Skin demand threatens Nigeria crocs

Aminu Abubakar Yahoo News 12 May 09;

KANO, Nigeria (AFP) – Business is booming at Ismail Dauda's crocodile tannery in northern Nigeria, but environmentalists fear soaring demand for skins could be driving the reptiles to extinction.

Thirty-five year-old Dauda followed his father Maifata, whose name means "The Skin Man", into the family business of tanning crocodile and python pelts when he was just 15.

At his tannery in the old part of Nigeria's main northern city of Kano dozens of workers clean and cure the skins. In a good month they look to "process" up to 20,000 animals.

"We have been tanning snake and crocodile skins here for 120 years, but in the last few years we had a boost in our business... there is more demand and there is more market for it," Dauda told AFP.

Some crocodiles are still alive when they are brought to the tannery. After their jaws are roped together, they are turned on their backs before their throats are slit.

The meat is sold to people in the south of the country and the skins, once tanned, are exported to India, Saudi Arabia and now to China, to be made into high-quality leather products such as handbags and shoes.

Processed python skin sells for four dollars a square metre, while a crocodile pelt can bring in between 40 and 170 dollars depending on its size, explained Dauda.

He took a wooden pole to stir a pit containing a putrid smelling concoction of ash, potash and soda ash in which scores of python and crocodile skins were being soaked.

"It is a fact the volume of supplies has dropped in a decade which is perhaps an indication the rate of killing is higher than their regeneration rate, but this is a business we can't stop because it is very lucrative."

Environmental activists are furious that crocodiles might soon face extinction in Nigeria, especially if their hides are simply going to become fashion accessories for the wealthy.

"The trade is unregulated, is illegal, is not recorded. Two species are almost extinct now," Mathew Dore, an environmentalist who has worked with crocodiles for more than 25 years, told AFP.

He said the Nile crocodile, whose skin carries the most value, is "very, very scarce, almost extinct" in Nigeria, and the last time he saw the rarer long-snouted variety was 20 years ago in a zoo.

"The most abundant species now is the West African dwarf crocodile most commonly found in the Niger Delta, and with all this oil pollution and poverty issues, dependence on the crocodile (market) is continuous and unregulated," he told AFP from the southern state of Edo.

It is no coincidence the hide of the West African dwarf crocodile is not so prized for leather goods.

"Ninety percent of the skins are from illegally hunted animals," said environmental activist Desmond Majekodunmi.

"The population has been absolutely decimated. Immediate action needs to be taken, otherwise we will find our crocodile population has gone below the capacity to regenerate itself."

Local crocodile stocks have become so depleted hunters are now bringing in animals from Cameroon, Chad and Ghana.

A 1985 Nigerian law supposed to protect the crocodile and the python does not stop their skins being sold at Lagos airport, right under the eyes of customs agents.

"It does not require much effort to clear the skins at the airport. All you need to do is to pay the officials off," Dauda told AFP. "The officials at the airport... sometimes visit this tannery and we give them some token even if we have no goods to export."

Local Nigerian officials blamed the federal government for the failure to enforce the law.

"The responsibility of stopping trade in the skins of endangered species such as crocodiles lies with the federal government that controls the airports and security agencies," state environment commissioner Garba Yusuf told AFP.

"If the security agencies live up to their duty of arresting and prosecuting offenders, the trade will be stopped because once it becomes impossible to export the skins the demand will drop and the tanners and traders will be out of business."

Dore said crocodile farming was virtually unheard of in Nigeria as would-be farmers looking for short-term profitability were often deterred by the gestation period.

Crocodiles do not reproduce until age five and so a farmer typically has to wait for 10 or 15 years until he can start selling animals, said Dore, who tried bred the animals himself for a decade.

The Nile crocodile was listed as "Lower Risk" on the 1996 World Conservation Union (IUCN) list of endangered species.

The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) lists it as threatened with extinction in certain areas and "not threatened, but trade must be controlled" in others.


Read more!

Powering our way out of poverty

Harish Hande, BBC News 12 May 09;

As we reach the end of the first decade in the 21st Century, about one third of the world's population still has no access to electricity, says Harish Hande. In this week's Green Room, he argues that poor people should be at the centre of sustainable energy policies, not on the end of handouts.

As the world's leaders consider how to finance our battle against climate change, the financing of practical, affordable solutions for poor people in countries like my own, India, appears to be of little interest.

It is nearly 130 years since Thomas Edison gave us the electric bulb, yet more than two billion people on this planet still do not have the luxury of electricity.

Up to 50% of households in India still have no access to modern lighting. Millions of street vendors, whether in the hi-tech city of Bangalore, India, or Kampala, Uganda, still resort to kerosene or candles to sell their meagre wares.

Today, one of the greatest threats to the environment is poverty. Can we go and tell a poor woman in a rural part of a developing country not to cut wood or stop using kerosene for her lighting because it leads to global warming? Does she have a choice?

We've invented iPods and flat-screen TVs, but somehow have not invested in ways to eliminate an Iron Age technology that consumes wood inefficiently and creates harmful indoor air pollution.

Millions of poor households around the world use the classic three-stone cooker to prepare their food, while using wood as the basic fuel.

Millions of trees have to be cut to meet the cooking needs of the poor; for lighting, millions of litres of kerosene are burnt daily. Yet, in this lopsided world, we are spending millions of dollars on finding solutions for the problems created in the West while the poor in developing countries have no choice but to keep harming the environment.

Cheap and continuous

Solutions do exist. Many assume that renewable energies like solar electricity are too expensive for the poor.

True, solar panels alone may be "expensive" but if they are combined with affordable financing mechanisms for the poor, they can be rolled out widely and make clean electricity a sustainable and viable option for millions around the developing world.

The poor spend between 10-15% of their meagre income on energy services like lighting and cooking.

This is a much higher percentage than those people who are better off. For example, a typical street vendor in Bangalore pays 15 rupees ($0.32) for four hours of kerosene lighting each day.

On a monthly basis, she therefore pays $9-10 to light her street cart. Today, solar lighting can be provided to her at commercial rates for $5-6 every a month.

The big bonus is that the vendor is able to pay for it on a daily basis, not on a monthly basis. As one street vendor told me: "300 rupees a month is expensive but 10 rupees a day is very affordable."

Much attention has gone in to reducing the cost of the technology, but much less on the details of supply chains and financing.

This would make technologies like solar, bio-gas and small-hydro affordable today, not tomorrow, to the poor.

Sustainable forms of energy can also play a key role in income generation - a primary path out of poverty for the millions who do not have access to reliable grid-distributed electricity.

The poor are also victims of inefficiency - they use inefficient sewing machines, bangle making machines and power looms. This results in soaring overall costs.

The blame is placed on renewable energy technologies, not inefficiencies of the appliances.

Many of these devices are produced with the assumption that grid electricity is "infinite" so, especially in the developing world, there is little incentive to make more efficient products.

High-efficiency income-generating appliances would increase the attractiveness of renewable energy technologies - leading to higher incomes.

Solutions are simple and do-able, but require approaches that are focused on the poor.

Many of the policies, products (both financial and technology) and processes are designed with a top to bottom approach.

This can completely bypass the needs of the poor. Technology is pushed down with disastrous consequences; many solar systems used in the rural areas of India do not work well, creating a notion that renewable energies are not reliable.

Clean cooking solutions have been created but with the idea that one size fits all, without considering the different fuel sources, food choices, cooking styles, or the size of the family.

It's high time that the poor become central to energy policies and not just recipients or "project beneficiaries".

Only then will sustainable energy be their ticket out of poverty, as well as a vital way to address climate change.

Harish Hande is managing director of Selco Solar, India

Selco Solar was the 2007 winner of the Outstanding Achievement Award from the Ashden Awards for Sustainable Energy


Read more!

Cost of solar energy will match fossil fuels by 2013, claims Solarcentury

Falling production costs for solar panels and increasing nonrenewables electricity costs have brought parity closer
Adam Vaughan, guardian.co.uk 12 May 09;

Solar energy will fall in price to match the cost of conventional fossil fuel electricity far sooner than previously expected, the UK's largest solar company has claimed in a new report.

Solarcentury said British homeowners will see solar achieve "grid parity" – the point where solar electricity rivals or becomes cheaper than conventional nonrenewable electricity – by 2013. Most predictions suggest that technological innovation will not bring the price down far enough until 2020 or later.

The company suggested falling production costs for solar panels and increasing conventional electricity costs have brought parity closer. Prices for solar and grid electricity in residential homes are expected to crossover at around 17p to 18p per unit of electricity (kWh) in 2013, followed by parity for commercial solar electricity in 2018.

Last December, the renewable energy analysts New Energy Finance predicted silicon costs – a key material for much solar panel technology – would fall by 31.5% in 2009 compared with 2008 levels. Energy consultants Element Energy, under commission from the government, have also forecast solar PV costs will fall by around half between now and 2020.

Derry Newman, CEO for Solarcentury, said: "When you reach grid parity, you have a watershed moment where the perceptions of investors and consumers shift. People have been programmed to believe solar is expensive and takes a hundred years to pay back, but when parity arrives people realise it takes 8-10 years to payback, and they can then be making money out of it."

Jeremy Leggett, executive chairman of Solarcentury said, "The feed-in tariff that the government has said it will bring in from April 2010 is vital. A burst of premium-pricing for solar energy, of the kind now on offer in 18 European countries, will stimulate a very fast-growing market."

Experts said the projections were based on significant assumptions in future energy prices, which have been extremely volatile over recent years – last year saw gas and electricity prices double, but now household bills are falling again.

Ray Noble, solar PV specialist at the Renewable Energy Association, said: "The predicted grid parity by 2013 could be possible if all of the predictions, both in terms of grid electricity prices increasing and reductions in the cost of solar PV, come through. However that's a big if – any slight changes in the pricing can add further years to this date." He added that the important message is that even if grid parity slipped to 2016, the moment when solar can compete on cost is not far off.

Chris Goodall, Green party parliamentary candidate and author of Ten Technologies to Save the Planet, warned the grid parity predictions were based on unrealistic price assumptions. "This projection of residential grid parity depends crucially on continually increasing prices of conventional electricity, but I just don't see any evidence that residential electricity will cost 17-18p a kWh in 2013. The 'underlying' retail price of electricity at the moment is no more than 11p per kWh," he said.

Newman argued that China will continue to take more fossil fuel and believes peak oil will begin to bite in 2013, which will both contribute to rising prices in fossil fuel electricity.

Other parts of the world, such as Spain and California, have already achieved grid parity on the price of solar, but only for large installations rather than small scale ones for homeowners.


Read more!

Cleaner air from reduced emissions could save millions of lives, says report

Researchers predict that 100 million early deaths could be prevented by cutting global emissions by 50% by 2050
Adam Vaughan, guardian.co.uk 12 May 09;

Tackling climate change by cutting greenhouse gas emissions could save millions of lives because of the cleaner air that would result, according to a recent study.

Researchers predict that, by 2050, about 100 million premature deaths caused by respiratory health problems linked to air pollution could be avoided through measures such as low emission cars . The economic benefits of saving those lives in developing countries such as China and India could also strengthen the negotiating hand of the UK and Europe at a crucial UN climate summit in Copenhagen this December.

Johannes Bollen, one of the authors of the report for the Netherlands Environment Agency, said the 100 million early deaths could be prevented by cutting global emissions by 50% by 2050, a target consistent with those being considered internationally. "

The reports warns that if governments continue with business-as-usual energy use, then population growth, ageing demographics and increased urbanisation will cause premature deaths from pollution to increase by 30% in OECD countries, and 100% outside the OECD.

The study also has implications for which technologies are chosen to reduce CO2 and other greenhouse gases. The study points out that while carbon capture and storage technology can capture CO2, it does not usually trap other air pollutants. Last month, the energy and climate minister, Ed Miliband, put "clean coal" at the centre of UK energy policy by pledging no new coal-fired power stations would be built without at least partial CCS.

In contrast, the report said, reducing car emissions and the number of vehicles on the road would lead to both lower greenhouse gases and fewer local air pollutants from exhausts. Jim Storey, air quality policy adviser at the UK's Environment Agency, said he wanted climate policies that account for their effect on air pollution: "There are win-wins for climate change and air quality that should be pursued with all haste, such as improving energy efficiency in houses, and reducing emissions from transport. Transport remains the largest cause of air pollution in the UK, and accounts for around 20% of the UK's greenhouse gas emissions."

The report also said the economic gains of cleaner air could be attractive for developing countries during climate treaty negotiations in Copenhagen later this year. By not losing people of working age to pollution, India and China, for example, stand to gain 4-5% in GDP in 2050 as a result of cleaner air, compared with around 1% of GDP in OECD countries such as the UK. "The local air pollution benefits of climate mitigation policies provide an additional economic incentive for countries to participate in a global agreement to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions," said Bollen.

The health threat of air pollution is well known. Recent research from the American Lung Association revealed that 186 million US residents live in areas with dangerous levels of air pollution. "Despite almost 40 years since the Clean Air Act passed in 1970, six in 10 Americans still live in dirty air areas, areas where the air is unhealthful to breathe," said the ALA's Paul Billings. As well as citing dirty diesel vehicles and coal power plants as significant contributors to US air pollution, the Association's report called for a clean-up of cruise ships, container ships and tankers, which it said will be responsible for approximately 45% of US particulate emissions by 2030. Confidential data released last month from the shipping industry suggested 15 of the world's biggest ships may now emit as much pollution as all the world's 760m cars.

In the UK, a report published this month by the London Assembly Environment Committee claimed that poor air quality in London may have contributed to 3,000 premature deaths in the capital in 2005. London has the worst air quality in the UK and among the worst in Europe for small, sooty particles known as PM10s and nitrogen dioxide.

The key air pollutants that can harm human health include nitrogen dioxide, sulphur dioxide, volatile organic compounds, ammonia and particulate matter and are produced by burning fossil fuels in power plants and vehicles. Children and the elderly, plus people with respiratory conditions such as asthma, are particularly at risk.


Read more!

Best of our wild blogs: 12 May 09


The frog of human kindness
victim of animal release on the annotated budak blog

Surprises from Changi rocky shore
with otter sighting! on the wonderful creation blog and crabs of changi, also on the wild shores of singapore blog and nature calls

Only Underwater @ Pulau Hantu
on the colourful clouds blog

Lady Mygale
on talfryn.net

An end to lice
on the annotated budak blog and leaf monkey.

World Migratory Bird Day
on the Lazy Lizard's Tales blog

Turning Cars Into Nodes on the Net: Our Electric Car Future
on the Daily Galaxy: News from Planet Earth & Beyond

Pink-necked Green Pigeon swallows MacArthur palm fruit
on the Bird Ecology Study Group blog

Monday Morgue: 11th May 2009
on the Lazy Lizard's Tales blog


Read more!

Get students to play active role in protecting planet

Straits Times Forum 12 May 09;

I REFER to the article, 'Blue Plan to save Singapore's biodiversity-rich coral reefs ready' (April 24). I heartily approve of the Blue Plan. As much as possible should be done to protect various aspects of the environment.

However, not enough is being done. All these policies take a long time to implement. Global warming and destruction of the environment will not wait for man to do something to rectify his mistakes.

We should make environmental conservation and protection one of our primary concerns, and the Government should devote more effort and resources to this.

One way is to better educate the public. After all, is it not we who harm the environment? The Government should start with schools. Most schools have few, if any, programmes related to the environment.

Of course, the basic minimum is being taught, such as the need for recycling, reducing and reusing. And recycling bins have been set up. However, all these are repeated over and over and students become bored and consider these measures burdensome.

If schools do more in-depth teaching, and conduct more programmes and workshops, students will become more interested and play a more active role in helping to conserve and protect the environment. Global warming will become a more real issue to them.

Lhavanya Dharmalingam (Miss)


Read more!

A miracle wrought by ordinary people

Straits Times Forum 12 May 09;

I REFER to Thursday's report, 'Singapore's green trump card'.

While Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew stressed that 'clean and green' is Singapore's secret weapon and recalled his efforts to clean the 'smelly and dirty' Singapore as a priority amid myriad challenges shortly after independence, I cannot help admiring his vision and leadership that helped to build a nation from scratch and lift it from Third World to First within several decades.

The story began with the shocking news that Singapore was abandoned, with scarce resources and people different in colour, language, culture and religion. Indeed, there seemed to be no hope that Singapore could survive and become a nation. However, not only did it survive, but it also endured; not only did it endure, but it also prospered. Within decades, it became a nation where hardworking people, regardless of colour, race, religion and culture, live harmonious, affluent and happy lives.

Singapore's success is an undeniable miracle, but the Singapore story is not about how supermen transformed a nation, but how decent people built decent neighbourhoods that are clean, green and safe, and how these neighbourhoods bind a nation.

As Mr Lee said, what could be done immediately after Singapore left Malaysia, was 'to show investors that this was a well-organised place'. To build order, he and his people set out to clean the city and plant trees. Once the infrastructure was in place, they worked to improve people's manners. Meanwhile, they worked to build other pillars of community - rule of law, science, education, etiquette and culture. The rest is history.

It is hard to believe that simply by sprucing ourselves up, showing good manners, and cleaning and greening our neighbourhoods, ordinary people can build a nation or sharpen its competitiveness. But the Singapore story has proved it all.

Singaporeans will do well to carry on this legacy. And foreigners like me, born and raised in 'reform and open policy'-steered China, learn that there are other ways to spur economic growth than simply sacrificing the environment and relying on cheap labour.

Jessica Wang Jing (Ms)


Read more!

Giving new life to old wood: eco-friendly furniture

Tan Hui Leng, Today Online 12 May 09;

WHEN Ms Anita Sam (picture) started importing eco-friendly furniture five years ago, customers snapped up pieces based on their design and craftsmanship. Today, consumers consider the environmental sustainability of the furniture’s raw materials first, and design second.

“I think Singaporeans have reached a level of maturity where they love good design and quality, but they also want to be socially responsible,” said the Singapore Permanent Resident and furniture industry veteran.

“It’s the ‘feel-good’ factor ... not only does the furniture look good, it is also good for the environment.”

Last Friday’s official opening of the flagship d-Bodhi concept store, which Ms Sam said saw “very substantial sales”, is testimony to her passion for environmental sustainability. In fact, sales at the eco-friendly furniture business have grown almost 10-fold from 2004 when it would ship out two containers a month to the 18 to 20 containers monthly now. The company aims to expand its monthly exports to some 30 containers this year and 50 next year.

d-Bodhi is one of a few reclaimed wood industry players in Singapore. The furniture range was started in 2002 by Dutch national Raymond Davids, a partner of the company. It recently set up a 3,200-square-foot flagship store at Alexandra Industrial Estate here and hopes to have 200 d-Bodhi shops worldwide by 2015.

d-Bodhi uses reclaimed teak from Indonesia, with pieces salvaged from buildings and railway sleepers and can be up to 100 years old.

“Reclaimed wood poses other challenges, such as the tedious collection of wood,” said d-Bodhi’s co-owner and director Ms Sam. A team of 700 in Indonesia is involved in the business — from sussing out buildings for sale to collection of wood.

Unlike buying new wood by volume, reclaimed wood comes in all shapes and sizes. It has to be processed more arduously, as items like nails, nuts and bolts and screws have to removed before they can be stripped down. The planks then have to be sorted according to the type of furniture they are more suited to be in their next lifetime.

However, such teak has a special quality which Ms Sam and other aficionados love for the character its grain, natural finish and age lend.

The d-Bodhi line is marketed as a premium brand, with prices starting at $300 for chairs and over $3,000 for bedroom sets. d-Bodhi also distributes to 13 countries globally and aims to sell in 25 countries by next year.

It has been successful in getting the United States-based Forest Stewardship Council to start a new certification category, that is, “100 per cent recycled wood” for such furniture, different from new wood sourced from sustainable plantations.

“For many of our customers, it’s a conscious decision to buy from us rather than from other shops,” said Ms Sam.

“Some of them also tell me frankly that they entertain friends and business associates who are environmentally friendly.”

That d-Bodhi’s furniture come with an international “green” certification is the icing on the cake. The company has extended the eco-friendly aspect of the business to reuse sawdust generated during the furniture making process as they are pressed with a resin to be made into home accessories like tealight holders, coasters and table lamps.

Looking ahead, d-Bodhi is open to using other types of reclaimed wood. It is also looking into working with more Singapore designers through Spring Singapore.


Read more!

Crude Oil spill unleash fear among endangered Olive Ridley turtles in Orissa coast

Anurjay Dhal, Odisha Today 11 May 09;

Bhubaneswar ( Orissa ) The Indian Oil Corporation officials manning the Paradip-Haldia pipe line in Orissa, have unleash fear among the endangered Olive Ridely turtles.

According to Biswajit Mohanty, chief of 'Operation Kachhapa', a major oil spill has occurred in the under sea portion of the Paradip- Haldia pipeline in the Paradip coast.

The oil was being received for piping to Haldia refinery through the single point mooring (SPM) system when the pipe broke.

Under SPM, an undersea pipeline is laid out for 4- 5 kms inside the sea to deeper waters where deep draught vessels carrying huge loads of crude oil can anchor and unload the oil without coming inside the port.

Indian Oil has been using the SPM since December, 2008 to unload and transport crude oil, Mohanty added on Monday.

Sources reveal that the pipeline broke and crude oil spilled when the crude was being unloaded from the crude vessel “NABHI” on the night of April 22. At least 2,000 to 3,000 tons of crude oil has leaked out in the mid sea.

The SPM pipelines are of extremely high quality and are regularly tested for weak spots and likely spillages. It is clear that Indian Oil officials have goofed up in carrying out such under sea inspections at regular intervals to maintain the safety protocols.

“Though the officials are duty bound to report the spill in view of its proximity to the marine sanctuary, no intimation was given and the Wildlife wing of Orissa Government was kept completely in the dark about this accident.

Similarly, the news of the spill was concealed and local media were unaware of it for a long time though this is the first major oil spill at Paradip coast,” he alleged.

Since the summer currents are in the northward direction of the coast, these crude spills are expected to wash up at Gahirmatha which is only 15 kilometers away from Paradip port. This shall irreversibly damage the turtle feeding grounds in the wildlife sanctuary.

Turtles feed on benthic fauna like mollusca, sea worms, star fish, anemones, sea cucumber, etc. Once the oil covers this area, the fauna will die out and the resulting pollution will prevent their regeneration for a long time.

Crude oil is a very persistent pollutant and marine oil spills in the past have lead to disastrous loss of marine wildlife and habitat. Fish breeding grounds are destroyed by such spills.

Operation Kachhapa has demanded that an expert team comprising of marine pollution experts and biologists should be rushed to Gahirmatha coast to carry out an impact study and identify and quantify the damage which has occurred.

Indian Oil should be asked to pay compensation to help the forest department to carry out the impact study and also adopt appropriate remedial measures to mitigate the impacts.

The crude oil should be collected and disposed off safely instead of being allowed to pollute the pristine Gahirmatha Marine sanctuary, Mohanty added.

The move of the IOC has invited sharp criticism from wildlife activists and turtle lovers in Orissa in particular and the World in general.


Read more!

Healthy reefs 'vital to humanity'

ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies
ScienceAlert 11 May 09;

The lesson from Australia’s Great Barrier Reef is that we have to protect its biodiversity – because biodiversity in turn protects us.

That’s the message from Professor Sean Connolly from the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies and James Cook University who today receives the Australian Academy of Science’s prestigious Fenner medal for his pioneering work in understanding how ecosystems develop and maintain their amazing diversity.

“The Great Barrier Reef is one of the richest systems of living things on the Planet. Understanding how it became so rich, and how to keep it that way, is essential for its survival – as well as for all our industries and activities that depend upon the Reef,” he says.

Professor Connolly says his research shows that that species diversity lies at the heart of stable ecosystems.

Since ecosystems help to support humanity in many ways – with food, clean air and water as well as livelihoods, industries and recreation – keeping them in a condition to continue to support us is vital, he argues.

“As a rule, ecosystems with many species are more stable over time. This is because, as conditions change, the system is more likely to have species that can cope with the new conditions. Having lots of species reduces the likelihood of a major ecological collapse.

“In other words, high biodiversity is nature’s insurance policy.”

“But it is also our insurance policy, because it protects and assures the many services that ecosystems provide us.”

Professor Connolly says that the many rare species the GBR contains make the system more robust overall. “If conditions change, then common species may become rare and rare species common – but the system as a whole survives. It’s very much on our interest to manage and care for it so this keeps on happening.”

Professor Connolly has specialized in linking observations and experiments in marine ecosystems with mathematical models of how populations of different species change and interact over time – and how this drives the dynamics of biodiversity itself, now and in the deep past.

Among his achievements he has produced a model that helped pinpoint a previously unknown impact of ocean acidification caused by high CO2 in the atmosphere – increased loss of coral species due to storm damage.

His work on the geographic ranges of coral species has challenged the conventional view that conservation should focus mainly on ‘hot spots’ of species diversity.

Sean was a co-author of the Townsville Declaration on Coral Reef Research and Management, hailed by The Australian newspaper as “a remarkable example of an increased willingness by governments to heed scientific advice.”

He has identified a continued collapse in the populations of reef sharks on the Great Barrier Reef from over-fishing and his work is now helping to improve shark management in Queensland.


Read more!

Rules Proposed To Save The World's Coral Reefs

ScienceDaily 12 May 09;

An international team of scientists has proposed a set of basic rules to help save the world’s imperiled coral reefs from ultimate destruction.

Their proposal is being unveiled at the World Ocean Conference 2009 in Manado, Indonesia, where leaders of six regional governments plus Australia and the United States are meeting to declare the largest-ever marine reserve in world history, the Coral Triangle Initiative.

“The catastrophic decline in the world’s coral reefs demands urgent management responses on two fronts,” say the researchers from the Australian Research Council’s Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies (CoECRS), The Australian Museum, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, James Cook, Perpignan and the United Nations Universities and The Nature Conservancy.

These are the “...reduction of immediate direct threats such as climate change, over-fishing and water pollution, and actions to protect or enhance the resilience of reef ecosystems in the face of existing and unavoidable future threats,” they say.

The key to saving threatened coral ecosystems is to maintain the links (connectivity) between reefs allowing larvae to flow between them and re-stock depleted areas, the team led by Pew Fellow Dr Laurence McCook of Australia’s Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA) argues.

“Ecological connectivity is critically important to the resilience of coral reefs and other ecosystems to which they are linked,” says Dr McCook. “The ability of reefs to recover after disturbances or resist new stresses depends critically on the supply of larvae available to reseed populations of key organisms, such as fish and corals. For reefs to survive and prosper they must in turn be linked with other healthy reefs.”

The researchers propose six ‘rules of thumb’ for keeping coral ecosystems viable, based on the results of research carried out in the Bohol Sea in the Philippines, the Great Barrier Reef in Australia, and Kimbe Bay in Papua New Guinea.

These rules are:

1. allow margins of error in extent and nature of protection, as insurance against unforeseen threats;
2. spread risks among areas;
3. aim to create networks of protected areas which (a) protect all the main types of reef creatures, processes and connections, known and unknown; (b) achieve sufficient protection for each type of reef habitat type, and for the whole region; (c) achieve maximum protection for all reef processes (d) contain several examples of particular reef types to spread the risk;
4. protect whole reefs where possible; place buffer zones around core areas.
5. allow for reef species to spread over a range of distances, especially 20–30 km; and
6. use a range of conservation approaches, including marine protected areas.

The rules are designed to operate in a range of situations, including where detailed scientific knowledge of local coral reefs and their species is sparse, the team says in a review article in the journal Coral Reefs.

Protecting reef connectivity and allowing reef species to freely recharge depleted areas is vital to ensuring that coral reefs remain resilient in the face of mounting human and climatic pressures. To ignore the protection of connectivity until sufficient scientific data was available on all reefs would mean allowing reefs to continue to degrade for many decades to come.

“The risks of inadequate management arising from ignoring connectivity are greater than those associated with any scientific uncertainty,” the researchers say.

The work was funded jointly by the World Bank Coral Reef Targeted Research program and the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies.

“The Coral Triangle Initiative is one of the most important marine conservation measures ever undertaken anywhere in the world and the first to span several countries. It involves the six nations of Indonesia, the Philippines, Malaysia, Papua New Guinea, East Timor and the Solomon islands, and is as much about nation building and food security as it is about reef conservation” says Professor Terry Hughes, Director of the CoECRS, attending the Coral Triangle meeting today in Manado.

The ‘rules of thumb’ proposed in the research paper were an example of the sort of science being carried out across the region which will assist the Coral Triangle Initiative to achieve its goals, he said.

Journal reference:

1. L. J. McCook, G. R. Almany, M. L. Berumen, J. C. Day, A. L. Green, G. P. Jones, J. M. Leis, S. Planes, G. R. Russ, P. F. Sale and S. R. Thorrold. Management under uncertainty: guidelines for incorporating connectivity into the protection of coral reefs. Coral Reefs, (in press)

Adapted from materials provided by ARC Centre of Excellence in Coral Reef Studies.


Read more!

World Ocean Conference: Time for countries to speak out on marine issues



The Jakarta Post 11 May 09;

As the biggest archipelagic country in the world, Indonesia has called on the global commu-nity to speak out on the need and significance to preserve the ocean, which plays a key role in food security.

Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister Freddy Numberi told a press briefing Sunday that many countries were affected by global warming, including rising sea levels and sea temperatures.

"What about the people affected by the impacts *of global warming* caused by developed countries? Should we remain quiet?" he said a day before the start of the May 11-15 World Ocean Conference.

"It's time for us to speak out. about the absorption, about the emissions. These issues need further discussions."

He added many countries had to deal with rising sea levels, which in some places have already submerged some small islands.

The International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) predicts that climate change will raise sea levels by nearly 60 centimeters by 2100 if nations do not make a concerted effort to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

One of the examples is the Maldives, which are currently 1.5 meters above sea level and is at serious risk of being inundated by rising sea levels.

Freddy said Indonesia had received support from Pacific countries to speak out on the ocean-related issue, especially on preservation and food security.

He added the country had begun the preservation of its marine ecosystem in a bid to show the global community that Indonesia was taking real action.

"We've begun to create marine protected areas (MPAs), especially in the Savu Sea in East Nusa Tenggara. Our move was previously challenged by the local people because they observe the lamalera *whaling* tradition," he said.

"With the Savu Sea becoming a conservation area, they were afraid they would no longer be able to hunt whales. They only catch two whales a year. So we've kept the sea a conservation area, but we ensure they can still perform their traditional fishing rights."

The Coral Triangle Initiative (CTI) - to begin on May 14 - is expected to come up with an action plan to preserve 75,000 square kilometers of coral reefs spread out between six countries: Malaysia, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, the Solomon Islands, Timor Leste and Indonesia. The six countries will get international funding worth US$250 million.

The coral triangle is located between the Pacific and Indian oceans, making the spot a breeding ground for numerous species of fish, which makes it a potentially lucrative fishing industry.

WOC ignores main problems in ocean sector: Activists
Adianto P. Simamora and Jongker Rumteh, The Jakarta Post 11 May 09;

A long history of illegal fishing, the dumping of tailing from mining companies into the sea, and poor support for traditional fishermen are the three main problems in Indonesia's ocean sector. Unfortunately, those issues remain excluded from the agenda at the World Ocean Conference (WOC) that begins Monday.

Activists grouped under the Manado Alliances said their presence here was to observe the WOC and the Coral Triangle Initiative (CTI) Summit. They said they wanted to remind both national and foreign delegates about the real problems in the ocean sector.

"We see the conference falls short of critical and real problems that were excluded from the WOC agenda, namely rampant illegal fishing, tailing from mining into the sea, and the fate of small fishermen," coalition coordinator Reza Damanik said Sunday.

The coalition comprises the People's Coalition for Equal Fisheries (Kiara), the Mining Advocacy Network (JATAM), the Hijau Indonesia Institute, the Center for Ocean Development Institute Maritime Civilization Studies, the Anti-Debt Coalition (KAU) and the Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi).

Reza, who is also the Kiara coordinator, said the WOC would not guarantee sustainable fishery resources if the host country failed to be "courageous" about discussing the illegal fishing problem at the international meeting.

He added data from the coalition showed Indonesia's fisheries potential was slashed by 30 to 50 percent because of illegal trade practices.

"The conference also falls short on discussing issues related to mining tailing being dumped into the sea," Reza said.

"Many mining firms from industrialized nations operating in Indonesia still dump their mining wastes directly into the ocean."

He added the WOC did not answer the need to protect key fishing areas for the country's traditional fishermen.

"It is the government's responsibility to protect the rights of traditional fisheries from the impacts of global climate change," he said.

Outspoken mining activist Siti Maimunah insisted that participants from NGOs did not intend to disturb the WOC and CTI summit.

"We are here to insist on the substances of the WOC and CTI, which do not answer the root causes of problems in the ocean sector," she said.

Senior officials from 80 countries are slated to begin negotiations to reach a target of collective consensus on the role of the ocean in climate change during the five-day conference.

Organizers say the conference is aimed at raising commitment from international bodies and intergovernmental organizations to protect and conserve fisheries resources to ensure food security.

It is also targeted at drawing global attention to the need to save small islands and coastal areas as part of facing up to the threat from global climate change.

"But there are no representations from *real' stakeholders at the forum, and no consultations have been held to develop the concept of the WOC agenda," Glenn Ismael Ymata, from the regional Assembly of Artisans and Fishermen Trade Conference, said at the coalition meeting.

Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister Freddy Numberi has repeatedly said Indonesia has other forums to discuss issues such as illegal fishing.

He added climate change had become a real problem for mari-time countries as it threatened to raise sea levels and sea temperatures, which could kill fishes and threaten the livelihoods of coastal communities.

The police in Manado said they were forced to disband a meeting of traditional fishermen and civil society on Sunday. They declined to comment on the reasons for not allowing the fishermen to camp out in a reclaimed area of Kalasey Beach.

Walhi executive director Berry N. Forqan said the alliance was still negotiating with the National Police in Jakarta to obtain a permit for the meeting.

WOC and Indonesia's sustainable ocean development
Rokhmin Dahuri, The Jakarta Post 11 May 09;

Perhaps there is no country in the world that might have a greater need than Indonesia to be concerned about its ocean space and resources. After centuries of being at the epicenter of international trade and commerce due to its geo-strategic location on the the Asia Pacific Rim, Indonesia, which forms the world's largest archipelago (more than 17,500 islands) and possesses the greatest marine biodiversity of any region of the world, should be recognized as one of the most significant maritime nations.

Indeed, prior to the colonial era, Indonesia was one of the strongest maritime powers in the Asia-Pacific region. Moreover, at times when the Law of the Sea was negotiated, Indonesia was respected as one of the most outstanding leaders, especially in ensuring the archipelagic concept (the 1957 Djoeanda Declaration) was incorporated into the 1982 UNCLOS.

However, from the beginning of colonialism until the fall of the New Order government (1998), Indonesia has turned its back on the oceans and has not dealt effectively with coastal and ocean development as a sustainable source of its competitiveness, prosperity and sovereignty. For more than three and a half centuries, most Indonesians had perceived the oceans as "a marginal land" with insignificant economic potential and no strategic value for the nation.

Such a misleading perception was obviously reflected in the allocation of government funds, credit loans, human resources, science and technology, infrastructure and other management input into coastal and ocean development sectors that have been much smaller than those for land-based development sectors.

It is no coincidence the pattern of coastal and ocean resource development in the past was characterized by low technological content, inefficient and highly extractive, with no regard for environmental and resource sustainability. As a corollary, the physical destruction of vital coastal ecosystems (coral reefs, sea-grass beds, mangroves, estuaries and beaches), pollution, overfishing, biodiversity loss and other environmental stresses in some coastal areas (such as parts of the Malacca Strait, Jakarta Bay, the south coast of South Sulawesi, Buyat Bay and Aijkwa estuary in Papua) has reached a level that threatens their sustainable capacity in supporting further economic development.

Indonesian seas actually have tremendous economic, socio-cultural, and ecological functions, which are invaluable not only to Indonesia but also to the rest of the world. Indonesia is blessed with abundant and diverse coastal and ocean resources ranging from non-renewable resources such as oil and gas, iron ores, tin, bauxite, gold, copper and other minerals, and renewable resources including fish, marine organisms, mangroves, coral reefs and seaweed. Moreover, Indonesia's coastal and ocean ecosystems have many other roles and functions in people's daily lives and the economic development of the nation including tourism, sea transportation and communication, ports and harbors, maritime industries and services, cooling water for industries, waste assimilation and conservation.

In 2007 the contribution of coastal and ocean development sectors to the Indonesian economy was estimated at $100 billion (one-quarter of GDP), which is much lower than the total potential estimates of US$800 billion annually. Those coastal and ocean sectors represent a significant source of economic and social welfare, supporting directly or indirectly 60 percent of the Indonesian population who currently live in the coastal zone. Preliminary estimates indicate these activities provide employment opportunities for about 16 million people. Thus, if we could boost coastal and ocean development to up to 50 percent of the national GDP, then new employment opportunities for about 15 million people would be created.

Meanwhile, Indonesian seas and oceans determine the dynamic of world's climate including El-Nino, La-Nina, and global warming. Although scientifically still debatable, Indonesian seas and oceans as the center of global marine biodiversity (Coral Triangle) are strongly believed to have a greater sink function of greenhouse gases, particularly CO2.

Indonesia is also uniquely located as the only country on Earth where an exchange of marine life between the Pacific and Indian oceans occurs. Cetacean (whale and dolphin) movements between the tropical Pacific and Indian oceans take place through the passages between the Lesser Sunda Islands, which span over 900 kilometers between the Sunda and Sahul shelves. Skipjacks, tuna and other large pelagic fishes also use the Indonesian marine waters as their spawning grounds, nursery grounds, feeding grounds, and migratory routes from the Pacific Ocean to the Indian Ocean, and vice versa.

The challenge for Indonesia is therefore how to develop coastal and ocean resources on an optimal and sustainable basis for the utmost benefit of the Indonesian people and the world by proportionally achieving economic growth, social equity, ecological sustainability while also managing the impacts of global warming.

As far as marine conservation is concerned, Indonesia has been in the lead by establishing more than 8 million hectares of its territorial waters as MPA (marine protected areas) from 1977 to 2007. Since 2002 it has been planned the MPA will be enlarged to 10 million hectares by the end of 2010, making it the largest of its kind in the world.

If through the WOC, world leaders are fully committed to conserving the "Coral Triangle Ecosystem", the function of Indonesian seas as carbon sinks and the center of global marine biodiversity and gene pools will be strengthened. In return, world nations, especially industrialized countries and neighboring countries, should help Indonesia overcome chronic problems of high unemployment and poverty rates through the transfer of sustainable ocean technology, capacity building, productive investment, combating illegal fishing and trans-boundary environmental destructions, and free and fair international trade.

The writer is professor of coastal and marine resource management at the Bogor Institute of Agriculture.

WOC needs scientific help
Abdul Khalik, The Jakarta Post 11 May 09;

Lack of scientific support may deter representatives and experts from 90 ocean countries from bringing up the significance of oceans in climate change to the UN talks in Copenhagen in December.

Bringing ocean issues to the UN talks is crucial as it will attract global attention and funding from bilateral and multilateral agreements, with developing countries likely to get funding for their adaptation and mitigation programs in dealing with the impacts of climate change, observers say.

Mitigation programs involve taking action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and to enhance sinks aimed at reducing carbon dioxide levels, while adaptation refers to activities and policies to cope with the changing environment.

The conference's declaration draft clearly acknowledges "the crucial role of the ocean in regulating the world's climate. will contribute to both accelerating and dampening the rate of climate change", while also recognizing that marine ecosystems have "significant potential for addressing the adverse impact of climate change, including trough carbon sequestration and carbon storage".

With the ocean's underlining role, participating countries ask the UN secretary-general in the draft declaration to "integrate ocean considerations into the UN's climate change adaptation and mitigation measures, and invite parties of the UN Copenhagen meeting to consider the ocean dimension in the post 2012 framework".

The Copenhagen meeting will discuss a new regime on climate change to replace the Kyoto Protocol, which will expire in 2011.

With mitigation referring mostly to the ability to absorb carbon dioxide, the main contributor to global warming, and special adaptation funds for oceans requiring proof of concrete impacts of climate change on ocean countries, the conference needs solid support from scientific research to win over the UN's influential and developed member states, including the US and the EU.

However, scientists here remain divided over the role of oceans on climate change, with some saying oceans are in reality carbon emitters, rather than carbon sinks.

"We have no conclusive and final research on the role of oceans on climate change. In general, oceans are naturally carbon dioxide emitters," Iwan Eka, an oceanography expert at the Agency for the Assessment and Application of Technology (BPPT), said Sunday.

"With climate temperatures getting higher, more carbon dioxide will be released into the atmosphere."

Maritime Affairs and Fisheries Minister Freddy Numberi has repeatedly said Indonesia's 5.8 million square kilometers of sea could absorb around 245 million tons of carbon dioxide annually.

"It's too soon to conclude, as we are yet to conduct comprehensive research on the relation between climate change and the oceans," Iwan said.

On the sidelines of the WOC and CTI Summit, some 1,500 experts will also hold an international symposium on ocean policies and science and technology to try to reach a consensus on the role of the oceans in climate change.

The Indonesian government says it hopes the symposium will come up with the consensus to support the political decision in the Manado Ocean Declaration, saying it will table the scientific support at the 31st session of the International Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) that runs from Oct. 26 to 29 in Bali.

The IPCC is the world's only authoritative body on scientific climate matters. It was established by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) and the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP), and is currently working on its fifth assessment report, including on the ocean. The report will be complete in 2014.

The IPCC's fourth report has fully convinced the world to unite to address the impacts of climate change.

Saving our ocean
The Jakarta Post 11 May 09;

The first ever World Ocean Conference (WOC) begins today to be followed with the Coral Triangle Initiatives (CTI) on Coral Reefs, Fisheries and Food Security Inaugural Summit in Manado, North Sulawesi. Some 3,500 participants from 120 countries are expected to attend the event.

The government has ensured that all infrastructure in a city previously only known for its Bunaken marine park will be ready for the May 11-15 event. The fact that water covers 72 percent of the world's surface shows the significance of the event.

The WOC will focus on the Manado Ocean Declaration, which calls on those managing adaptation programs to consider the provisions for funding so as to integrate coastal and ocean management into the context of climate change. The declaration also stresses the need to promote the transfer of environmentally sound technologies for oceans from developed countries to developing countries to help the latter mitigate the impacts of climate change.

Indonesia hopes to convince the United Nations to adopt the declaration in the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) meeting in Copenhagen by the end of the year. Indonesia argues the ocean has the ability to absorb carbon and should therefore be included in the UNFCCC. With the country's 5.8 million square kilometers of sea, the water could absorb around 245 million tons of carbon dioxide (CO2) every year.

Besides the WOC, Indonesia and five other countries grouped in the CTI - Malaysia, the Philippines, Papua New Guinea, the Solomon Islands and Timor Leste - will not only talk about preserving coral reefs, but will also discuss the role of the coral triangle as an abundant resource of tuna. If the six countries are able to maintain the coral triangle conditions, they will receive a multi-billion US dollar benefit from the tuna industry.

Food security is another factor of focus at the CTI. Despite abundant resources, the coral triangle faces threats from overfishing and destruction of marine life from pollution and increasing demands for fish and marine resources.

We hope marine experts can contribute their research and ideas to help keep the ocean safe. Our seas have long suffered from mankind's ignorance; it is time to recognize their importance.


Read more!