanese firm that installed a turbine which needed electric power to keep it turning to save the face of its would-be-green owners.
But the American architects of this tower - SOM - insist that their experiments in a wind tunnel show this building will generate economically viable wind power.
The vertical axis turbines will be located in the mechanical floors mandated by the Chinese government as emergency muster floors, so no usable office space will be lost.
SOM claims that by thinking carefully about the use of space combined with energy-saving and energy-generating technology, they have been able to make unprecedented gains, so this building will potentially create as much energy as it uses.
They are by no means the only architects to espouse the principle of integrated design, of course. But some observers believe that too many buildings are still being put up with a few bolt-on green features, without proper thought as to what could be achieved through a more considered approach.
Take the cooling system in the tower. Most of the time, air conditioning is done by fat air ducts which gobble both energy and space between floors and ceilings. Here the cooling is done by a cool water system.
The water flows in ducts through concrete beams, and cool air descends upon the toiling masses from cold water radiators in the ceilings.
This doesn't just save energy. SOM say it saves so much space that it's allowed the building's owners to put in an extra five storeys of usable office floor at little extra cost. Indeed, they predict that the extra investments in the building will start making the money in five years.
There are other green features too. There's a wide-spaced double-glazed wall, which channels hot air upwards to a mechanical floor where it's harnessed for dehumidification.
There's also substantial use of solar photovoltaic technology on the frontages of the building, which curve upwards toward the sun, although the current cost of photovoltaic arrays militated against cladding the building completely in energy-generating glass.
Inside there are numerous automatic control systems to make sure power isn't being wasted.
SOM say they could have coaxed the building to produce more energy but it would have been futile because there's no facility in Guangzhou to feed self-generated power back into the grid. To many, this will be a familiar tale.
'Radical' design
I can't verify whether all its claims are true, but the building is undoubtedly an exciting project.
Ame Englehart, director of SOM's East Asia office said: "This building is so radical it could only have been commissioned in China. The owners are very self-confident and have been prepared to push the design as far as it will go."
SOM insists that the design is site-specific and can't just be replicated elsewhere.
But the sad observation from my viewpoint standing on the girders of the 24th floor is that this tower is very much the exception rather than the rule.
The Chinese government has increased building standards recently but they still don't lead to anything like the performance of the Pearl River Tower.
A report in the China Daily during my trip suggested that 40% of bribery cases in China involve property development.
And a Western businesswoman I bumped into told me her firm couldn't persuade Chinese clients to invest in more energy-efficient vehicles even if she could prove that they would start paying back their owners in energy costs is just 10 months.
Later in the week I'll be looking at the building frenzy in the Chinese countryside. Tomorrow, though, I'll be looking at electric scooters in Guilin.
HOW THE TOWER SAVES ENERGY
# High temperature fuel cells complement the sustainable systems
# The outer skin controls glare and includes a photovoltaic system for energy
# Wind turbines generate power which can be fed to mechanical equipment
# The design incorporates a "high performance" building envelope
# An air displacement system relies on raised floors
# Cooling tower water passes through embedded tubes in the building
