Row over China tiger photo 'fakes'

Michael Bristow, BBC News 5 Dec 07;

Photographs supposedly showing a rare South China tiger in the wild have sparked a controversy that at times has bordered on the farcical.

The saga has involved Chinese wildlife experts, government officials, internet users and an influential US magazine.

They have all been drawn into a row over whether the sub-species of tiger still exists in the wilds of China's Shaanxi province.

To resolve the debate, the Chinese government has now dispatched a team of experts to search for more evidence.

The drama began in October when Chinese farmer Zhou Zhenglong supposedly snapped the tiger in the forested mountains of Zhenping County.

According to state news reports, Mr Zhou took 71 photographs on two cameras, one digital, the other using film.


Only one shot was publicly released, but it was immediately hailed as proof that the South China Tiger is not extinct in the wild.

That claim was given credence when the US magazine Science published the photograph and an accompanying article about the row.

Other media organisations, including the BBC, also reported the story.

But critics were almost as quick off the mark, suggesting the photograph had been digitally altered and was a fake.

It did not help matters that farmer Zhou, a former hunter, was reported to be asking for 500,000 yuan ($68,000, £33,000) for the photographs.

'Flourescent' fur

Debate raged over the internet as both experts and laymen pointed out flaws in the photograph, which shows a tiger crouched in green undergrowth.

The more knowledgeable talked about how tigers are solitary, vigilant animals that are notoriously difficult to spot, let along photograph, in the wild.

Others could not believe the tiger's fluorescent-looking fur belonged to a real animal.

One internet user even posted a picture on the web showing the similarities between the Shaanxi tiger and one on a New Year calendar that hung in his home.

The debate seemed to be resolved when the China Photographers Society joined the growing band of doubters and declared the picture fake.

But some Chinese government officials are still clinging to the possibility that the photographs are real.

At a press conference, State Forestry Administration spokesman Cao Qingyao said an investigation had been launched to settle the matter.

A 10-strong team will scour an area covering 200,000 hectares searching for black bears, leopards and, of course, the South China Tiger.

Mr Cao said he was keeping an open mind about what they would find, according to state media.

"Whether the tiger on the photo is real or not, it's still difficult to evaluate the situation of the tigers at large in the area," he said.

Mythical creature?

The last wild South China tiger sighting in the country was recorded in 1964, and if they do still exist in the wild experts say their numbers do not exceed 30.

There are only about 60 in captivity, including one born in a wildlife reserve in South Africa last month - the first to be born outside China.

But the tiger debate has now become more than just a row about the survival of one of the world's most endangered animals.

It has become a discussion about conserving China's wildlife in the face of rampant economic development, and about telling the truth.

For some, it also appears to be about creating a myth.

One Shaanxi forestry official recently mentioned the tiger in the same breath as Scotland's Loch Ness Monster.

China wildlife office sued over "paper tiger" saga
Reuters 10 Dec 07;

BEIJING (Reuters) - A legal scholar has sued China's top wildlife authority for not getting involved in a national controversy over a farmer's "snapshots" of a wild tiger believed to be extinct, a newspaper said on Tuesday.

In October, Zhou Zhenglong, from mountainous Zhenping county in the northern province of Shaanxi, produced photographs of the tiger he said were taken in the forest near his village.

A local forestry authority said the photographs were proof that the South China tiger, belonging to a subspecies long feared extinct, still existed in the wild.

But Internet users have accused Zhou of making the tiger images with digital software, and local authorities of approving the photographs to bolster tourism.

China's top wildlife office, the State Forestry Administration, has drawn fire for sponsoring a so far fruitless search for the tiger, and for refusing to rule on the veracity of the photographs which experts have lined up to dismiss as fakes.

Hao Jingsong decided to sue the wildlife office after it turned down his demands to appoint a "professional organization" to verify the photographs, according to Tuesday's Procuratorial Daily, an official paper of China's top prosecutors' office.

"The (administration) sent a group of experts to Zhenping to conduct investigations into the tiger, without first verifying that the photographs were real," the paper quoted Hao as saying.

"This is irresponsible behavior," said Hao, adding that the suit was a "call for official credibility."

The suit would be registered by the Beijing Second Intermediate People's Court within a week, the paper said, citing a court official.

The South China tiger debate has captivated local media and Internet users in China, and has intensified in recent weeks following the emergence of a Chinese New Year commemorative poster whose image of a tiger bears a striking resemblance to the one in Zhou's pictures.

Earlier this month, a panel of photography, zoology and botany experts that analyzed Zhou's pictures out of a "sense of social responsibility," unanimously dismissed his tiger as faked.

RELATED ARTICLES

Public anger rising over tiger photo fiasco
Their trust in the authorities shaken by refusal to verify authenticity of photo
Sim Chi Yin, Straits Times 5 Dec 07;

Rare Chinese tiger spotted for first time in decades
Yahoo News 12 Oct 07