Best of our wild blogs: 8 Feb 08


Free Underwater World at Sentosa
a young explorer shares on the nautilus blog

Crab goes *crunch*
Horseshoe crabs being chopped up on the budak blog

New Year visitation: Sisters Island
on the wildfilms blog and manta blog and nature scouters blog

Escape to the mangroves
on the budak blog

Sunbird New Year surprise
amazing photos on the mountain and sea blog

Didactic Short Films of Lasting Values
clips for the family, on the flying fish friends blog

An interview with Google's green energy czar, Bill Weihl The phrase "to Google" has become synonymous with "to search." But soon it may connote something altogether different: "to green." on the grist mill blog


Read more!

Use of recycled decorations in Chinatown saves cost, wastage

Channel NewsAsia 7 Feb 08;

SINGAPORE : Red and gold may be the "in" colours this festive season, but it does not mean that decorations can't "go green" as well.

Some decorations in Chinatown have been recycled to save costs and cut wastage.

Some of the lanterns at Chinatown may look familiar because they have been used before during other festivals, including the Mid-Autumn Festival.

Other materials for the main decorations in Chinatown have also been reused.

The people behind these artworks had used less plastic and so they find it easier to recycle their materials.

David Ong, Chairman, Kreta Ayer-Kim Seng Citizens' Consultative Committee, said, "Wires, if they cannot be used, they can be stripped...Likewise, for light bulbs, they can be reused for the next light-up as well.

"So for iron structures, yes, you can take them off and you can put them back again - in different forms and shapes - even for wires as well. So all these can be reused."

"Reuse" is also the theme for decorations at Chinatown Point.

Cindy Low, Manager, Advertising and Promotions, City Developments Limited, said, "The difficulty is these decorations are meant for Christmas. So we actually need to refashion them to suit the Chinese New Year Theme.

"It helps us save costs...and also the time for the transition from Christmas to Chinese New Year decorations."

So instead of overhauling decorations to suit two very different occasions, which take place in a short span of time, organisers used some creativity and a lot of planning to cut down on wastage and costs. - CNA/ms


Read more!

Pet shops see rise in sales of hamsters ahead of Year of the Rat

Channel NewsAsia 7 Feb 08;

SINGAPORE : Pet shops have recently seen a jump in sales ahead of the Year of the Rat.

The favourite buy has been hamsters, with an increase in sales of between 5 and 20 percent. PetMart sells an average of 10 to 20 hamsters a month.

However, more have been sold in recent weeks, and staff say mostly teenagers are buying the hamsters.

Benjamin Wee, Managing Director, PetMart, said, "Right now at the moment, the most popular one is the Roborovski Hamsters, but the new one is a bit golden colour called Pudding Hamsters. So they are quite popular now...these two species in the market."

Hamsters are by nature timid and social, and they are easy to keep as pets - just like rabbits or mice.

They are also meticulous in hygiene and can groom themselves.

Another pet shop, Pet Lovers Centre, said it has also experienced a jump in sales in a species of hamster.

The Syrian species has a golden coat and a little more than 1,900 have been sold across its 18 stores - an increase of about 20 percent.

The Rat is the first of 12 Chinese Zodiac animal signs.

The Year of the Rat stretches until January 25 next year, after which the Year of the Ox begins.

Meanwhile, if you are looking to buy a pet, do remember the responsibilities that come with it.

Do your research to see what type of pet best suits you, and if you have time for the pet.

Check out the SPCA website for more information: http://www.spca.org.sg/adoption/responsibility.asp - CNA/ms


Read more!

World's largest river island washing away under flood waters

Andrew Buncombe, The Independent 7 Feb 08;

It may be the largest river island in the world but it is steadily shrinking – eroded by the Brahmaputra river in which it is situated. Efforts to preserve the island and halt the erosion, caused by the glacial flood waters of the Himalayas, have been unco-ordinated and – say critics – ineffective.

Now the authorities are staking their hopes that having the island of Majuli listed as a World Heritage Site can bring about the focus and the funds needed to help save the culturally rich island.

"If it is listed as a World Heritage Site, there will be a co-ordinated management plan. The state and federal authorities will be obliged to prevent the erosion," said Diganta Gogoi, project director with the Majuli Island Protection and Development Council.

This week, the Indian government submitted an application to Unesco, requesting that Majuli, in the north-eastern state of Assam, be listed for special status under the "cultural landscape" category. The UN body has in turn asked the Indian authorities to provide them with a risk-preparedness strategy, outlining how it planned to save the island.

The island – formed by a change of course by the Brahmaputra – has a long and rich history and is considered a centre of Vaishnavite Hindu culture, whose followers worship the god Vishnu. The island is home to more than 30 satras or monasteries, many of which house irreplaceable collections of writings, antiques and masks.

But the island is fast disappearing. In 1950 it was around 1,256 sq km but by 1990 it had shrunk to about half that size. Since 1990 up to 35 villages have been washed away and some reports suggest the island could disappear within as little as 20 years.

"The erosion problem is everywhere," said K N Dikshit, general secretary of the Delhi-based Indian Archaeological Society. "There are many historical artefacts and paintings. If the island is not preserved it will all disappear."

Majuli's people are also suffering as the land slowly disappears. Worst affected are those who try to eke out a livelihood on the edge of the river. Most of these people belong to the Mishing clan and, as their land and villages have disappeared, so they have been transformed from farmers into labourers. Reports from Majuli say that many of these communities are living in dire conditions.

"The main problem is that the Brahmaputra is a massive river. During the high flood season the discharge of water is enormous," said S Jagannatana, secretary to Assam's governor, Lt-Gen Ajay Singh. "The soil on the edge of the island is very loose – it's all alluvial silt."

The central government has set aside around £10m to fund measures to try to prevent the erosion. These have included concrete barriers placed in the river to try to divert the water and measures to strengthen the embankments of the island.

But local people say these steps have made little difference and that the land from which they try to survive continues to disappear, sometimes requiring them to move overnight. Their lives have become a constant struggle to find a piece of land that seems stable – at least for a while.


Read more!

Artificial reef to mitigate impact of US nuclear station

Artificial Reef Off the SC Coastline?
SC Times 6 Feb 08;

Vol. 3, Issue 6, February 7-13, 2008

THE LATEST: The California Coastal Commission approved a permit on Wednesday for Southern California Edison to build a 126.7-acre artificial reef from San Mateo Point to just north of the San Clemente Pier. The reef will stretch 2.5 miles in length approximately .6 miles offshore.

The reef has been in the works since the 1960s when a study revealed that water pumped from the Pacific Ocean into the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station to cool Units 2 and 3 was returned to the ocean 20 degrees warmer, which was declared harmful to the ocean’s kelp beds. To compensate, Southern California Edison agreed to build an artificial reef to mitigate any damage done to the ocean environment.

“What we’re about to do it attempt to create a complex eco system on a rather large scale,” said SCE Manager of Environmental Projects David Kay at Wednesday’s meeting. While optimistic about the project, he did warn the commissioners that it may not go perfectly. “We have time to adapt our reef to the curveballs that Mother Nature occasionally throws,” he said.

In the past four decades, Southern California Edison has cooperated in years of study and testing. In 1999 they build their first test reefs: 22.5 acres in 56 different patches, crafted from ruble and rock in various densities and heights. In the years since, project leaders have learned that these reefs must be located in waters not too deep or shallow and not on ground that’s too sandy or too hard. They also learned that smaller formations of rock that move with major storms is most effective for the kelp, a weed-like plant that claims ground quickly but can be blocked out by coral. This coral, in turn, is usually jarred from the rocks when they move during a storm, allowing the kelp to again thrive.


Read more!

'New type of bird' found in Nepal

Charles Haviland, BBC News 5 Feb 08;

A previously unknown sub-species of bird has been discovered in the southern grasslands of Nepal, scientists say.

The bird is a warbler with a very long tail and slender beak and has been named the Nepal Rufous-vented Prinia.

Scientists say the bird provides an important geographical link between previously-known varieties in Pakistan and India.

But they warn its tiny population means the sub-species is endangered.

The bird was first spotted in 2005 in a wetland area.

But it is only now that taxonomists have decided it is distinctive enough to be described as a separate sub-species.

'Exciting find'

It has different dimensions from the two other types of Rufous-vented Prinia, and in colour comes between the rich chestnut of its western neighbour and the grey of the one to the east.

Hem Sagar Baral of Bird Conservation Nepal said the find is exciting because while the other two types belong to Pakistan's Indus river basin and the Brahmaputra of north-east India, this Nepalese sub-species fills the gap.

The latest find "appears to form the link" between the two pre-existing sub-species, he said.

The new find brings the number of bird species spotted in Nepal to an exceptionally high 862.

But the conservationists are warning that with habitat loss and degradation, the newly-identified variety is highly threatened, with at most 500 birds currently alive.

They are however elated that it has been found in a reserve which is well monitored by bird-watchers, and are now speculating that there may be more species waiting to be found - new to Nepal, or even to the world.


Read more!

Rescue appeal as big turtles are washed up on British beaches

Michael McCarthy, The Independent 7 Feb 08;

The endangered reptiles, including loggerheads often found off Florida and central America, are probably being washed up as a result of south-westerly winds. The winds are forecast to continue and more turtles are expected to turn up on British and Irish beaches, according to the Marine Conservation Society and Marine Environmental Monitoring (MEM).

Most turtles eventually die in cold seas, but some survive. While stranded turtles may appear to be dead, they may be comatose because of the cold conditions, and can recover.

"While many of the turtles reported this year have washed up dead, three have been alive," said MEM's strandings co-ordinator Rod Penrose. "Under no circumstances should live turtles be put back into the sea here in the UK. If rescued in time, these animals can be nursed back to health, indeed, 11 out of 19 live stranded turtles rescued from UK and Irish beaches in the past decade have been successfully rehabilitated and released."

The strandings started in Scotland in late December, when a dead juvenile loggerhead turtle washed up on the shores of Islay.

Since then, another 10 have stranded on beaches in Gwynedd and Anglesey in Wales, Argyll in Scotland, counties Clare, Cork and Wexford in Ireland, and in south-west England. In the past two weeks, two live loggerhead turtles were found – one at Bude, Cornwall, on 26 January and another at Putsborough Beach, north Devon last Saturday.

Both are juveniles, and are now recovering in the Blue Reef Aquarium in Newquay, north Cornwall. The aquarium's curator, Matt Slater, said it was extremely rare for two turtles to wash up around the same time and that they were recovering. He said they were probably from America or Mexico.

If they recover they will be flown to a dedicated rescue centre in Gran Canaria and eventually be released into warmer seas. The latest stranding, reported on Monday, was of a dead leatherback turtle that washed up without its head or flippers at Tywyn in Gwynedd, Wales.

Six of the seven known species of turtle are classified as endangered or threatened. They were formerly hunted on a large scale for their meat, fat and shells, and their eggs were also taken, but now they are protected. However, they are sometimes accidentally caught by fishing boats, or swallow plastic bags, mistaking them for food.

Stranded turtles should be reported to MEM on 01348 875000, which will rescue live turtles and recover any that have died.


Read more!

US group files to protect Pacific walruses

Dan Joling, Associated Press Yahoo News 8 Feb 08;

A conservation group filed Thursday to protect Pacific walruses because of the threat to their northern habitat by global warming.

The Center for Biological Diversity petitioned the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to list walruses as threatened under the Endangered Species Act because of warming and its effect on sea ice used by the animals as a feeding and resting platform. The group also said oil and gas development throughout the animals' range was a threat.

The listing request was filed as the Fish and Wildlife Service decides whether to list polar bears as threatened because sea ice has diminished due to global warming.

"The Arctic is in crisis from global warming," said Shaye Wolf, lead author of the petition and a biologist with the conservation group. "Arctic sea-ice is disappearing at a stunning rate that vastly exceeds the predictions of the best climate models."

Bruce Woods, a spokesman for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service in Anchorage, said the law calls for a review to determine whether the petition contains "substantial information" within 90 days if practicable.

If the petition passes that first hurdle, the agency would have nine months to perform a status review on walruses.

Summer sea ice last summer receded to 1.65 million square miles, the lowest level since satellite measurements began in 1979, according to the National Snow and Ice Data Center at the University of Colorado. In September, sea ice was 39 percent below the long-term average from 1979 to 2000.

Sea ice in the Chukchi Sea, the part of the Arctic Ocean between Alaska's northwest coast and the Russian Far East, receded well beyond the shallow outer continental shelf over water too deep for walruses to dive to reach clams and other benthic creatures they eat.

As many as 6,000 walrus in late summer and fall abandoned ice over deep water and congregated on Alaska's northwest shore.

Herds were larger on the Russian side, where one group reached up to 40,000 animals. Russian observers estimated 3,000 to 4,000 mostly young walrus died in stampedes when herds rushed into the water at the sight of a polar bear, hunter or low-flying aircraft.

Aside from stampedes, biologists worry that if current ice trends continue, and walrus are based on coastlines every summer, they will put tremendous pressure on nearby foraging areas rather than rich offshore feeding areas they historically have reached by living on the edge of the ice pack.

"The Pacific walrus is an early victim of our failure to address global warming," Wolf said. "As the sea ice recedes, so does the future of the Pacific walrus."

Unlike seals, walruses cannot swim indefinitely. Females and their young traditionally use ice as a diving platform, riding it north in spring and summer like a conveyor belt over offshore foraging areas, first in the northern Bering Sea, then into the Chukchi Sea.

An adult walrus can eat 200 pounds of clams in a day.

Scientists at the National Snow and Ice Data Center have said they do not expect summer sea ice to bounce back without changes in current warming trends. Mark Serreze, senior research scientist, said in December that the complete loss of summer sea ice by 2030 was a reasonable expectation.

Two scientists at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, Calif., said last month the Arctic Ocean could be entirely ice-free during the summer months by 2013. Wieslaw Maslowski, research associate professor in the Navy school's Department of Oceanography, and researcher Jaclyn Clement Kinney modeled and monitored Arctic ice melt by analyzing data provided by submarines and satellites, scientific studies and records over the past several decades.

Wolf also said walrus are likely to be affected by petroleum development. The U.S. Minerals Management Service on Wednesday accepted high bids on 2.76 million acres of Chukchi Sea ocean bottom. Five other lease sales in the Pacific walrus's habitat in the Chukchi, Beaufort and Bering seas off Alaska's shore are planned by 2012.

Increased oil and gas development and a proliferation of shipping routes pose threats to the Pacific walrus from the heightened risk of oil spills and rising levels of noise pollution and human disturbance, according to the group.

Wolf said the window of opportunity to act is closing rapidly and rapid action is needed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. She called for a moratorium on oil and gas development.

Oil and gas development, shipping, and greenhouse gas emissions affecting the Arctic would be subject to greater regulation under the Endangered Species Act if the walrus is listed.


Read more!

Wal-Mart to pay more for "greener" goods

Nichola Groom, Reuters 7 Feb 08;

INDIAN WELLS (Reuters) - Wal-Mart Stores Inc is willing to pay more for products that last longer and hurt the environment less, the company's director of sustainability said on Thursday, adding it might not necessarily have to raise retail prices as a result.

"Bad quality products create waste, and so having tighter standards on the social side, on the environmental side and on the quality side will reduce waste," Matt Kistler, Wal-Mart's senior vice president of sustainability, said in an interview.

"We are even willing to pay more for products that have that." But that does not have to mean higher prices for customers.

"I don't know if we have to pass on the higher costs," Kistler said at the Clean-tech Investor Summit in Indian Wells, California.

"We are looking at a very small amount of dollars and the savings in the supply chain that we are finding because of sustainability in some cases will more than offset the incremental costs of what we are paying for a better quality item."

Wal-Mart, the world's largest retailer, has set a goal of one day using only renewable energy and creating zero waste.

As part of that effort, the company has pushed its suppliers to cut back on the amount of packaging they use by 5 percent by 2013.

To meet that goal, it has developed a "packaging scorecard" that will rate its 60,000 suppliers on their ability to cut waste and conserve resources.

Wal-Mart's suppliers had a February 1 deadline to comply with the "packaging scorecard" initiative, but many of the company's smaller vendors -- which represent roughly 20 percent of the goods the company buys -- have yet to do so, Kistler said.

"We do not have all suppliers 100 percent compliant today, which is a disappointment because we did give them a year," he said. "The smaller companies that we may not buy consistently from or the same product from, those are the ones that either have not (complied) or it simply doesn't make sense for them."

But Kistler added the scorecard had already produced a lot of change in the packages of its most popular products.

"The scorecard is really more geared toward the products we buy year after year," he added.

(Reporting by Nichola Groom; Editing by Andre Grenon)


Read more!

The price of cheaper chicken

Tesco hits a new low with arrival of the £1.99 chicken
Martin Hickman, The Independent 6 Feb 08;

Tesco slashed the price of a whole chicken to £1.99 yesterday, in a move that critics warned would heap financial pressure on the poultry industry and make it harder to the improve welfare of factory-farmed animals.

Britain's biggest supermarket chain said the price of a "standard" bird would be cut by 60 per cent until Sunday to help families on tight budgets, adding that it had doubled its order for higher-welfare chicken.

The animal welfare group, Compassion in World Farming (CIWF), said the arrival of a £1.99 bird was "depressing", as it followed weeks of publicity and debate about the welfare of broiler chickens, arising from a Channel 4 series and campaign by the chef High Fearnley-Whittingstall.

Dr Lesley Lambert, the CIWF's director of research and education, said: "£1.99 doesn't reflect the real price of producing a chicken. At the moment, farmers make only 2p per chicken, so this will push them to the limit."

She said that Tesco should be cutting the price of its higher-welfare chicken rather than its bottom-of-the-range birds. However, Tesco, which said that a family of four would now be able to eat a roast dinner for 99p each, claimed that it wanted to improve animal welfare while helping shoppers squeezed by "mortgage worries, energy price rises and inflation". Jonathan Church, a company spokesman, said: "We have been working hard for a while to increase the amount of higher-welfare chicken we sell and the recent debate in the media about chickens has helped raise awareness of the choice available.

"But our investment in premium chicken should not be seen as a move away from providing more affordable options. No one should feel guilty for buying a chicken just because it is good value. The only reduction we make is in the price, not the welfare."

The promotion – which was surprising given Tesco's refusal to respond to a £2 chicken offer from Asda last year – could prompt a supermarket price war. Last night, a spokeswoman for Asda said: "We always endeavour to be best on price. As far as I know we have no plans to cut prices, but it might all change tomorrow."

Sales of free-range chickens increased over the past month after Channel 4's week-long series Hugh's Chicken Run showed how the country's 800 million broiler chickens lead cramped, painful lives compared with their free-range counterparts.

In a study published today in the Public Library of Science One journal, researchers at Bristol University found that, by the age of 40 days, 27 per cent of fast-growing indoor broiler chickens have walking problems. Three in 100 were completely lame. The study, funded by Defra, warned that only the introduction of slower-growing birds would improve welfare standards.

In his television show, Fearnley-Whittingstall divided a chicken shed in two to show how the lives of free-range and standard birds differ; his mass-produced birds had higher rates of leg burn and had to be culled in greater numbers.

Fearnley-Whittingstall said yesterday: "I'm very surprised [at Tesco] because everybody is selling out of free-range chicken. To launch a £1.99 chicken is in direct contradiction to a statement [the chief executive] Sir Terry Leahy made last summer when he said he didn't want to get into a food price war on chicken."


Read more!

Biofuels can have real ecological benefits

Stephen Whittaker, The Telegraph 7 Feb 08;

The 'biofuels backlash' has certainly gathered pace in recent months and we anticipate that the recent spate of reports, from both sides of the Atlantic, criticising the negative environmental impact of biofuels production is only the tip of the iceberg.

Perhaps, given the size and scale of the industry today, this is not surprising.

There's no doubt that globally there has been a rush by some emerging countries to produce biofuel on the same industrial scale as fossil fuels and there is evidence that deforestation has been one unfortunate consequence of this.

However, there is the danger that we throw the baby out with the bathwater; that the failure to differentiate between 'good' and 'bad' biodiesel production undoes years of sound ecological progress.

Any journey that takes a 'green' product from its perception as a niche alternative and turns it into a successful, globally available commodity is unlikely to happen without causing a few ripples.

What is important is that any issues are monitored and handled responsibly, that the industry is regulated as effectively as possible and that improvement in best practice is continuously encouraged.

If we want the world's innovators and entrepreneurs to take new, alternative products through to mass production, then we need to be as assertive in the crucial expansion stages as we were when it was a quirky, niche idea.

Sustainably produced biofuels genuinely deliver significant net benefits when it comes to the environment, and in the UK they are certainly helping many local councils and environmentally-aware private businesses achieve and exceed their carbon-reduction targets.

Biofuels consistently offer many environmental and performance advantages over traditional diesel. They produce no net emissions of carbon dioxide, one of the main gases responsible for global warming, and they burn more cleanly and efficiently than fossil diesel and cause less pollution when burnt.

At the heart of the current biofuel debate is the sourcing of raw materials used in its production process. Historically, our fuels have always been based on the recycling of waste vegetable oils, sourced locally from food manufacturers, pubs and restaurants and then recovered in the biofuel production process as an oxygenated vegetable oil ester.

This remains our principal source of raw material, but more recently supplemented by other genuinely sustainable feedstocks such as animal fats or fish oils of known (preferably local) origin and with traceable history.

For the producer that remains genuinely determined to produce a sustainable, environmentally-friendly product and uses these raw materials to achieve that objective, biofuel does make a fantastically positive contribution to the climate change agenda, in line with key Government policy.

The European manufacturer that is sourcing locally produced vegetable oils such as rapeseed, sunflower or olive oil as the basis of its biofuel production is, literally and metaphorically, miles and miles away from those associated with the destruction of Indonesian or Amazonian rain forests. To lump them all together in a critical report is a sweeping and inaccurate generalisation.

We must not dismiss or ignore the negative consequences that mass biofuel production is undoubtedly having on some parts of the world, but nor should we underestimate the very real ecological benefits that sustainably produced biofuels are having on the UK's ability to reduce its dependency on fossil fuels."

Stephen Whittaker is managing director of Cheshire-based ESL Biofuels established almost 10 years ago as the UK's first commercial manufacturer of biodiesel.


Read more!

Study: Ethanol may add to global warming

H. Josef Hebert, Associated Press Yahoo News 8 Feb 08;

The widespread use of ethanol from corn could result in nearly twice the greenhouse gas emissions as the gasoline it would replace because of expected land-use changes, researchers concluded Thursday. The study challenges the rush to biofuels as a response to global warming.

The researchers said that past studies showing the benefits of ethanol in combating climate change have not taken into account almost certain changes in land use worldwide if ethanol from corn — and in the future from other feedstocks such as switchgrass — become a prized commodity.

"Using good cropland to expand biofuels will probably exacerbate global warming," concludes the study published in Science magazine.

The researchers said that farmers under economic pressure to produce biofuels will increasingly "plow up more forest or grasslands," releasing much of the carbon formerly stored in plants and soils through decomposition or fires. Globally, more grasslands and forests will be converted to growing the crops to replace the loss of grains when U.S. farmers convert land to biofuels, the study said.

The Renewable Fuels Association, which represents ethanol producers, called the researchers' view of land-use changes "simplistic" and said the study "fails to put the issue in context."

"Assigning the blame for rainforest deforestation and grassland conversion to agriculture solely on the renewable fuels industry ignores key factors that play a greater role," said Bob Dinneen, the association's president.

There has been a rush to developing biofuels, especially ethanol from corn and cellulosic feedstock such as switchgrass and wood chips, as a substitute for gasoline. President Bush signed energy legislation in December that mandates a six-fold increase in ethanol use as a fuel to 36 billion gallons a year by 2022, calling the requirement key to weaning the nation from imported oil.

The new "green" fuel, whether made from corn or other feedstocks, has been widely promoted — both in Congress and by the White House — as a key to combating global warming. Burning it produces less carbon dioxide, the leading greenhouse gas, than the fossil fuels it will replace.

During the recent congressional debate over energy legislation, lawmakers frequently cited estimates that corn-based ethanol produces 20 percent less greenhouse gases in production, transportation and use than gasoline, and that cellulosic ethanol has an even greater benefit of 70 percent less emissions.

The study released Thursday by researchers affiliated with Princeton University and a number of other institutions maintains that these analyses "were one-sided" and counted the carbon benefits of using land for biofuels but not the carbon costs of diverting land from its existing uses.

"The other studies missed a key factor that everyone agrees should have been included, the land use changes that actually are going to increase greenhouse gas emissions," said Tim Searchinger, a research scholar at Princeton University's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs and lead author of the study.

The study said that after taking into account expected worldwide land-use changes, corn-based ethanol, instead of reducing greenhouse gases by 20 percent, will increases it by 93 percent compared to using gasoline over a 30-year period. Biofuels from switchgrass, if they replace croplands and other carbon-absorbing lands, would result in 50 percent more greenhouse gas emissions, the researchers concluded.

Not all ethanol would be affected by the land-use changes, the study said.

"We should be focusing on our use of biofuels from waste products" such as garbage, which would not result in changes in agricultural land use, Searchinger said in an interview. "And you have to be careful how much you require. Use the right biofuels, but don't require too much too fast. Right now we're making almost exclusively the wrong biofuels."

The study included co-authors affiliated with Iowa State University, the Woods Hole Research Center and the Agricultural Conservation Economics. It was supported in part indirectly by a grants from NASA's Terrestrial Ecology Program, and by the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation. Searchinger, in addition to his affiliation with Princeton, is a fellow at the Washington-based German Marshall Fund of the United States.

The study prompted a letter Thursday to President Bush and Democratic and Republican leaders in Congress from nearly a dozen scientists who urged them to pursue a policy "that ensures biofuels are not produced on productive forests, grassland or cropland."

"Some opportunities remain to produce environmentally beneficial biofuels" while "unsound biofuel policies could sacrifice tens of hundreds of million of acres" of grasslands and forests while increasing global warming, said the scientists, including four members of the National Academy of Sciences.

Food-Based Biofuels Can Spur Climate Change - Study
Deborah Zabarenko, PlanetArk 8 Feb 08;

WASHINGTON - Alternative fuels made from corn, soybeans, sugarcane and palm trees can in some cases increase the amount of climate-warming carbon dioxide that goes into the atmosphere, US researchers reported on Thursday.

These so-called food-based biofuels can actually hurt the environment if they are produced on land that was formerly grassland, rainforest or savanna, the scientists said in the journal Science.

Nonfossil fuels -- ethanol made from corn or sugarcane and biodiesel made from palm trees or soybeans -- are meant to lessen dependence on petroleum products, which release the greenhouse gas carbon dioxide when they burn.

However, biofuels can release carbon even before they are burned, depending on how they are made, said study co-author Jason Hill of the University of Minnesota.

As demand for these alternative fuels grows, farmers are plowing under forests and grasslands that used to store carbon and keep it from getting into the atmosphere, and using these lands to grow the food crops that now can be used for ethanol or biodiesel.

Biofuels grown this way come with a "carbon debt," the researchers found. Instead of cutting greenhouse pollution, the net effect is to increase it.

The carbon lost by converting rainforests, peatlands, savannas and grasslands outweighs the carbon savings from biofuels. Some conversions release hundreds of times more carbon than the annual savings from replacing fossil fuels.

CENTURIES OF CARBON DEBT

For example, the scientists wrote, Indonesia's conversion of peatlands for palm oil plantations had the world's greatest carbon debt, one that would take 423 years to repay.

The next worst case was the planting of soybeans in the Amazon, which would not pay for itself in renewable soy biodiesel for 319 years.

There are biofuel sources that do not rack up these formidable carbon debts, Hill said: nonfood plants including perennial grasses that only have to be harvested, without plowing under existing species that hold on to carbon.

"Our group has looked at using diverse mixtures of native species ... (on) prairie land, land that's restored back into prairies," Hill said in a telephone interview. "We essentially have no native prairies left in this nation but we can restore land into prairies, thereby restoring an ecosystem that was natural and also getting the biofuel benefit from it."

Biofuels, whether made from prairie plants, corn or soybeans, lack the potential to satisfy US fuel needs, Hill said.

"If we take every corn kernel we produce in this nation and convert it to ethanol, we would offset only 12 percent of our gasoline use," he said. "And that doesn't include the energy it took to produce that ethanol in the first place.

"None of these are solutions, but we better be sure we're not making the problem worse, and that's what's happening with the current generation of food-based biofuels," Hill said. (Editing by Xavier Briand)


Read more!