Peatland-clearing ban may ease haze woes

But questions remain as to how Jakarta enforces moratorium and what happens after it expires
Zubaidah Nazeer Straits Times 25 May 11;

JAKARTA: Now that clearing of new peatland is banned in Indonesia, countries affected by the haze from burning peat in Sumatra could get some breathing room.

That is assuming the landmark moratorium is enforced.

For years, Singapore and Malaysia suffered hazy skies and acrid smoke as landowners in Indonesia used traditional slash-and-burn methods to clear their concessions and plant the year's food and commercial crops, such as oil palm.

The moratorium - passed last Friday after a five-month delay - places about half of Indonesia's primary forest and peatland, or 64 million ha, off limits to development till the end of next year.

'To the extent that the moratorium leads to less disturbance of such areas, this could lead to a commensurate reduction in the frequency and severity of haze events over time,' said Ms Frances Seymour, director-general of the Centre for International Forestry Research (Cifor).

It was, she said, the first step towards Indonesia's target of reducing carbon emissions by up to 26 per cent by 2020.

The new areas of peatland covered under the moratorium are mainly scattered over the east coast of Sumatra and the southern tip of Kalimantan.

Indonesia is the world's third-largest emitter of greenhouse gases, after China and the United States, due largely to deforestation caused by illegal logging, mining and expansion by palm oil plantations.

The moratorium, hailed as a landmark step in tackling climate change, had been delayed as business people, green groups and the government tussled over the extent of the coverage.

As the world's largest palm oil exporter and one of the leading producers of rice, Indonesia is struggling to balance economic growth with environmental preservation. To nudge it forward, Norway last year extended a US$1 billion (S$1.2 billion) package to help Indonesia create monitoring systems and pilot projects to protect forests.

Some environmentalists have called the moratorium an 'anti-climax'. They wanted it to cover existing concessions in forest areas, so that producers could no longer strip them. They also pointed out that of the 64 million ha of primary forest covered by the ban, at least 35 million ha are already protected.

Greenpeace Indonesia had wanted 105 million ha of forest to be included.

Mr Yuyun Indradi, a Greenpeace campaigner, said that if current practices such as draining existing peatland concessions continue, protected areas close by remain at risk of being burned by extreme dry weather or lightning. 'This will not reduce the haze problem,' he said.

Other environmentalists have over the past few days asked how the moratorium will be enforced and what will happen after next year.

A report by the Human Rights Watch in 2009 for instance pointed out that rampant corruption meant that local officials did not enforce rules when it came to land development.

'The impact of this remains to be seen,' said Mr Yuyun. 'But the positive side of this is that the government has stepped in to suspend new concessions.'

Mr Agus Purnomo, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's special aide on climate change, said the government would issue recommendations on punishing those who flouted the ban.

Exact sanctions remain unclear, opening up the risk of poor implementation in a country with weak law enforcement.

Mr Agus said the ban would allow the government to give 'double protection' to natural forests at risk of illegal practices such as squatting and logging.

Risk of poor implementation

THE moratorium is a two-year suspension on new permits to clear primary forests and peatlands, which took effect last Friday.

Secondary forest areas or those already affected by human activity are allowed to have permits issued - a blow to environmentalists. These permits allow firms to develop the land for mining or agriculture.

The moratorium is part of a US$1 billion (S$1.23 billion) climate change deal signed with Norway last year to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from deforestation. The idea is to help finance an independent system of monitoring and measuring emissions.

Its implementation will be overseen by a task force piloted by reform-minded technocrat Kuntoro Mangkusubroto. It includes 64.2 million hectares of primary forests and more than 30 million hectares of peatlands.

It was not clear if there would be any sanctions if the moratorium was not followed, or if companies developed land covered by the moratorium's ban.

This opens up the risk of poor implementation in a country with rampant corruption and weak law enforcement, said Reuters.

Some of the exemptions include allowing firms that already hold permits or approvals from the forestry minister to log and convert forest land, to develop geothermal and other power plants, oil and gas fields, sugar and rice plantations, and ecosystem restoration.

ZUBAIDAH NAZEER