SeaWorld trainer’s death: What exactly happened? Will we ever know?

ABC, CBS, Good Morning America, Orlando Sentinel 25 Feb 10;

The death of SeaWorld trainer Dawn Brancheau illustrates how eyewitnesses can see a traumatic incident far differently.

First, though, SeaWorld didn’t help matters by suggesting, in a news conference yesterday afternoon, that the trainer had slipped and fallen in the tank. That incorrect information confused matters, and the theme park had to backtrack from it. Why add confusion to the tragedy? (

But what happened between Brancheau and the whale Tilikum? You have a range of accounts.

What did Tilikum do? ABC’s “Good Morning America” said the whale “suddenly lunged at the woman.”

On CBS’ “The Early Show,” a witness said her daughter saw the whale “kind of lashing out. He shook her [Brancheau] violently.”

The Sentinel quoted witnesses who said “the animal suddenly grabbed Brancheau by the upper arm, tossed her around in his mouth and pulled her beneath the water.”

But a husband and a wife shared a less dramatic account on WOFL-Channel 35. The husband said the trainer’s hair must have been in the whale’s teeth when the animal rolled, taking her down with him. (Would that behavior qualify as an attack?)

The wife told WOFL there was a “a sudden jerk” and the whale brought the trainer up once before taking her down for five minutes.

Was the whale agitated? WESH-Channel 2 reported that it was.

On “Good Morming America,” George Stephanopoulos asked, “What pushed this whale over the edge?”

Yet a husband and a wife told “GMA” that the whale didn’t seem agitated while being patted by the trainer.

What was the whale’s manner?

WKMG-Channel 6 quoted the daughter of a former SeaWorld worker, who described Tilikum as “difficult, depressed and usually temperamental.”

On “GMA,” Chuck Tompkins, curator of zoological operations at SeaWorld, disagreed.

“I think that information is extremely inaccurate. I’ve worked with Tilikum his entire career here at SeaWorld,” Tompkins said. “I can tell you right now he is not a depressed animal. He is a very good animal.”

CBS’ “The Early Show” noted that the whale had many safe interactions with humans.

If Tilikum had a hard day yesterday, the killer whale was hardly alone. A witness told “The Early Show” that trainers had said three other whales did not want to perform and were not cooperating.

As for the late Brancheau, WESH had touching footage of her from 2000, when she said she had a lot of fun working with the whales.

From the reporting, we learned Brancheau knew the dangers and thought of the whales as her children.

I wonder what she would make of stories about a “killer whale attack.”

This is one of those stories that we’ll probably never know exactly what happened. Of course, that won’t stop anyone from talking about it. But when the human race deals with such magnificent creatures, mysterious things are bound to happen.

Death of Sea World trainer: Do 'killer whales' belong in theme parks?
Daniel B. Wood Christian Science Monitor Yahoo News 24 Feb 10;

Los Angeles – The death of a veteran Sea World trainer in Orlando, Fla., Wednesday has spotlighted the campaign of several major animal rights groups to keep marine mammals out of theme parks altogether.

Dawn Brancheau was killed when a 12,300-lb. male orca “killer whale” grabbed her in front of an audience at the Orlando theme park.

Now, animal rights activists say that many questions should be asked in the wake of Ms. Brancheau's death. Sea World has said that the very same orca is responsible for human deaths in 1991 and again in 1999. The Humane Society of the United States has long campaigned for marine mammals to be removed from theme parks.

“These behemoths are denied all of their natural, instinctual inclinations, and we humans tend to think, ‘Well, this is just a bad animal.’ But it is a wild animal, used to running free in an entire ocean, but now confined to a very small space,” says Joyce Tischler, founder of and general counsel for Animal Legal Defense Fund. She compares an orca’s life in captivity in a tank to keeping a human being in a bathtub for his entire life. She says most Americans have romanticized notions of sea life perpetuated by such TV series as “Flipper.” But even dolphins are known to aggressively run their teeth down the backs of humans in hundreds of incidents that are not reported outside the conservation community press, she says.

SeaWorld closed its Orlando park immediately after the tragedy, and suspended its orca show in San Diego. “We've initiated an investigation to determine, to the extent possible, what occurred,” SeaWorld President Dan Brown said in a brief statement to reporters. Ms. Brancheau had worked at the park since 1994. Mr. Brown said no SeaWorld park had ever before experienced a similar incident and pledged a thorough review of all of the park's standard operating procedures. “This is an extraordinarily difficult time for the SeaWorld parks and our team members. Nothing is more important than the safety of our employees, guests, and the animals entrusted to our care," Brown said. “We extend our deepest sympathies to the family and friends of the trainer and will do everything possible to assist them in this difficult time.”

The orca is the largest member of the dolphin family and is known as a favorite at Sea World. Killer whales are a highly social species.

But “the vast majority of the orca whales in captivity would be far better off to be returned to the wild. Orcas are unbelievably ill-suited to life in theme parks and can be successfully returned to the wild. We know, because we have done it,” says David Phillips, director of the International Marine Mammal Project for the Earth Island Institute, who led the effort to rescue, rehabilitate, and release the killer whale Keiko, made famous in the movie “Free Willy.” “Orcas deserve a better fate than living in cramped pools.

Mr. Phillips recalls that Keiko went from languishing in small pool in Mexico City all the way to swimming with wild whales in his native waters in Iceland. He ended up swimming to Norway and living there in a bay with some human care until he died. Phillips says the public would be better served by seeing orcas in the wild and ensuring their protection there.

“This isn’t the first time that stressed-out orca whales have injured or killed people, and unfortunately, it is not likely to be the last,” says Phillips. “It is high time that the marine park industry get out of the captive orca business.”

Tischler takes on the argument most often given by defenders of such captivity: That it is educational and spotlights the need for conservation and protection of such creatures: “The people who run these theme parks are not interested in conservation or protection, they are interested in making money,” Tischler says. “I would be asking, ‘Why was this animal kept after the first death?’ ”

“This is a giant warning sign that society needs to rethink this question of holding large predators in captivity,” says Chris Palmer, author of “Shooting in the Wild,” a book about wild animals in captivity, who also teaches at American University. “Having a trainer killed this way can’t justify whatever benefits we get from conservation or protection.”

SeaWorld Won't Euthanize Whale, Feds Investigate Trainer Death
Park Has No Plans to Euthanize Killer Whale Linked to Deaths of 3 People
Russell Goldman, ABC News 25 Feb 10;

SeaWorld has no plans to euthanize the killer whale that dragged a trainer to her death Wednesday, and will allow trainers to continue to work with the animal, a park official said today.

As two federal agencies launched investigations into Dawn Brancheau's death, the park said it will review its safety policies and determine whether Tillikum, a 12,000-pound bull killer whale, will be used in shows and publicly displayed.

Brancheau, 40, an experienced trainer, was snatched by the whale in front of a stadium of horrified onlookers, thrashed and ultimately held under water to drown.

SeaWorld has for years banned trainers from swimming with Tillikum, who was linked to the death of a Canadian trainer in 1991 and another man who snuck into a holding area in 1999. The whale has, however, been used in public shows and is given commands from trainers from the sides of the tank.