Shellfish from Malaysia meets safety requirements for heavy metals: Singapore Food Agency

Channel NewsAsia 10 Apr 19;

SINGAPORE: Samples and tests of shellfish imported from Malaysia meets Singapore's food safety requirements for heavy metals, the Singapore Food Agency (SFA) said on Tuesday (Apr 9).

Responding to CNA's queries, the agency said that Singapore imported about 40 per cent of its shellfish, including live, chilled, frozen crustaceans and molluscs, from Malaysia last year.

The rest of its shellfish imports are from countries including China, India, Indonesia and Vietnam.

SFA's response comes in the wake of reports about the potential risk of heavy metal poisoning from eating shellfish from the Straits of Malacca.

A team of scientists from Malaysia found high concentrations of heavy metals such as arsenic, cadmium, plumbum (lead) and mercury in the Straits of Malacca during a scientific voyage on Mar 13-22.

The findings, published on Tuesday, showed that the waters off Johor, Port Klang and Pulau Pinang presented a higher risk of heavy metal contamination.

"Samples and tests of shellfish from Malaysia met our food safety requirements for heavy metals," SFA told CNA.

"While tests of shellfish from Malaysia meet our food safety requirements, shellfish accumulate environmental contaminants and naturally will have some levels of heavy metals. Therefore, to avoid exposure to high levels of heavy metals through consumption, consumers should eat shellfish in moderation," it added.

Imported food, including shellfish, are inspected and sampled at the point of import or at retail markets for compliance with food safety requirements, the agency stated.

Tests cover a wide range of food-borne hazards including chemical contaminants such as pesticides, heavy metals and drug residue, as well as microorganisms such as E coli, Salmonella and Listeria.

Source: CNA/nh(aj)

Lecturer denies issuing warning against eating shellfish from Straits of Malacca
Satiman Jamin New Straits Times 9 Apr 19;

KUALA TERENGGANU: Like most Malaysians, Associate Prof Dr Ong Meng Chan was shocked after reading the news on Monday that seashells from some sections in the Straits of Malacca were unsafe for consumption.

The lecturer at Universiti Malaysia Terengganu’s School of Marine and Environmental Sciences, who was quoted in the Bernama story, said had never issued such warning and now found himself inundated with requests for interviews to clarify the matter.

“I did not issue such warning and the article is certainly not related to the sample collection we conducted en route to LIMA 2019 because we have yet to even start processing the samples we obtained during the trip,” he said in an interview.

He showed a stack of clear plastic tubes that contain the sediment samples from 45 stations along the route that UMT’s research vessel RV Discovery took on its way to LIMA 2019.

“We will have to cut up the samples, send them for dating and analyses. Only then will we be able to know the heavy metal concentration in each sample according to the relevant timeline.

“There are huge differences between the heavy metal concentrations in marine sediment and marine organisms, as the organisms’ uptake of heavy metals is very complex with various parameters that differ between species,” he said.

He said although a study in 2015 showed that the heavy metals pollution level in sediments taken along the Straits of Malacca was higher than samples taken around the South China Sea, it does not indicate that shellfish reared or caught in the former are unsafe.

“The South China Sea is a huge area with strong currents that can disperse pollutants to a bigger area much faster compared to the estuarine on the West Coast of Peninsular Malaysia.

“The effects of ocean currents also contributed to lower readings of pollutants at the northern part of the Malacca Strait as it meets the Indian ocean,” he said.

Ong said he loved eating shellfish and did so regularly.

“My hometown is also on the West Coast and I regularly eat shellfish and other seafood varieties whenever I go back there on holidays,” he said.

He said the permissible levels of heavy metals in shellfish were normally based on their contents in raw specimens.

“In Europe, especially in France where I studied for my PhD it is the norm to consume shellfish like oysters raw. Cooking the shellfish, as practiced in Malaysia will remove most of the heavy metals,” he said.

On another note, he said it is good that Malaysians are more aware of the presence of pollutants in the environment but care should be taken to not blow things out of proportion.

“Pollutants, including heavy metals are on the rise globally with the increase in human activities. Industrial and agricultural runoffs from heavily populated areas are of course higher than sparsely populated areas.

“What we should do is increase our monitoring and take steps to reduce the pollutants from human activities,” he said.

A press statement from the Department of Fisheries (DOF) director general Datuk Munir Mohd Nawi echoes what Ong said about the presence of heavy metal pollutants in shellfish.

He said Malaysia produced three main shellfish species with cockles leading at 12,482 metric tons while mussels and oysters at 2,274 and 1,402 metric tons respectively.

“Since 2013, the DOF have conducted safety monitoring of shellfish under the National Shellfish Sanitation Program (NSSP) involving samples from farms and specimens harvested from the wild.

Last year some 1,128 shellfish samples were taken from all over Malaysia to monitor the parameters set under the NSSP for heavy metal analyses for cadmium, lead and mercury,” he said.

He said the levels of heavy metals in shellfish samples taken in Malacca (Sebatu), Johor (Air Baloi, Teluk Jawa and Teluk Kabong) and Penang (Seberang Prai Selatan) were within the limits sets under the Foods Act 1983.

“In Selangor (Sungai Besar, Jeram and Kapar) the levels for lead and mercury have not exceeded

the limit, but the level of cadmium was found to be above the limit for cockles samples taken in Sungai Besar at the end of last year.

“The DOF have our own Standard Operation Procedure for cases where the NSSP went above the limits, including informing the local communities about such occurrences and continuous monitoring will be conducted in the affected areas.” he said.