Sarawak needs coal-fired power plants: Awang Tengah

The Star 27 Jan 10;

KUCHING: Sarawak needs coal-fired power to complement its hydro power generation, especially in the Sarawak Corridor of Renewable Energy (Score), to meet high demand at energy-intensive industries, said Sarawak’s Second Minister for Planning and Resource Management Datuk Awang Tengah Ali Hassan.

In rebuking a claim by Miri-based NGO Borneo Resources Institute that the Sarawak government had classified the mining and exploitation of coal reserves under renewable energy projects, he said: “Yes, we know coal is not a renewable energy.”

“However, with a combination of resources, coal can be used as a source of power to meet demand from energy-intensive industries in the state,” he told reporters after opening Arcardia Apartments built by Lee Onn Construction Sdn Bhd here.

Borneo Resources had challenged the Sarawak government to explain how coal mining could be categorised as renewable energy and included among the projects under the Score initiative.

It was reported that there was 400 million tonnes of coal deposits at Merit Pila in Kapit Division.

Besides the state’s 1,000MW domestic demand for energy, Awang Tengah said that Sarawak needed to increase power supply to woo factories and smelting companies.

He said the RM6bil Bakun Hydroelectric Project was expected to generate 300MW this year and this would be increased to 2,400MW by 2012.

The proposed 900MW Murum dam project, currently under construction and expected to come on stream in 2013, would not generate enough electricity to meet demand from heavy industries, he said.

“When all the development comes in, especially energy intensive industries, we will require a lot of power.

“Some investors are committed, so we need to tally their needs. We are looking at Baleh, Baram and other areas like Limbang and Lawas. We have done the technical studies. When they are implemented depends on Sarawak’s needs,” he said. — Bernama


Read more!

Rich coal vein left untapped in Borneo

Roy Goh, New Straits Times 26 Jan 10;

BALIKPAPAN: This city has one of the richest coal deposits in Borneo but no one has plans to mine it.

"Scrape a little bit of earth and you can find coal," said city planner Dr Suryanto MM, adding that preserving the environment is a bigger priority than earning riches.

This has been the Indonesian government's general direction in the last several years on the issues of environmental protection as well as global warming.

Suryanto said the government had a policy to preserve 52 per cent of the city's 500 sq km land area as forest reserves.

He said this during a dialogue and fact-finding mission from Sabah led by former chief minister Datuk Harris Mohd Salleh at the city's government office here.

Harris, along with a group of entrepreneurs, journalists and representatives from the Sabah Indonesian Consulate are here to learn more about economic opportunities in Kalimantan as well as its policies to help foster better understanding and strengthen relationships.

"With the effects of global warming, I think it is pertinent for us to play our part as the green lung of the world. We need to balance development and the conservation of the environment."

Suryanto said even though there were development projects, strict limits or criteria were set before they were allowed to proceed.

"For instance, we plan to reclaim about 400ha of sea near the city centre to build a coastal road that would ease traffic in the long term. As it is now, we are using coal fired plants to generate electricity."

He said coal used at the plants were brought in from other parts of Kalimantan.

The city had also set international standards of approval for major development projects, he said.


Read more!

No EIA, no coal mining in Kalimantan: Indonesian Ministry

Adianto P. Simamora, The Jakarta Post 26 Jan 10;

To prevent further environmental damage, the government has said it would revoke the licenses of mining firms operating in Kalimantan that do not have environmental impact analysis documents (Amdal).

The State Environment Ministry said it would use its new authority, as stated in the 2009 Environmental Law, which gives the ministry the authority to revoke business permits.

“We have sent a fact-finding team to South Kalimantan to check whether coal mining firms have secured Amdal,” the ministry’s deputy for spatial planning, Hermien Rosita, said Monday.

“The team will also verify if mining firms have complied with the Amdal papers.”

She said the office also planned to send another team to East Kalimantan to assess the coal mining companies operating in the area.

The enforcement of Amdal will help protect ailing environmental conditions across Kalimantan, she said.

“We have long been informed of the poor environmental management of several mining firms in Kalimantan,” Hermien said.

However, she said, as the authority to issue Amdal had been designated to local administrations, the ministry’s authority to intervene had been restricted.

Article 77 of the new environmental law stipulates the environment minister can impose administrative sanctions on business owners and their activities if local administrations intentionally fail to deal with serious environmental violations.

Article 111 stipulates that officials who issue environmental permits without Amdal will be subject to a maximum three years in jail and/or a Rp 3 billion fine.

Kalimantan, the country’s richest province for coal deposits, has long been under pressure to better regulate huge and overlapping licenses awarded to companies to exploit coal.

Nine regents in South Kalimantan province for example, have granted principal permits to 229 mining companies allowing them to mine deposits of coal in 200,000 hectares of the Meratus protected forest.

East Kalimantan only has 19.8 million hectares of land, but regional chiefs have granted overlapping permits, mainly to mining and plantation firms in about 21.7 million hectares.

Activists have said that selling business permits to dig the natural resources had been a common practice to increase the local budget.

The government itself admitted that many companies had no Amdal documents before commencing operation.

The Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi) said that many existing Amdal documents were made through a “copy and paste” system without discussion with local communities about the projects.

Amdal papers are basic documents to determine whether business activities are environmentally feasible in a particular area.

The documents are required for the issuance of business permits. Since the implementation of regional autonomy, local administrations have been authorized to manage natural resources in their area.

A study from the state environment minister showed that only a quarter of the country’s 460 municipal and regency administrations have set up Amdal commissions to issue the document.


Read more!

Indonesia cuts capacity of planned geothermal plants

Muklis Ali Reuters 26 Jan 10;

JAKARTA (Reuters) - Indonesia has cut the planned capacity of geothermal power plants it will start building this year by 18 percent to 3,900 megawatts (MW), an official at the mines and energy ministry said on Tuesday.

Indonesia has established two programmes to increase power generation by 10,000 MW in a bid to resolve chronic power shortages in the country.

One of these "crash programmes" originally had nearly half or 4,733 MW of its power slated to come from geothermal sources across Indonesia.

"After we examined it carefully, we can only build 3,900 MW of the geothermal projects for the second crash programme. We expect those projects to be concluded in 2014," J. Purwono, director general of electricity at the ministry, told reporters.

He said state electricity company PT Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) is expected to build a combined total of 880 MW of geothermal power plants in the second crash programme and the rest are expected to be built by the private sector.

"PLN will build the geothermal power plants and it will buy the steam from geothermal operated by state oil firm Pertamina's unit," he said.

He also said the government may allow PLN to amend an agreement it made with Sarulla geothermal developer on electricity prices from the project.

PLN awarded a contract in 2006 to a consortium of PT Medco Energi Internasional, Ormat Technologies, and Itochu Corp to build a 330-megawatt geothermal power plant in Sarulla, North Sumatra province.

The Sarulla developer asked for an electricity price revision but the talks have stalled in recent years, holding up the project.

"The government has allowed PLN to settle the Sarulla project. But PLN has to ask state audit agency opinion first. If the audit agency say the project is okay then PLN can amend its contract and revise the price," Purwono said.

Indonesia is tapping alternative sources of energy to meet rising power demand and cut consumption of expensive crude oil as its own reserves dwindle.

It also has rising greenhouse gas emissions, but the clean energy source projects are not expected to generate carbon credits. Indonesia has pledged to cut emissions by 26 percent from business as usual levels by 2020.

The vast archipelago, with hundreds of active and extinct volcanoes, has the potential to produce an estimated 27,000 MW of electricity from geothermal sources.

However, that potential remains largely untapped because the high cost of geothermal energy makes the price of electricity generated this way expensive.

PLN has 25,000 MW of generating capacity but daily output is far less because most of its plants are old and inefficient.

(Editing by Neil Chatterjee)


Read more!

Indonesia Readies $1b ‘Green’ Fund to Spur Clean Investments, Reduce Emissions

Jakarta Globe 26 Jan 10;

A planned new national fund to drive infrastructure developments that help cut greenhouse gas emissions will be running this year with $1 billion in it, a Finance Ministry official said on Tuesday.

At global climate talks in Copenhagen last month, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono announced the plan to develop the Indonesia Green Investment Fund, aimed at catalyzing development that could speed economic growth, boost food and clean water production and help cut emissions blamed for global warming.

Indonesia has promised to slash its emissions by at least 26 percent from “business as usual” levels by 2020, but Yudhoyono has also vowed to boost economic growth to 7 percent or more by 2014.

Indonesia’s sovereign wealth fund, the Government Investment Unit, will put $100 million into the fund, with a further $900 million coming from foreign governments including Norway and Australia, as well as institutional investors, said Edward Gustely, a senior Ministry of Finance adviser.

“We’re in the initial stages, but the target is to have this fund operational this year,” Gustely said, adding that it would rival Brazil’s Amazon Fund in size and scope. “There’s no reason why this can’t, in the next five years, scale to $5 billion or more.”

Brazil launched its Amazon Fund in 2008 to promote sustainable development and scientific research in the world’s largest rain forest, with donations from Europe.

Indonesia last year became the first country to launch a legal framework for a UN-backed scheme called Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Degradation, which allows polluters to earn tradeable carbon credits by paying developing nations not to chop down their trees.

The green investment fund will not offer loans or grants but rather top-off funding for projects where a bank lender is seeking an additional cash injection.

“Many technology providers and project sponsors don’t have the balance sheet to fulfill the required equity needed to secure financing,” said Gustely. “We would come in and play a catalyst role to ensure good projects with good asset quality, with good expertise and proper management, can be deployed and proceed.”

Projects like the Indonesia Green Investment Fund are a way for countries to take the initiative on climate change, Gustely said. “This is driven by creating more food, water and energy in a sustainable fashion while trying to achieve Indonesia’s growth objectives,” he said.

Fitrian Ardiansyah, climate change program director for World Wildlife Fund Indonesia, welcomed the fund but said more needed to be done to reduce Indonesia’s greenhouse gas emissions.

“The Indonesian government heavily subsidies fossil fuels, but investment in renewable energy sources is too expensive. The government must help the private sector by making investment in renewable energy sources cheaper, which will address the problem. But at the moment coal plants continue to be built, which does not help,” he said.

Reuters


Read more!

Bulgaria's 'green' energy boom sparks fears

Diana Simeonova Yahoo News 26 Jan 10;

SOFIA (AFP) – Bulgaria is undergoing a boom in the renewable energy sector that experts warn could see an influx of dodgy investment and actually end up doing more harm than good for the environment.

And the government -- the main driver behind the boom -- is taking note.

This month it imposed a half-year moratorium on new "green" energy projects in a bid to sift out those with serious financing and prevent a vital Black Sea bird migration route from being built over with wind farms.

"Too many tickets have been sold for this show," Economy and Energy Minister Traicho Traykov told an investors' forum earlier this month.

"We need to get the sector in order," he said.

The number of "green" energy projects in Bulgaria has exploded from almost nil just a few years ago to a proposed 12,000 megawatts (MW) from wind farms, solar energy parks and small hydropower stations, a government expert said.

That figure is equal to Bulgaria's current installed capacity and would be impossible to handle by the grid.

Experts agree that many of the planned projects will never actually come to fruition due to a lack of funding.

The current boom originates in a European Union-wide agreement under which Bulgaria has said 16 percent of electricity consumption will come from renewable energy sources by 2020 compared with under eight percent now.

The government has ordered the national electricity company and private utilities to connect all green-power capacity to the grid as soon as it is up and running and buy power generated in this way at fixed preferential prices.

With such attractive incentives in place, investors -- many still smarting from the burst bubble in Bulgaria's construction sector -- appear to see the renewable energy sector as a sure-fire return on their money.

Operators have already connected some 350 MW from wind turbines and solar batteries and signed preliminary contracts to connect a further 1,451 MW.

This will practically fill the whole capacity of the network, said Georgy Mikov, executive director of national electricity company NEK.

Moreover, NEK estimates show that about 2,000 MW of green sources would be sufficient for Bulgaria to meet its 16-percent green-power target by 2020.

But the renewable energy producers themselves say no less than 5,000-6,000 MW would be necessary.

The moratorium will give the government time to win approval for a national plan for the development of renewables by 2020, said energy minister Traykov.

The government is particularly keen to reduce harm to the Black Sea Via Pontica bird migration route, a prime spot for the construction of wind parks.

It also seeks to curb wind farm construction in protected nature zones and solar energy park installations on fertile farmland.

The European Commission last year launched an infringement procedure against Bulgaria for allowing wind turbines on the Via Pontica route.

The authorities also want to be able to select the more serious projects with secure financial backing from the mass of applications. One way would be to impose expiry deadlines on construction permits, experts suggested.

If operators know which areas are designated for green-power development, they will be better able to upgrade the grid in that area and connect the new capacities, officials said.

Environmental organisations are supporting the curbs, with Bulgarian group For The Nature and WWF Bulgaria saying in a statement: "We fully support the development of renewable energy but not at the expense of protected territory."


Read more!

Indonesia to hold international Muslim conference on climate change

Antara 26 Jan 10;

Jakarta (ANTARA News) - Indonesia will host an international Moslem conference on climate change, which will be the first of its kind in Bogor, West Java, on March 1-2, 2010, a committee member said.

Ismid Hadad, the head of the steering committee, said in a press conference at Kehati Foundation here on Tuesday that the conference is the following agenda of the Moslem Seven Year Action Plan for Climate Change (M7YAP) declared in Istambul, Turkey, early in June 2009.

Ismid, who is also the head of the advisory board of Kehati said the conference would discuss three issues, namely climate change and actions Moslems in the world could do and the establishment of Moslem Association for Climate Change Action (MACCA) which is aimed at becoming an umbrella organization to accommodate activities and the implementation of the seven year action plan in various countries and Moslem communities in the world.

The third issue is the planned declaration of four green cities in Moslem countries or the Al Khaer City, including Bogor in Indonesia, Madina in Saudi Arabia, Salleh in Morocco and Sanaa in Yemen.

The four cities` development will be monitored for seven years by MACCA.

Ismid said the committee would invite around 150 environment experts, academics and clerics from 30 countries with Moslem population, such as the United Arab Emirates, Brunei Darussalam, Malaysia, India, Africa, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Kuwait, Egypt, Britain and Indonesia.

Fauzi Masud from the forestry ministry said the organizer would also invite several mayors from Moslem countries, such as from Madina, Salleh and Sanaa.

Fachruddin Mangunjaya from the Conservation International Indonesia said the M7YAP had a vision of consolidating funds from Moslems in the world to be contributed to climate change actions.

Among the programs to be carried out by the M7YAP are establishing waqf bodies in the year ahead to implement their climate change plans and develop green Moslem cities in the world.

The conference will be held in cooperation with several private organizations, such as Muhammadiyah, Nahdlatul Ulama, the Indonesian Council of Ulemas, the Kehati Foundation and the Conservation International Indonesia with support from the ministries of forestry, environment, religious affairs and the Bogor city administration, the National Council on Climate Change and the Earth Mate Dialogue Center based in London.


Read more!

Japan sticks to 25 percent carbon cut target

Reuters 26 Jan 10;

TOKYO (Reuters) - Japan has stuck to its offer to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 25 percent by 2020 for a U.N. accord on condition major emitters agree on an ambitious climate deal, a statement from the foreign ministry showed on Tuesday.

The target, based on 1990 levels, was submitted on Tuesday to the U.N. Climate Change Secretariat under a climate accord worked out by major emitters led by China and the United States last month in Copenhagen.

The accord said rich nations should submit by January 31 targets for cuts in emissions by 2020 and for developing nations to outline actions for slowing the rise of emissions to help avert heatwaves, sandstorms, floods and rising sea levels.

"I hope that all countries will submit (a target), but ... what's important in order to cut CO2 and to stop global warming is for the United States and China, the greatest emitters, to submit this," environment minister Sakihito Ozawa was quoted by a ministry official as saying in a news conference.

Japan had hoped to play a big negotiating role at the climate talks in December with its target, so big emitters such as the United States, China and India join a new pact that goes beyond 2012, when the first phase of the Kyoto Protocol ends.

But the Copenhagen talks ended with a weak deal. The meeting failed to adopt the Copenhagen Accord to curb climate change after opposition from Cuba, Venezuela, Bolivia, Nicaragua and Sudan, meaning the conference merely "took note" of the plan.

China, India, Brazil and South Africa promised on Sunday to submit their own climate action plans to the United Nations by January 31.

Experts say the total cuts offered by rich countries at the talks amounted to no more than 18 percent and fall far short of the 25-40 percent U.N. scientists consider necessary to avert dangerous climate change.

(Reporting by Chisa Fujioka and Yoko Kubota; Editing by Jerry Norton)


Read more!

Best of our wild blogs: 26 Jan 10


Coming soon: Singapore's new natural history museum!
from wild shores of singapore

Will there be dolphins at Resorts World Sentosa?
from wild shores of singapore

A head for honey
from The annotated budak and Frills and feathers.

Nature in Singapore: worms transformed and good and bad vines
from Celebrating Singapore's BioDiversity!

Vanishing Finlaysonia: status of a rare mangrove plant
from wild shores of singapore

Common Myna with deformed bill
from Bird Ecology Study Group

Ghost Crab @ Changi 24Jan2010
from sgbeachbum

Paddyfield Pipit taking a sand bath
from Bird Ecology Study Group

Saturday CJ walk with NIE Green Club
from Adventures with the Naked Hermit Crabs

Thu 28 Jan 2010: 12pm @ SZG - Bob Cook (WCS) "Defining the Zoological Conservation Organization of the 21st Century - The Wildlife Conservation Society Model"
from ecotax at Yahoo! Groups


Read more!

Singapore needs to build capabilities in understanding climate change

Hetty Musfirah, Channel NewsAsia 25 Jan 10;

SINGAPORE : Environment and Water Resources Minister Yaacob Ibrahim on Monday said that Singapore needs to build up capabilities in understanding climate change.

This will help the country and the region be better prepared for the impact of climate change and its effect on weather systems.

Dr Yaacob was speaking to experts who are meeting in Singapore for the first time to discuss the impact of typhoons in Asia.

The Asia Pacific Region is one of the most vulnerable areas to natural disasters, and Singapore has been part of a 14-member UN-ESCAP/World Meteorological Organisation Typhoon Committee since 1997.

Last year, more than 300 people died in the path of Typhoon Ketsana when it struck Southeast Asia.

From 1950 to 2005, more than half of the worldwide deaths caused by natural disasters occurred in this region, and many of the deaths were typhoon-related.

Wind storms and floods associated with typhoons accounted for 57 per cent or some US$33 billion of the economic losses in this region in the same period.

Singapore is spared such devastation due to its location, but Dr Yaacob said that there is still a need to be prepared.

Typhoon Vemai, which struck in 2001 for example, brought on heavy rainfall, flash floods and even caused disruption to flights in Singapore.

Dr Yaacob said: "Typhoons are powerful ... and their influence can extend to hundreds and thousands of kilometres beyond, bringing in dry weather in one part and wet weather in another.

"They can significantly affect the regional rainfall patterns. Our climate scientists in MSD (Meteorological Services Division) will therefore collaborate with experts in the region to better understand the relationships between climate change and typhoons."

Singapore's MSD said it plans to hire more climate scientists and take on research.

Foong Chee Leong, director-general, Meteorological Services Division, said: "We have already started work with the US International Research Institute for Climate and Society on how to have short-term weather forecasts.

"So with this short-term weather forecast, we are able to roughly give an estimate in the next three months or six months, what is the average rainfall like.

"This will be very useful for our colleagues in the Public Utilities Board in planning the water resources. So we want to know climate change - will it affect our afternoon showers, whether it will cause the showers to be more intense, and as a result, how it affects our drainage system.

"The meteorological services has all along been focusing on weather services; now we are going to enhance and build capabilities to meet the new challenges of climate change.

"In other words, we have more climate scientists in MSD, so that we can look into short-term weather protection, the most important is long-term prediction, and all these results will help the policy maker in deciding on adaptation measure, how we can better protect our island state from climate change."

Seventy experts in Singapore said they have their work cut out for them, even though the committee has been developing such strategies for over 40 years. As cities get more populated, strategies for evacuation - such as good roads - have become just as important. - CNA/ms


Met Service conducting climate change research
Grace Chua Straits Times 26 Jan 10;

SINGAPORE'S weatherman is going head-on into climate change research.

The Meteorological Services Division, under the National Environment Agency, is working with institutes here and abroad to examine regional climate change, aiming to predict climate patterns more effectively.

Yesterday, Minister for the Environment and Water Resources Yaacob Ibrahim announced that the division will study regional climate change with the Centre for Environmental Sensing and Modelling (Censam), a Singapore-MIT Alliance research institute based at the National University of Singapore.

It is also collaborating with institutes like the British Met Office's Hadley Climate Centre to more reliably predict short- and long-term regional climate, he added. Dr Yaacob was speaking at the opening of a meeting of Asia-Pacific countries this week on typhoon planning and mitigation measures.

The Typhoon Committee, organised by the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific and the World Meteorological Organisation, is being held for the 42nd time, but this is its first time in Singapore.

On the sidelines of the same meeting, Meteorological Services Division director-general Foong Chee Leong said the division needed more climate scientists to study and model the climate. The division has just three officers in its research and development arm, out of a staff strength of about 145, and is looking to double that number to six.

They could be trained locally or overseas, he said.

The reason for boosting climate research: Climate change will affect the weather, Dr Foong said, and more extreme weather events such as typhoons are likely to occur.

Singapore may not be directly affected by typhoons, but it is not spared from their indirect effects on the aviation or shipping industries.

In December 2001, Typhoon Vamei formed near Singapore, producing heavy rainfall here and delaying or diverting 50 flights at Changi Airport.

The study with Censam will last about three years, said the centre's Dr Wang Chien.

It will help climate scientists tell if Singapore and the region will become hotter or wetter, or if it will rain for more days each year, for example.

This will help government planners better prepare for weather events such as the storm that flooded Bukit Timah last year, Dr Wang added.


Singapore part of efforts to tackle typhoon effects
Today Online 26 Jan 10;

Singapore needs to build up its academic capabilities in understanding climate change, and this will help the country - and the region - be better prepared for its impact on weather systems, said Minister for the Environment and Water Resources Yaacob Ibrahim.

He was speaking to experts meeting in Singapore to discuss ways of lessening the impact of typhoons in Asia, such as Ketsana whose rampage across South-east Asia last year left more than 300 dead. Singapore has been part of the 14-member United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific/World Meteorological Organisation Typhoon Committee since 1997. And while the Republic has been spared the devastation due to its location, said Dr Yaacob, there is still a need to be prepared. Typhoon Vemai in 2001, for example, brought on heavy rainfall, flash floods and even caused disruption to flights in Singapore.

Local climate scientists will collaborate with regional experts to better understand the relationships between climate change and typhoons.

Hetty Musfirah


Read more!

Economic growth 'cannot continue'

BBC News 25 Jan 10;

Continuing global economic growth "is not possible" if nations are to tackle climate change, a report by an environmental think-tank has warned.

The New Economics Foundation (Nef) said "unprecedented and probably impossible" carbon reductions would be needed to hold temperature rises below 2C (3.6F).

Scientists say exceeding this limit could lead to dangerous global warming.

"We urgently need to change our economy to live within its environmental budget," said Nef's policy director.

Andrew Simms added: "There is no global, environmental central bank to bail us out if we become ecologically bankrupt."

None of the existing models or policies could "square the circle" of economic growth with climate safety, Nef added.

'No magic bullets'

In the report, Growth Isn't Possible, the authors looked at the main models for climate change and energy use in the global economy.



They then considered whether economic growth could be maintained while "retaining a good likelihood" of limiting the global average temperature to within 2C of pre-industrial levels.

The report concluded that a growth rate of just 3%, the "carbon intensity" of the global economy would need to fall by 95% by 2050 from 2002 levels. This would require an average annual reduction of 6.5%.

However, the authors said that the world's carbon intensity had "flatlined" between 2000 and 2007.

"For each year the target was missed, the necessary improvements would grow higher still," they observed.

The findings also suggested that there was no proven technological advance that would allow "business as usual" to continue.

"Magic bullets - such as carbon capture and storage, nuclear or even geo-engineering - are potentially dangerous distractions from more human-scale solutions," said co-author Victoria Johnson, Nef's lead researcher for the climate change and energy programme.

She added that there was growing support for community-scale projects, such as decentralised energy systems, but support from governments was needed.

"At the moment, magic bullets... are getting much of the funding and political attention, but are missing the targets," Dr Johnson said.

"Our research shows that to prevent runaway climate change, this needs to change."

The report concluded that an economy that respected environmental thresholds, which include biodiversity and the finite availability of natural resources, would be better placed to deliver human well-being in the long run.

Tom Clougherty, executive director of the Adam Smith Institute, a free-market think-thank, said Nef's report exhibited "a complete lack of understanding of economics and, indeed, human development".

"It is precisely this economic growth which will lift the poor out of poverty and improve the environmental standards that really matter to people - like clean air and water - in the process, as it has done throughout human history," he told BBC News.

"There's only one good thing I can say for the Nef's report, and that's that it is honest. Its authors admit that they want us to be poorer and to lead more restricted lives for the sake of their faddish beliefs."


Read more!

Biodiversity: Words Are Not Enough

Stephen Leahy, IPS 25 Jan 10;

PARIS, Jan 25, 2010 (IPS) - Words are not enough to stop the rapidly unraveling web of life, agreed heads of state and international conservation organisations at a high-level meeting that ended here last Friday.

"How can we fund specific actions to stop this?" asked Henri Djombo, minister of sustainable development, forestry economy and environment for the Republic of Congo.

"There is never enough funding, never enough political will, especially in the wealthy countries. So what can we do?" Djombo told about 150 delegates attending a high-level event to launch the International Year of Biodiversity at the Paris headquarters of the U.N. Scientific, Educational and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO).

"Our wealth and well-being is being undermined by not acting," said a clearly frustrated Djombo through a translator.

One reason for inaction is that so few people know what biodiversity is. In the case of France, 75 percent people of surveyed didn't know what it meant, said Chantal Jouanno, France's state secretary for ecology. And what most people want are new roads, not alternative forms of transport, Jouanno said.

"We have forgotten nature is the source of life on our planet, that nature provides the basic infrastructure for all economic activity and for our cultures," said Julia Marton-Lefèvre, director-general of the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

"Imagine if 30 percent of your friends faced extinction and that risk was increasing," Marton-Lefèvre told IPS, referring to the fact that 30 percent of all species are threatened - including 22 percent of all mammals who are our biological 'cousins'.

She also noted that studies have show that at least 60 percent of all ecosystems are degraded and in decline. In making a similar parallel she asks: "What would you do if 60 percent of your farm had become degraded and was getting worse?"

"Life has taken billions of years to evolve and we are part of that, we are enmeshed in it. But we suffer from a lack of understanding of this reality and a peculiar obstinacy," E.O. Wilson, the eminent octogenarian biologist from Harvard University, told delegates.

"It is the little things, microscopic animals like nematodes, that truly run our world," said Wilson, who coined the term biodiversity decades ago.

A single teaspoon of soil may contain a billion bacteria, and perhaps 6,000 different species, and most of those are unknown. However, we do know each has evolved to fit a particular niche and perform a special function but we know almost nothing about those, he said.

"This is the world as it exists. We depend on these... But the great tragedy unfolding presently it is human actions are destroying countless species and ecosystems before we even know they exist," Wilson said.

The species extinction rate is 1,000 times higher than the normal and it's going higher. Without serious action to reduce this, half of all existing species will be gone by 2100, never to exist again. No one knows what that really portends for Earth's life support systems that humans rely on.

The central problem, Wilson said, is how to sustain ourselves on this planet while improving the lives of the world's poorest billion and preserving nature. There is little change for the poor if their environment is devastated, nor can nature survive a billion land-hungry people.

"We know how to do this and we have the resources," he reminded delegates.

For its part, the IUCN has set ambitious new goals to boost protection of existing conservation lands and increase the size of protected areas from the current 12 percent of land to 15 percent by 2015.

Less than one percent of the oceans are presently protected but the dire state of global fish stocks and coral reefs means urgent action is needed to protect 15 percent by 2020, said Marton-Lefèvre.

To truly take significant action to protect nature requires a re-examination of the economic system that perpetuates the drivers of biodiversity loss, said Victoria Tauli-Corpuz, chairperson of the United Nations Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues.

"Market mechanisms don't integrate ecology, culture, fairness, and equity. We need to diagnose the real causes of the extinction crisis - the current economic system," Tauli-Corpuz told IPS.

The present economic system treats nature as something to exploit, she explained. Indigenous peoples use nature too, for food, cutting trees to build their houses, and sometimes to earn money.

However, there is a strong cultural value of "enough" - a balance between real human and community needs and the need to preserve nature.

"In our community [in the Philippines], we have strict rules. If someone cuts a tree, it must be used for themselves, not to be sold, and they have to replant," she said. "These customary laws work and that's why most of the world's remaining forests are in the hands of indigenous peoples."

Wealth in traditional communities is defined by having good relations within the community and with nature, not acquisition of money and material things, she added. Those are the values that protect nature.

"In any place where individual rights predominate, people don't care about nature," Tauli-Corpuz said.

Although coming from a very different perspective, E.O. Wilson has reached a similar conclusion. Protecting nature and helping the world's poorest is "an ethical and spiritual decision".

He offered one last warning to delegates: "In future, each nation will be defined by what it refuses to destroy."


Read more!