Nuclear power plant in Singapore not likely for next 10-20 years: expert

Joanne Chan Channel NewsAsia 2 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE : Singapore is unlikely to have a nuclear power plant for at least the next 10 to 20 years, said one advisor to the local energy sector.

On Monday, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said Singapore needs to diversify its energy sources and is studying the option of nuclear power.

"We're talking about a process here that's decades, not years, if you think about how long it takes to develop these technologies, and ultimately deploy them. I think the watch will go on for probably another 5 or 10 years or longer, before one actually makes a decision," said Peter Schwartz, chairman of Global Business Network.

"And you won't see a nuclear power plant in or around Singapore for at least something in the order of 10 to 20 years or even longer than that," he added.

Schwartz is also a member of the International Advisory Panel on Energy, set up by the Trade and Industry Ministry in 2008 to provide insights on emerging energy trends.

Another option being explored by Singapore is solar power, which has become more cost effective over the years.

Renewable Energy Corporation has chosen Singapore to develop one of the world's largest integrated solar manufacturing plants.

The S$2.6 billion facility will be officially opened by PM Lee on Wednesday. - CNA /ls

No N-power for next 10-20 years, says MTI adviser
But Singapore should start ball rolling, tackling safety and lack of engineers
Lynn Kan Business Times 3 Nov 10;

ALTHOUGH technology is evolving quickly to come up with safer, smaller and more efficient nuclear reactors, Singapore is unlikely to get a nuclear power plant for another 10-20 years, says a member of the Ministry of Trade and Industry's International Advisory Panel on Energy (IAP).

At a news briefing to wrap up the IAP's three- day meeting, the chairman of Global Business Network, Peter Schwartz, said that the 'process of tracking nuclear power technology and developing the capabilities of understanding that technology' will take decades.

As such, he expects 'Singapore will not make a decision about this for about 5-10 years or longer, and you won't see a nuclear power plant in or around Singapore for at least, in the order of 10-20 years or longer than that, because of the time frames involved'.

The consensus among IAP members is that diversifying into nuclear power is not urgent for Singapore, which for now has arranged for sufficient gas supplies to meet its power needs.

But Claude Mandil, former executive director of the International Energy Agency, said that it would be a mistake for Singapore to sit back. 'Things have to be started immediately because they are lengthy processes,' he said. For one, a strong safety culture must be developed, which should be started now if Singapore wants a nuclear power plant by 2020.

'Singapore must hammer out what is needed to make sure and convince the public that nothing serious will happen with a nuclear power plant,' he said. 'That needs quite a culture - and it's not too early to start.'

Mr Mandil also said that Singapore should not passively watch developments in nuclear power. Rather, it should develop skills and R&D so it can participate in these developments.

Another panellist, Lord Ronald Oxburgh, former chairman of the Shell Transport and Trading Company, pointed out that Singapore lacks nuclear engineers. 'Fundamentally, Singapore is going to need nuclear engineers if it wants to think seriously and evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of adding nuclear to the mix,' he said. 'You don't magic up engineers overnight out of the air - they have to be trained, learning safety procedures.'

Mr Mandil said that having a core of nuclear engineers would also help produce solutions best suited to land-scarce Singapore.

'Singapore should wait a little bit to see what is the new kind of reactors, and that's why it should also participate in developing them,' he said. 'If Singapore could improve the safety issues of running a plant - which are already good now - it could even build a plant near the city centre, which would be suitable for Singapore's needs.'


Read more!

'Give cash incentives to boost green car sales'

Manufacturers say this will encourage drivers to make switch
Jessica Cheam Straits Times 3 Nov 10;

LEADING car manufacturers yesterday urged governments, particularly those in Asia, to play a key role in kick-starting the electric vehicle (EV) revolution.

This means giving monetary incentives to encourage consumers to buy these green cars rather than traditional ones that run on fossil fuels.

When the adoption of such vehicles becomes widespread, the incentives can be removed and costs of EVs would have decreased too, said experts at a panel discussion on the opening day of the Clean Energy Expo Asia.

EVs are considered more environmentally friendly as their greenhouse gas emissions are lower, while also addressing the issue of over-dependence on fossil fuels.

French car maker Renault's Asean and Japan area operations manager Arnaud Mourgue said existing markets, such as Singapore's, need to provide significant incentives at the start for EVs to take off.

In Singapore, for example, an EV could be sold to a consumer by next year for about $70,000 to $80,000 - comparable to the price for a conventional mass market car, said Mr Mourgue.

But that is dependent on the authorities relaxing the current tax regime, which would now make an EV cost nearly $200,000 to the average consumer.

Renault is in talks with the Energy Market Authority (EMA) and the Land Transport Authority (LTA) to bring in a fleet of these cars by next year for Singapore's EV pilot project.

Under a current government programme, the Transport Technology Innovation and Development Scheme (Tides), taxes are waived for electric cars, but only for companies and organisations. Private car owners are not included in this test phase.

The LTA has a Green Vehicle Rebate scheme - set up in 2001 - which encourages the take-up of green vehicles. The scheme, which offers a rebate of up to 40 per cent of a car's Open Market Value, will run its course by the end of next year. The authority said yesterday it will review the scheme when the time comes.

But industry experts say more can be done, like allowing schemes similar to Tides to be made available to consumers to get things moving.

'Incentives are a necessity to reach a certain volume to get the economies of scale. After a few years, we won't need those incentives. Infrastructure of the network, mindset of our customers and production efficiency will be there,' said Mr Mourgue.

Managing director David Chou of EV World, which converts existing cars into EVs, agreed.

'Such incentives will help win the consumer over to EVs, and we will see more EVs on the road. Technology improvement will also constantly be bringing the costs down,' he added.


Read more!

No plastic bags in Penang from January

The Star 3 Nov 10;

GEORGE TOWN: Come Jan 1, plastic bags will be practically banned state-wide.

The move – an extension of the current “No Plastic Bag Day” in shopping centres and hypermarkets on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays – means that no plastic bags can be used every day by almost all business sectors.

The ruling will cover all hypermarkets, supermarkets, departmental stores, pharmacies, fast food restaurants, nasi kandar outlets, convenience stores including petrol kiosks and chain stores.

Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng said the move would reduce the state’s carbon footprint.

“Mini markets and sole proprietorship businesses will have to adhere to the ruling on Mondays, Tuesdays and Wednesdays in order to ensure the renewal of their licences.

“Previously, they only had to adhere to the ruling on Mondays,” he said when tabling the 2011 Budget at the state legislative assembly yesterday.

Lim’s two paragraph announcement on the wide-ranging plastic ban was buried inside his 27-page budget speech, apparently catching many by surprise.

To promote the “No Plastic Bag Day” ruling, the state will distribute 500,000 brochures to create public awareness besides erecting educational billboards.

On July 1, last year, Penang became the first state to implement a “No Plastic Bag Day” ruling in shopping complexes and hypermarkets every Monday, before it was extended to Tuesdays and Wednesdays as well from Jan 2.

From July 1, 2009 to Oct 28, a total of 32.5 million plastic bags were saved under this campaign.

Shoppers who did not bring their own reusable bags were charged 20 sen for each plastic bag when making purchases.

The money collected from the sale of plastic bags went to the “Partners Against Poverty” Special Fund to help the state’s hardcore poor.


Read more!

Too risky to ‘experiment’ with transgenic mosquitoes here

The Star 3 Nov 10;

THE Consumers Association of Penang and Sahabat Alam Malaysia are very disturbed by the Government’s approval for the release of genetically-modified (GM) mosquitoes for field testing.

The risk assessment and regulatory experience for GM insects worldwide is still immature. The World Health Organisation is only now developing guidelines for countries to use as the basis for developing their own regulations for the field testing and release of GM insects.

The approval process for the GM mosquitoes will set a precedent for all future field trials and release of genetically-modified organisms in the country.

If the National Biosafety Board and the Biosafety Department does not set the bar high for meaningful public feedback – detailed study of socio-economic and environmental impacts, solid science, risk assessment, risk management, transparency, liability and redress – it will mean a lack of scrutiny for other GM crops, food, feed and processing in the future.

We are against the release of GM organisms as there is still no scientific consensus on their safety and there are many uncertainties related to genetic engineering, making assessment of their risks difficult.

In fact, the International Assessment of Agricultural Science and Technology for Development, endorsed by 58 governments, states: “The impacts of transgenic plants, animals and micro organisms are currently less understood. This situation calls for broad stakeholder participation in decision making as well as more public domain research on potential risks.”

Two court cases in the United States suggest that environmental oversight of genetically engineered crops is grossly insufficient. Likewise, we are concerned that there might be an oversight in the application for the release of GM mosquitoes in Malaysia.

However, as the pubic does not have access to the application dossier, it is impossible to assess whether all issues have been adequately and satisfactorily addressed by the applicant.

There is a dire need for a much wider public debate on the issue of GM mosquitoes than there has been to date, with further means of ensuring meaningful and effective public participation.

All information must be made available to the public, including the location of the specific release sites within Bentong and Alor Gajah districts, given the significance of the proposed experiments.

Malaysia, as a party to the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety and the Convention on Biodiversity, must fulfil its obligations therein to ensure that activities related to these GM mosquitoes are undertaken in a manner that prevents or reduces the risks to biological diversity, taking also into account risks to human health.

Malaysia’s field release experiment is also coming under intense international scrutiny, as this is one of the first such releases of GM mosquitoes in the world.

As there are doubts about the safety of these GM mosquitoes, the precautionary principle must apply. In our view this is best met by the Government withdrawing the approval and not to release the GM mosquitoes in the light of public health and environmental concerns.

S.M. MOHAMED IDRIS,

President,

Consumers’ Association of Penang and Sahabat Alam Malaysia.


Read more!

Third of Sharks, Rays Threatened with Extinction

LiveScience.com Yahoo News 2 Nov 10;

One third of the sharks, rays and skates on Earth are threatened with extinction, according to a new study by the International Union for Conservation of Nature.

The dramatic numbers are part of a larger, comprehensive IUCN study of the state of the planet's vertebrate populations. The study found that roughly one-fifth of vertebrates are threatened. Among those are cartilaginous fishes, a group that includes sharks, rays and skates.

Previously, more localized shark studies indicated that along the U.S. eastern seaboard alone, populations of some shark species have been cut in half, and some have dropped by a staggering 90 percent.

The newly issued reports are based on an ongoing appraisal of the IUCN Red List, the worldwide standard for assessing the conservation status of species. Red List categories run from "least concern" to "near threatened," "vulnerable," "endangered," "critically endangered," "extinct in the wild" and "extinct."

Placement in a category reflects a species' abundance, reproductive rate, geographic range and other such factors.

Jack Musick, emeritus professor at the Virginia Institute of Marine Science, oversaw the Red List assessment of sharks, skates, and rays by an international team of more than 100 experts.

His group's work suggests 345 of the 1,044 species of cartilaginous fishes studied, or 33 percent of them, are "threatened," a broad grouping that includes species in the "vulnerable," "endangered" and "critically endangered" categories.

Musick cautioned that assessing the exact threat level for cartilaginous fishes is made difficult by a large number of species for which there aren't enough data - a reflection of the difficulty and high cost of sampling these underwater creatures.

The assessment shows that threats to cartilaginous fishes (and other vertebrates) occur mainly in the tropics - regions where large numbers of species with relatively confined distributions coincide with intensive fisheries.

To reduce the threat to cartilaginous fishes, Musick and his co-authors call for a number of conservation actions. These include habitat protection, management of harvest and trade, adoption of new law and policy measures, and enhanced awareness and education campaigns.


Read more!

Toxic Chemicals Found Deep At BP Oil Spill Site

Maggie Fox PlanetArk 3 Nov 10;

Toxic chemicals at levels high enough to kill sea animals extended deep underwater soon after the BP oil spill, U.S. researchers reported on Tuesday.

They found evidence of the chemicals as deep as 3,300 feet and as far away as 8 miles in May, and said the spread likely worsened as more oil spilled.

The chemicals, called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons or PAHs, can kill animals right away in high enough concentrations and can cause cancer over time.

"From the time that these observations were made, there was an extensive release of additional oil and dispersants at the site. Therefore, the effects on the deep sea ecosystem may be considerably more severe than supported by the observations reported here," the researchers wrote in the journal Geophysical Research Letters.

The Deepwater Horizon oil drilling rig exploded in April, killing 11 workers and spilling about 4.9 million barrels or 185 million gallons of crude oil.

Terry Wade of Texas A&M University, Steven Lohrenz of the University of Southern Mississippi and Stennis Space Center and colleagues began testing the waters around the spill soon afterwards.

Environmental experts were most worried about the PAHs because they are so toxic, but not much was known about how long they could last in the water or how long it would take them to dissipate.

The initial tests showed they were at high levels very deep under the water, the report shows.

"Based on our findings, subsurface exposure to PAH resulting from the Deepwater Horizon oil release was likely to be associated with acute toxicity effects in discrete depth layers between 1,000 and 1,400 meters in the region southwest of the wellhead site and extending at least as far as 13 km," the research team wrote.

PAHs include a group of compounds, and different types were at different depths, they said.

It is possible they dissipate quickly, but no one has yet showed this, they added.

"Our findings suggest that toxicity effects of the subsurface PAH compounds could have extended at least as far as 13 km from the wellhead site," the researchers said.

In September a team at Oregon State University said they found alarming levels of PAHs in the region, 40 times higher than before the area was affected by the oil spill.

Last week, the Food and Drug Administration and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration said testing had helped confirm that chemicals used to disperse oil from the BP spill have not made their way into fish, crabs, shrimp or oysters from the Gulf of Mexico.

(Editing by Jerry Norton)


Read more!

Best of our wild blogs: 2 Nov 10


3 Nov (Wed): Paul Teng on "Sustaining aquaculture to meet the demand for fish" from ecotax at Yahoo! Groups

Seagrassy Collage by Kevin
from teamseagrass

Roosting of a mixed flock of starlings
from Bird Ecology Study Group

Amazing Anomurans: Global checklists now in the Raffles Bulletin of Zoology from wild shores of singapore


Read more!

Singapore Index on Cities' Biodiversity to measure conservation efforts

Joanne Chan Channel NewsAsia 1 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE : National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan has said the Singapore Index on Cities' Biodiversity aims to be the definitive tool to measure conservation efforts.

The index is the first of its kind for cities to benchmark their efforts and identify areas for improvement.

It uses indicators such as the percentage of protected areas and the strength of governance to determine the city's biodiversity score.

The index was formally endorsed last Saturday at the 10th Conference of Parties (COP) to the Convention on Biological Diversity, held in Nagoya, Japan.

Mr Mah was speaking on Monday at a ground-breaking ceremony of the Gardens by the Bay.

Marina South is now a giant construction site, but that is all set to change by the end of next year.

The first phase of the Gardens by the Bay is scheduled to open in November 2011, including the "Supertrees" or vertical gardens that will be up to 16 storeys tall and Kingfisher Lake.

The Gardens project has faced delays, but is mostly on-track for completion.

Mr Mah said: "The second conservatory ("Cloud Forest") is going to be ready six months later; it will be ready by the middle of 2012.

"The first conservatory ("Flower Dome") will be ready by November/December 2011. So we are doing it in phases because of the delays and some problems in construction."

A ground-breaking ceremony was held on Monday for the Kingfisher Lake - named after the bird species spotted in the area.

Mr Mah said there are hopes that the population of kingfishers will grow once the lake is completed.

Aside from its aesthetic appeal, the lake will also act as a natural filter. Water from the Gardens will run-off into the lake and be cleansed by the aquatic plants before being discharged into the Marina Reservoir.

Japanese company Kikkoman contributed S$1 million towards the development of the lake.

CEO of Kikkoman, Yuzaburo Mogi, said Singapore and the company both recognise the importance of water and it is this shared awareness that led to the donation.

Mr Mogi said: "Kikkoman is very aware of the importance of water. We need water of the highest quality to make soy sauce."

Another conservation effort being pushed forward by Singapore is for more cities to adopt the Singapore Index on Cities' Biodiversity. It has already been test-bedded by over 30 cities.

Mr Mah said: "Seventy European cities are also adopting the concept of the index as part of their own programmes. We have also offered the World Cities Summit as a platform for cities to get together to report on their progress and to prepare for the next COP meeting."

The next World Cities Summit will take place in 2012.

- CNA/al

Related link
Singapore Index on Cities' Biodiversity adopted in Nagoya on the Celebrating Singapore's Biodiversity blog.


Read more!

Gardens by the Bay on track for completion

Mustafa Shafawi Channel NewsAsia 1 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE : Singapore's second botanic gardens, Gardens by the Bay, is on track for completion at the end of next year.

Significant progress has been made since construction started in November 2007.

Its key features - most notably the two dome-shaped Conservatories and the Super trees - are now visible to anyone travelling along the East Coast Parkway.

National Development Minister Mah Bow Tan said the Gardens by the Bay plays a strategic role in Singapore's city in a garden vision.

It will also be a hotbed for biodiversity to flourish, adding to Singapore's urban ecosystem of streetscape greenery, parks, nature reserves and skyrise greenery.

Mr Mah was speaking at the groundbreaking ceremony for KingFisher Lake in the Gardens by the Bay.

Beyond its aesthetic appeal, he said the lake will form part of a sustainable ecosystem.

It acts as a natural filter, capturing run-off water from within the Gardens, cleansing the water, and then releasing it back into the Marina Reservoir.

The lake will over time be a nature habitat teeming with aquatic plants, fishes, dragonflies and birds.

Visitors can learn the value of aquatic plants in nature, and the significance of clean water in sustaining biodiversity.

Japanese company Kikkoman has contributed S$1 million towards the development of the lake. - CNA /ls

Kikkoman donates $1m lake
Soya sauce maker chose project as clean water is key to its trade
Jessica Lim Straits Times 2 Nov 10;

AT FIRST glance, there is little in common between a Japanese soya sauce manufacturing firm and Gardens by the Bay (GB), one of the attractions at Marina Bay.

Dig a little deeper, and there is - in the most prosaic way imaginable. Clean water is an essential component of soya sauce. And GB's lakes help produce just that: water that is filtered and drained into the reservoir to be finally piped into homes and factories.

This is why soya sauce maker Kikkoman Corporation is donating $1 million to GB for the development of Kingfisher Lake, a 5,800 sqm body of water in GB's Bay South garden. The sum - the largest cash donation GB has received - will be used to build features like a mini-waterfall, a lily pool and a spring water system.

Kingfisher Lake captures run-off water from the gardens, filters it through aquatic plants and then discharges clean water into the Marina Reservoir nearby.

The firm's Singapore arm - Kikkoman Singapore - committed the money through the Garden City Fund, a registered charity of the National Parks Board, which runs GB. 'To make high-quality soya sauce, pure and clean water is very important. Gardens by the Bay has some unique and very important water management initiatives using water circulation systems and aquatic plants,' said Kikkoman chief executive Yuzaburo Mogi at a ground-breaking ceremony for Kingfisher Lake on Monday.

He said the firm, which is celebrating its 25th year in Singapore, approached GB after researching possible water-related projects it could sponsor.


Read more!

PM Lee on carbon tax and nuclear power in Singapore

Carbon tax needed if global emission-curbing regime arises: PM Lee
Satish Cheney Channel NewsAsia 1 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE: Singapore will have to apply a carbon price - be it through a carbon tax or a cap and trade scheme - to send the right price signals, if there's a global regime to curb carbon emissions.

This is according to Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong who was speaking at the Singapore Energy Lecture on Monday.

The Ministry of Finance had previously said it would be "more practical" to reduce carbon emissions through taxes because Singapore is a small domestic market with only "a few large energy consumers".

PM Lee said it is not enough to just push for efficiency gains because of the rebound effect.

Consumers would just use more efficient appliances more often, thereby increasing overall consumption.

So, there's a need to impose a charge to induce consumers to change their behaviour.

Mr Lee said this at the Singapore Energy Lecture on Monday.

He said this was part of a four-pronged strategy to prepare itself for the future energy landscape.

"If there's a global regime to curb carbon emissions, that means that Singapore will have to reduce our own emissions more sharply than we are doing now, in order to comply with international obligations, and we would have to make the carbon price explicit to send the right price signals," said PM Lee.

Analysts said it is not easy to figure out how a carbon tax will impact consumers and companies here in Singapore as details are not available for now.

But green activists welcome the idea, saying it will encourage more environmentally-conscious behaviour.

One suggestion is to invest the money collected towards energy research.

Howard Shaw, Executive Director of Singapore Environment Council said: "Currently the energy tariff is a flat figure. So, if you use more, you pay more. Perhaps one way of moving forward from that is to divide households into lower energy users, average energy users and high energy users.

"Basically, the high energy users will be subject to a different higher tariff. So, the more you use, the more you pay in terms of rate."

India, which is Asia's third-largest energy consumer, already has a carbon tax.

In July this year, the Indian government introduced a nationwide carbon tax of 50 rupees per metric tonne of coal both produced and imported into India. Officials expect to raise 25 billion rupees for the financial year 2010-2011 from the tax which they are hoping to use for a clean energy fund.

Countries like Japan and South Korea are considering implementing a carbon tax.

Meanwhile, Mr Lee says there are many uncertainties surrounding the energy climate.

So Singapore is diversifying its energy supplies as well as investing in energy research.

The prime minister noted that several Southeast Asian countries are planning to build nuclear power plants.

Given its small size, safety is a major concern for Singapore.

At the same time, he said the nuclear energy option could not be totally dismissed.

"There is often strong resistance in countries - from the green movement, from populations who have witnessed accidents like Chernobyl, and are fearful and anxious about their safety. But if we look at this rationally, without nuclear energy, the world cannot make sufficient progress in dealing with global warming," said Mr Lee.

He added it would be a long time before Singapore takes any decision on nuclear energy, but it should ready itself to do so.

-CNA/wk/ls

Making the right energy choice
The way forward is to impose a charge, says Prime Minister Lee
Teo Xuanwei Today Online 2 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE - By his reckoning, the United Nations climate change talks in Cancun this month will not yield an agreement. But if a global treaty is reached to curb carbon emissions, Singapore will have to apply a "carbon price", said Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

Speaking at the Singapore Energy Lecture yesterday, Mr Lee pointed out that sending the "right price signals" is part of its key strategies for the future energy landscape.

The way forward, said Mr Lee, is to get consumers to "make the right choices" by imposing a charge - through a tax system or cap-and-trade scheme.

Said Mr Lee: "At present, we don't have a carbon tax, but we calculate a shadow price for carbon in our cost-benefit analysis so that Government policies and decision making can be better-informed and rational."

"If there's a global regime to curb carbon emissions, and that means Singapore will have to reduce our own emissions more sharply than we're doing now in order to comply with international obligations, then we'll have to make the carbon price explicit to send the right price signals."

Mr Lee said Singapore is investing in industry research and development, developing infrastructure, diversifying energy supplies and keeping options - including nuclear power - open.

While Singapore uses market forces in the energy sector as far as possible, a competitive industry and more energy-efficient technologies may not be sufficient, he said.

The Finance Ministry had previously said it would be "more practical" to reduce carbon emissions here through taxes because Singapore is a small domestic market with only "a few large energy consumers".

The Economic Strategies Committee had also recommended the Government price energy to reflect its "total cost", including energy security and environmental sustainability.

Industry experts whom MediaCorp spoke to yesterday said carbon pricing here is "inevitable at a certain point",

Said Cuscaden Investments director David Hoe: "For those who believe that climate change is caused by an increase in carbon, the only way for rational economic behaviour is to put a price on the intangible long-term losses in the environment."

Although determining the "real price" of carbon is tricky and has implications on individuals and the economy, it is the only way to focus everybody's minds on energy efficiency, added Mr Hoe, who expects the move to happen within five years.

KEEPING NUCLEAR ENERGY OPTION OPEN

Mr Lee also reiterated the need to diversify energy supplies to "protect ourselves against supply disruptions and price fluctuations".

Singapore is building a liquefied natural gas terminal, which will be ready by 2013, instead of relying on piped natural gas from its neighbours. Other possibilities include coal and importing electricity from nearby sources.

One more "big solution" is nuclear power, said Mr Lee, who acknowledged it was "very difficult to do" and "not something we can likely undertake".

An obvious obstacle is opposition due to safety fears. "If we even build one, it'll be very difficult to put it far from population," he said.

But Singapore "can't afford to dismiss the option of nuclear energy altogether". Said Mr Lee: "If we look at this rationally, the world can't make sufficient progress in dealing with global warming without nuclear energy."

He cited the example of Germany, where despite "tremendous opposition" and a previous commitment, the government extended their nuclear plants beyond 2020. Mr Lee also noted that the United States may build new plants for the first time in 30 years.

It may take Singapore "a long time", but it is important to keep up with new developments and give the country "the ability to exercise the option, should it one day become necessary and feasible".

Asked during the Q&A session if this might happen during his administration, Mr Lee said: "I would say possibly during my lifetime."

Safety a major concern but nuclear power can't be dismissed
Singapore should have ability to exercise option should it be necessary one day
Joyce Hooi Business Times 2 Nov 10;

(SINGAPORE) While a nuclear power plant in Singapore is not just around the corner, it is certainly on the horizon.

When pressed for a timeframe on how soon there might be one on the island at the Singapore Energy Lecture yesterday, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said: 'Possibly during my lifetime.'

It is, however, 'not very soon', he added.

In his lecture at the event that was part of Singapore International Energy Week, Mr Lee said that Singapore's small size would be a challenge, in addition to the existing concerns about safety, nuclear waste disposal and the challenges faced by developing countries in building nuclear power plants.

'Safety is a major concern, because of our high urban density . . . and yet we cannot afford to dismiss the option of nuclear power altogether,' he told the audience.

'So we keep up with new developments, the technologies are advancing - smaller, safer reactors, with more fuel-efficient designs that reduce the amount of nuclear waste produced and we keep up with experiences in other countries.'

He said that it would be a long time before any decision is made on nuclear energy.

But, Singapore should be ready to do so. It should have the ability to exercise such an option, 'should it one day become necessary and feasible'.

Singapore will have to start building up its capabilities now by consulting specialists and training its engineers and scientists to assess the developments in nuclear energy, he said.

'Without nuclear energy, the world cannot make sufficient progress in dealing with global warming,' he said.

In the region, other countries have taken the plunge. Russia will be helping to build Vietnam's first nuclear plant, while Malaysia has approved construction of one.

Indonesia's House of Representatives have also approved the government's plans to build nuclear plants.

Mr Lee also emphasised the need to factor carbon into the price of energy if a global commitment to cut carbon emissions is reached.

'If there is a global regime to curb carbon emissions, and Singapore has to reduce (carbon) emissions more sharply to comply with our international obligations, then we will have to make the carbon price explicit to send the right price signals.'

If carbon were to be priced into energy use, it would apply to both the industry and consumers, he said.

In his speech yesterday, Mr Lee spoke about four key strategies to cope with the changing landscape of energy - promoting competitive markets, diversifying energy supplies, building robust infrastructure and investing in energy research and innovation.

Government preparing for nuclear power option
We need to be ready when time comes for us to make a decision: PM
Rachel Chang Straits Times 2 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE will start now to prepare for the day when nuclear energy is necessary and feasible.

That day may not be that far off, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said yesterday at a dialogue at an annual Singapore energy conference.

When asked by moderator Sri Jegarajah from broadcasting station CNBC whether it would be during his time in office, he said to laughter: 'I would say possibly during my lifetime.'

Earlier, PM Lee, in a 45-minute address, gave the clearest indication yet that nuclear power is increasingly an option being scrutinised by the Government.

Identifying nuclear power as an 'important part of the solution to mankind's energy problems', he said Singapore is building up its capabilities now because the nuclear option is one it 'cannot afford to dismiss'.

Measures taken will include getting in touch with nuclear experts as well as training local engineers and scientists, the Prime Minister said.

The Ministry of Trade and Industry is currently in the midst of doing a feasibility study on having nuclear power here.

'It will be a long time before we make any decision on nuclear energy,' he said. 'But we should get ourselves ready to get ready to do so. That means to give Singapore the ability to exercise the option should it one day become necessary and feasible.'

PM Lee's keynote lecture at the Singapore International Energy Week was attended by 800 businessmen, policymakers and analysts from across the globe.

The conference, which ends on Thursday, offers a variety of sessions on topics ranging from power generation and energy security to carbon trading.

In his address, PM Lee dwelt on the future energy challenges facing the world and Singapore's energy strategy.

This includes diversifying the country's energy supplies, as well as introducing measures to influence Singaporeans to adopt a more energy-saving lifestyle.

His lecture comes a month before the United Nations global conference on climate change in Mexico and amid an uncertain world where government leaders, he said, are grappling with such questions as: 'Will future energy prices rise significantly? What will be the global regime on climate change? What new technologies will emerge?'

But PM Lee made it clear that Singapore would put a price on carbon, should a legally binding global agreement to curb carbon emissions be reached.

He did not specify whether this carbon price, which all consumers and businesses must pay, would be in the form of a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade scheme.

But he revealed the Government has already calculated a 'shadow price for carbon' which it uses in policy-making.

PM Lee's comments on nuclear energy come in the wake of a building momentum in the region and around the world in favour of nuclear power.

Where once governments promised to retire reactors to placate populations fearful of disasters such as the one in Chernobyl, Ukraine, in 1986, the looming urgency of finding alternatives to fossil fuels has refocused minds.

He cited Germany's 17 nuclear reactors as an example. Scheduled to shut down by 2020, its Bundestag, or Parliament, has extended their use by 12 years on average despite widespread objection.

Closer to home, South-east Asian countries such as Vietnam, Thailand and Malaysia have plans to build reactors.

But before embarking on them, developing countries must first build up a strong safety culture, among other things, he said.

For highly urban Singapore, its small size poses an extra challenge, he added.

'If we ever build (a nuclear plant), it's very hard to put it far from population because nowhere in Singapore is far from population,' he said.

'But we cannot afford to dismiss the option of nuclear power altogether.'

He expressed the hope that technological advances to make nuclear reactors smaller, safer and less waste-emitting would one day make them feasible here.

'If we look at this rationally, without nuclear energy, the world cannot make sufficient progress in dealing with global warming,' he stressed.

Nanyang Technological University Assistant Professor Chang Youngho said building up local capabilities was a step in the right direction: 'We need to train local people who can design nuclear plants for the local context.'

A price on carbon if climate pact is inked
PM Lee says this will send right message to consumers, businesses
Jessica Cheam Straits Times 2 Nov 10;

SINGAPORE will have to put a price on carbon to send the right message to consumers and businesses if all countries pledge to curb greenhouse gas emissions, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said yesterday.

This could be in the form of a carbon tax which would translate to higher energy costs, or through 'cap and trade', a form of carbon trading that rewards those who save energy and makes polluters pay for their emissions.

It is not enough for Singapore to 'just push for (energy) efficiency gains', he said, because energy consumption can still increase when consumers use energy-efficient appliances such as air-conditioners more often.

Hence the need to charge people to change their behaviour, he said yesterday at the annual Singapore Energy Lecture held at Suntec City as part of Singapore International Energy Week.

This is the first time Singapore has explicitly declared it will impose a carbon price if a global deal on climate change is reached.

Mr Lee's comments to an 800-strong audience come a few weeks before the United Nations climate change meeting in Cancun, Mexico where governments across the globe will meet to negotiate a global climate treaty.

In a changing energy landscape, Singapore's challenge will be to find energy that is cost-competitive, secure, and clean and sustainable.

To that end, it has invested in beefing up knowledge and capabilities in different types of energy such as nu-clear and solar to give the country more options in the future.

It is also diversifying its energy supplies, such as by importing liquefied natural gas (LNG) and building an LNG terminal by 2013.

Other strategies include building a robust electricity grid and gas infrastructure and promoting a competitive market. Singapore, for instance, is the first country in Asia to liberalise its electricity and gas markets.

Some of these strategies were part of the recommendations in an Economic Strategies Committee report released in February.

Singapore does not have a carbon tax now, but Mr Lee said the Government has calculated a 'shadow price for carbon' to help it formulate policies.

He did not elaborate on what this price is, but the current price of a UN-approved carbon credit is between ? 12 (S$22) and ? 15 a tonne.

'If there is a global regime to curb carbon emissions... then we will have to make the carbon price explicit to send the right price signals,' he said.

Speaking at the sidelines of the event yesterday, Energy Market Authority chief executive Lawrence Wong said details of the carbon price and how it will be implemented are 'still being studied'.

Countries like New Zealand have just established a cap-and-trade system and many European countries such as Germany and Switzerland have carbon taxes.

Singapore had previously committed to reducing its emissions by 16 per cent below business-as-usual (BAU) levels by 2020 if a legally binding climate change deal is finally reached.

Its current plan, without any deal, is to reduce by about 7 to 11 per cent below BAU levels by 2020.

Commenting on a question from the audience about the upcoming negotiations in Cancun, Mr Lee said he does not think there will be a 'grand agreement', but it was important to keep the conversation going.

'It's not something you can solve with one international negotiation... we hope cumulatively (to) make progress in time so we don't have sudden catastrophic change in the global climate,' he said.

Carbon pricing system still being studied
Jessica Cheam & Grace Chua Straits Times 2 Nov 10;

IT IS only a matter of time before Singapore introduces a carbon pricing system, and consumers and businesses will be charged for the carbon emissions tagged to their goods and services.

That was the view of environmentalists and those from the energy sector, after Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said yesterday that the country would impose carbon pricing if a global agreement on curbing carbon emissions was reached.

Asked to elaborate on the pricing system and who it would affect, Energy Market Authority chief executive Lawrence Wong said: 'The concept is clear enough that you have a carbon price which applies to all, not just one group of consumers, but residential and industrial consumers.

'All have to pay a carbon price.'

The authority is studying the method that Singapore should adopt: a carbon tax or a cap on carbon emissions and trading of allowances.

Industry leaders such as chief executive Edwin Khew of IUT Global, a waste-to-energy firm, said that while companies here had started to look at reducing their operational costs - a large part of which was energy - some small and medium-sized enterprises had not fully considered the impact of higher energy costs.

'If the carbon tax kicks in, these companies will be scrambling,' said Mr Khew, who is also chairman of the Sustainable Energy Association of Singapore.

So, will a carbon tax or a cap-and-trade system work better for Singapore?

Credit Suisse's Asian chief economist Joseph Tan said it could be a combination of both. 'The concept of a carbon price, while established in Europe, is new to Asia,' he noted.

Of the two, he felt that a carbon tax would be easier to implement in the short run.

'A carbon tax is much easier to understand first,' he added.

When consumers and businesses are more familiar with carbon prices, then a cap and trade system could be implemented.

Singapore's position in the region could served it well as a carbon trading hub, Mr Tan pointed out.

'Carbon trading will allow more market participation as businesses will need to buy and sell. Relying on market prices will also be an efficient way of allocating resources,' he added.

Having a carbon pricing system would also make people think twice about buying energy-guzzling products, said Mr Howard Shaw, executive director of the Singapore Environment Council.

He pointed out that a carbon price of sorts already existed, in the form of higher road tax and certificate of entitlement prices for cars with larger engines.

But Mr Shaw also wanted to know what the revenue from a carbon tax would be used for.

'Will it go back into government reserves or will it actually be directed into the implementation of clean and renewable energy resources in Singapore?' he asked.

The latter was necessary, he said, to shift towards a clean-energy economy.


Read more!

Singapore gencos looking at power import, coal gasification

Ronnie Lim Business Times 2 Nov 10;

YTL-owned PowerSeraya is interested in commercially importing Malaysian electricity into Singapore sooner than the government's suggested medium-term 2018 target, while China Huaneng-owned Tuas Power is looking into the possibility of coal gasification to produce electricity.

The heads of the two big Singapore gencos told BT this on the sidelines of the Singapore Energy Summit yesterday when asked about the Republic's plan to allow the gencos to use these options as a way to help them diversify from their 80 per cent dependence on piped Indonesian and Malaysian gas.

Right now, Singapore's diversification strategy is to complete the $1.5 billion LNG terminal, with the first liquefied natural gas arriving here in 2013.

'Singapore could consider allowing electricity imports before this,' said John Ng, chief executive of PowerSeraya, adding that it has broached this with regulator Energy Market Authority.

The Republic can immediately import some 200 megawatts from Malaysia through two 230kV submarine cables at Senoko which currently connect the two countries.

It had previously indicated that it would allow foreign power imports of up to 600MW, or about 10 per cent of peak demand here.

YTL, as far back as 1997, was interested in supplying electricity to Singapore, and will need to build its own connections to the Republic if it wants to supply more than 200MW, Mr Ng said.

But the regulator will need to set up a structure first to allow for such electricity imports, he added.

Other issues include getting Tenaga's nod, plus recognising the fact that Malaysian gas feedstock is subsidised.

There will also be need for clarification by EMA whether such imports will count as part of the genco's licensed capacity.

Separately, Tuas Power's president and CEO Lim Kong Puay told BT that it was starting to look at coal gasification here, but that it will also study whether the market can support more capacity, given the new plants planned by a number of gencos.

A coal gasification project will be about 30 per cent more expensive than a combined cycle gas firing plant, he added.

Tuas has already embarked on the coal route, but on a smaller scale, through its $2 billion clean coal/biomass multi-utilities project on Jurong Island, which will provide an additional 102MW of electricity.

Following the Economic Strategies Committee's recommendations, EMA has just set out in its Statement of Opportunities 2010 report that it was prepared to allow coal use and electricity imports in the medium-term - once LNG imports reach three million tonnes per annum or by 2018, whichever is earlier.

Citing these two diversification options in his Singapore Energy Lecture yesterday, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said that Singapore gencos should be encouraged to pursue these options commercially.

New technologies like gasification plants are reducing the impact on environment as they can create synthetic gas from coal, and they also have the potential to generate cost-effective baseload electricity in the future, he said.

'The EMA will create an open and flexible framework for diversification to take place on a market basis,' he added.


Read more!

Singapore's coal-firing plant seems in good hands

Huaneng's Yuhuan plant is spotlessly clean, and lessons learnt there will find their way here
Ronnie Lim Business Times 2 Nov 10;

CLEAN coal - which Tuas Power will use as a feedstock at its upcoming $2 billion clean coal/biomass Tuas Multi-Utilities Complex (TMUC) on Jurong Island - seems an oxymoron. But given technology such as ultra-supercritical coal-firing plants, as well as carbon-capture facilities being developed by its new owner, China Huaneng, Singapore's first coal-firing station coming on stream in 2012 seems in good hands, regarding environment issues.

Dispelling preconceptions of choking fumes and soot spewing from its chimney stacks, Huaneng's Yuhuan coal-firing plant, which our group of Singapore journalists visited, is spotlessly clean. Enhancing its 'green-ness', the plant, along the south-east coast of Zhejiang, is nestled amid rice and vegetable fields with 'bei shan, mian hai' - or mountains behind and the sea in front - which is considered good Feng Shui.

More critically, pardon the pun, Yuhuan's ultra-supercritical power plant has boilers which can operate at higher temperatures and have greater thermal efficiency, therefore it uses less coal to produce the electricity. The plant is considered one of the cleanest, most efficient and advanced worldwide.

With 4,000-megawatt (MW) capacity, the Yuhuan station is also Huaneng's biggest. It is 50 per cent bigger than the 2,670MW Tuas Power (TP), which Huaneng acquired from Temasek Holdings for $4.2 billion in 2008, and about a fifth larger than Singapore's largest genco, the 3,300MW Senoko Energy.

Capitalising on its superior efficiency, the Yuhuan facility is also Huaneng's biggest electricity generator of all its power plants in China. Yuhuan produced a whopping 16.9 billion kilowatt hours of electricity in the first three quarters of this year, or almost 9 per cent of Huaneng's total output in that period, latest figures show.

Yuhuan is an integral part of Huaneng's 'green action' drive to cut its greenhouse emissions, which is important given that 85 per cent of the group's power stations are coal-firing. It has also embarked on developing energy alternatives such as wind, solar and biomass. A Huaneng official says: 'We have an aggressive plan to produce about 35 per cent of our electricity from clean energy by 2020.'

On the coal-firing front, Huaneng is working hard to reduce its carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by developing technology such as the ultra-supercritical plants employed at Yuhuan, and also through carbon-capture pilot projects like its Shidongku 2 station, just outside Shanghai.

TP's TMUC project, which was based on Japanese technology, was already at an advanced development stage when Huaneng first came into the picture. Nevertheless, the new Chinese owner has not shied from getting involved.

'Huaneng has extensive experience which TP can tap as it develops the Tembusu project,' a Huaneng official said.

For instance, Huaneng is getting Chinese manufacturers, including boiler makers, involved in TMUC, 'as costs are lower than in Japan', one official said. Tapping its connections, it is also sourcing low-ash coal from South-east Asia for the project. TP's Singapore engineers have also been to the Chinese coal plants, such as at Shidongku, to learn how Huaneng handles its coal.

At Yuhuan, for example, barges unload coal at the plant's jetty from which it is transported via a fully enclosed conveyor system to covered storage silos before use.

'This is exactly what we will do in Tuas as well,' remarks a TP official. Additionally, TMUC's use of carbon-neutral biomass feedstock, such as palm kernel, will help reduce the plant's emissions to a level comparable with those of oil-fired plants.

Yuhuan has China's first 1,000MW ultra-supercritical pressure boilers which, by operating at 600° Celsius steam temperatures, result in a net thermal efficiency of around 46 per cent, or 6 per cent more than the earlier-generation supercritical plants.

'This also means that we burn about 6 per cent less coal to produce the same electricity output,' said a Yuhuan official, adding that the station is planning to add another two super-ultracritical plants to the existing four, with each 'possibly even going up to 1,200MW capacity'.

Parallel to this, at its 2,400MW Shidongku 2 station on Shanghai's outskirts, Huaneng has developed a pilot facility for carbon capture (that is, CC without the S, as in storage), with its 100,000 tonnes per annum CC plant there currently the largest in the world. This was an expansion of its first Beijing CC pilot plant, which captures just 3,000 tonnes of CO2 per annum.

'Beijing and Shanghai were chosen for the carbon-capture pilot plants as they were the most polluted cities,' said Chen Xi, a director at TP's Beijing office.

Still, with most of China's coal plants still focusing on desulphurisation processes, CO2 capture is still relatively new, admits Cao Xuegao, Shidongku's vice-plant manager.

The 150 million yuan (S$29 million) Shidongku CC plant occupies an area of 6,000 square metres and is divided into carbon-capture and refining sections, with the latter processing the carbon into 99.5 per cent pure CO2 for sale to the food and beverage industry (to produce carbonated drinks, for example).

But the CC pilot plant - which barely captures 2 per cent of the CO2 produced by the Shindongku 2 power station - is not commercially viable yet, concedes Mr Cao.

It is a costly process with the carbon capture costing about 300-350 yuan per tonne. But as the CC plant has been barely operational for 10 months, 'we are looking to just break even and not make profits at this stage', he adds.

Huaneng is now working with Xian Thermal Research Institute on how to optimise the CC process to try to further lower costs, he says. This will likely involve a combination of a scaling-up in capacity as well as through technology advances.

'The Beijing and Shidongku CC pilot projects will provide the basis for the study of large-scale CO2 capture and geological storage technologies,' Mr Cao says.

Still, given that carbon capture is still a work-in-progress and not commercially viable yet, it is unlikely that Huaneng will be able to introduce the technology at its Singapore TMUC project for a while yet. Undoubtedly, however, lessons learnt will eventually find their way here.


Read more!