Indonesia plays down mining threat to forests

Reuters 18 Mar 08;

JAKARTA (Reuters) - An Indonesian decree allowing mining companies to operate in tropical forests is unlikely to lead to massive deforestation, a forestry expert and government officials said on Tuesday arguing that mining had a limited impact.

Under a presidential decree issued on February 4, mining firms, including open-pit miners, will be able to pay between 1.8 million and 2.4 million rupiah ($200-$265) per hectare (2.5 acres) for forest land used for activities such as housing, roads, mine sites and waste dumps.

The decree has alarmed environmental groups concerned about Indonesia's rapid deforestation.

The country had the fastest pace of deforestation in the world between 2000-2005, according to Greenpeace, with an area of forest equivalent to 300 soccer pitches destroyed every hour.

Krystof Obidzinski, a researcher with the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), said historically mining had never been a significant contributor to deforestation.

"Definitely there's a danger and it's regrettable but on the overall schemes of things, as far as deforestation per se, we think it's not a major concern," he told a panel discussion on deforestation with foreign correspondents.

The decree applies to 13 mining firms that four years ago were allowed to resume operations in forest areas -- including Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold which operates the massive Grasberg mine in Indonesia's remote Papua province.

Obidzinski said the new regulation was driven by a need to reinvigorate mining sector investment, a key tax contributor, as well as the need of the forestry ministry to recoup income lost due to a decline in other forest activities.

Bowo Satmoko, a senior official of the forestry ministry, said so far only three mining companies had been given the go ahead to exploit forest areas.

"The others are still proposing exploration," he said.

He said that mining permits were confined only to the 13 firms, although an official at the energy and mines ministry told Reuters last week that companies which had mining permits before a forestry law was issued in 1999 could also be eligible.

Another forestry ministry official, Syaiful Anwar, said the bar would be set high for companies operating in forests.

"For companies to be able to operate there's a procedure and it is a tough procedure," he told reporters.

A leading domestic environmental group, Walhi, has collected donations from hundreds of people to buy up more than 3 million square meters (32 million sq ft) of protected forest to prevent mining companies being allowed to operate there.

Indonesia's forestry law issued in 1999 prohibited open-pit mining in protected forest areas. But in 2004, the country's fourth president, Megawati Sukarnoputri, issued a decree to allow the companies to resume operations in protected areas.

(Reporting by Ahmad Pathoni, Editing by Ed Davies and Sanjeev Miglani)

Related articles

Indonesia may allow more mining in forest areas
Reuters 14 Mar 08;

Outcry over cheap rents for forests in Indonesia
Govt is offering mining companies land to collect rent for state coffers
Salim Osman, Straits Times 7 Mar 08;

More protected Indonesian forests up for grabs
Ika Krismantari, The Jakarta Post 1 Mar 08;