Are Beetles Imported into the U.S. to Kill Invasive Trees Doing Too Good a Job?

Strategy that unleashed cedar leaf beetles on Tamarisk trees may have to be revised as the chompers spread to threaten endangered birds

Anne Minard, Scientific American 19 Mar 09;

A foreign beetle imported to attack invasive trees in the U.S. Southwest may have brought its own culinary agenda. Researchers in Utah and Arizona are sounding the alarm about salt cedar leaf beetles, which were imported from Kazakhstan several years ago to control invasive tamarisk trees.

"Now that the beetle is spreading to large areas, we need to start looking for unexpected consequences of defoliation and death of the tamarisk," says Philip Dennison, a geographer at The University of Utah and lead author of a study warning of the unintended risks published this month in the online edition of the journal Remote Sensing of Environment.

Tamarisk trees, native to Europe and Asia, were first planted in the U.S. in the early 1800s as ornamentals and to stabilize soil, especially on riverbanks. The trees took off, and now dominate 1.6 million acres (650,000 hectares) of mostly riverside habitat throughout the Southwest. Dense tamarisk stands have crowded out native trees like cottonwoods and willows. And tamarisk gets a bad rap for being thirsty enough to drop water tables and dewater small streams—although the new research says the rep may be undeserved. Tamarisk was first identified as a pest around 1900, and biologists since the 1940s have implemented various control strategies, including herbicides, manual removal, and defoliation by goats and beetles. Total cost estimates approach $100 million for the decades-long efforts.

Beginning in 2001 biologists in nearly all southwestern states—with input and funding from the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS)—released the beetles in tamarisk thickets.

The program has been "spectacularly successful, one of the most successful biological control projects ever in the U.S.," says Jack Deloach, an entomologist with the U.S. Department of Agriculture's (USDA) research arm, the Agricultural Research Service.

But Dennison and his co-authors are now proposing that officials put on the brakes, based on satellite monitoring in 2006 and 2007 of 56 beetle-treated areas in southern Utah. The researchers report that beetles have been dutifully stripping the tamarisk of their needles but that some of the immediate effects are worrisome.

As it turns out, tamarisk trees have a silver lining, Dennison says. Their sprawling branches, which are covered with long, pliable needlelike leaves, provide coveted cover for native birds. Among them the endangered willow flycatcher, which routinely nests in the tamarisk thickets that replaced the willow trees there. Salt cedar beetles were originally kept out of Arizona and New Mexico to protect the flycatcher, but researchers report that the beetles are now creeping from Utah's Virgin River into flycatcher habitat in southern Utah and northern Arizona. The Center for Biological Diversity (CBD), a Tucson, Ariz.–based conservation group, has filed a notice of intent to sue the USDA and APHIS to halt the beetle program, charging that the bugs have gotten out of hand and are threatening the endangered birds.

Nate Ament, a restoration ecologist with the nonprofit Tamarisk Coalition in Grand Junction, Colo., says the greatest risk to streamside ecosystems comes in tamarisk's wake. The new satellite data show tamarisk-related water loss is lower than previously believed. If tamarisk trees are killed off by the beetles, newer weedy arrivals—like Russian knapweed, Russian olive and pepperweed—could hammer the water supply even more.

"We really emphasize revegetation with native trees as a crucial component of the restoration process," Ament says.

On that point, all sides agree. The CBD's Robin Silver says one of the aims of the suit is to prompt revegetation with native trees, like willows, in places where the tamarisk might die off.


Read more!

Global warming greatest threat to polar bears

Pierre-henry Deshayes Yahoo News 19 Mar 09;

TROMSOE, Norway (AFP) – The five countries that ring the Arctic on Thursday declared climate change the single greatest threat to polar bears, calling for urgent action to curb global warming.

Months ahead of a crucial global climate conference, the five countries -- Canada, Denmark (with Greenland), Norway, Russia and the United States -- expressed their "deep concern" at the end of a three-day meeting in the northern Norwegian town of Tromsoe.

"The parties agreed that long-term conservation of polar bears depends upon successful mitigation of climate change," they wrote in a joint statement following discussion on threats to the white bear that have emerged since they first signed a conservation agreement in 1973.

That agreement was aimed mainly at banning the hunting of polar bears, which at the time was considered the only real threat to the animal.

Nearly four decades later, however, the Arctic partners said they "agreed that impacts of climate change and the continued and increasing loss and fragmentation of sea ice... constitutes the most important threat to polar bear conservation."

They also "recognised the urgent need for an effective global response that will address the challenges of climate change."

While the statement was not legally binding, it was welcomed by environmentalists and scientists who said they hoped it would send a clear message to the international community ahead of talks to be held in Copenhagen in December on a new global pact on climate change to replace the Kyoto accord.

"It's a success," WWF polar bear expert Geoff York told AFP.

"The parties took significant steps in the right direction and the responsability now lies with governments to take action in order to reduce their emissions," he insisted.

Andrew Derocher, a Canadian who heads up scientific umbrella organisation the Polar Bear Specialist Group, was also pleased with the outcome of the Tromsoe meeting.

The final statement was "much more encouraging than I had feared at the beginning of the meeting," he told AFP, pointing out that he was "very pleased that the predominant threat of climate change was unanimously recognised by all nations.

"Now the question is how this message translates in Copenhagen and how the message of these two meetings (in Tromsoe and Copenhagen) will then translate in the global community and its willingness to cut emissions," he added.

Global warming is believed to be to blame for the increasingly rapid melting of the Arctic sea ice, which makes up the polar bear's primary hunting ground for its main prey, seals.

According to satellite pictures, the Arctic sea ice has over the past four summers stood at its lowest level in three decades, while some estimates say the ice could disappear completely during the warm months in the near future, which would have devastating consequences for the polar bear.

With the mercury rising ever higher, as many as two thirds of the 20-25,000 polar bears that roam the Arctic could disappear by the middle of this century, according to a recent estimate from the US Geological Survey.

The melting ice means not only shorter hunting seasons, but it also means the bears have to cross greater distances to reach their icy hunting grounds, something that has led to a deterioration of the bears' health, impacting their reproductive capacities and the cubs' chances of survival.

The polar bear is also threatened by chemical pollutants from industries and increased human activity in the once-pristine Arctic.

The Arctic states, which have only met twice since 1981, also agreed in Tromsoe to more frequent exchanges. They are now set to meet in Canada in 2011 and in Russia two years later.

Arctic nations take important first step towards saving polar bears
WWF 19 Mar 09;

Tromso, Norway - Five nations committed by treaty to conserve polar bears have come up with a resolution linking the future of the species to urgent global action on climate change.

“We are very encouraged by the final declaration from this meeting,” says Geoff York, polar bear coordinator for WWF International’s Arctic Programme.

“We were concerned that some countries were lagging behind the others in their commitment to dealing with climate change, but ultimately, the parties recognized climate change as the primary threat to the future well-being of polar bears. They also recognized formally “the urgent need for an effective global response that will address the challenges of climate change”, to be addressed at fora such as the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change”.

The five Arctic nations signed a binding 1973 Agreement on the Conservation of Polar Bears that includes provisions to protect polar bears and their habitat.

The Norwegian government played a key role in bringing the parties together, and in setting high expectations for the meeting. Erik Solheim, Environment Minister of Norway told Norwegian television. “It would be an amazing crime against future generations if we did not save the polar bear.”

The meeting made some other important advances. It has agreed to come up with a circumpolar action plan for the management of bears, and to formally designate the Polar Bear Specialist Group of the World Conservation Union (IUCN) as the scientific advisory body to the Agreement. These were both measures proposed by WWF in advance of the meeting.

“Although we are generally very pleased with the meeting outcome, this is by no means the end of the story- it is the start on the path to polar bear survival,” says York. “The real proof of this new commitment to taking urgent and effective action on climate change is what leaders of these nations will commit to later this year. Ministers from these five countries are meeting in this same town toward the end of April at a meeting of the Arctic Council, and have a golden opportunity then to outline their national commitment to climate change.”

Ultimately, the polar bear nations must join with other countries at the UN climate conference in Copenhagen in December 2009 to sign an effective global deal on climate change that will save the polar bears’ Arctic sea ice habitat, along with the entire ice ecosystem.


Read more!

Will Success Kill the Pangasius?

Barbara Hardinghaus, The Spiegel 18 Mar 09;

The Pangasius, or striped catfish, began taking the European fish market by storm a few years ago. It satisfied a voracious appetite for inexpensive white fish. But its success may become its downfall.

Manuela Wendland looks through her round glasses at the many different kinds of fish in the fresh food counter. The saleswoman sees whole fish, half fish and fish fillets, all of them arranged on ice and surrounded by lettuce leaves.

Wendland wears a wide, blue apron and a hood over her ash-blond hair. These days, she says, she is seeing more and more Pangasius, a fresh-water species also known as the striped catfish.

It arrives frozen, Wendland says, and has practically no bones; it's mild-tasting and a good fish for kids. She picks up a piece and places it on a scale in a Hamburg supermarket. It weighs 198 grams (7 ounces) and costs €1.96 ($2.50).

The Pangasius made its first appearance in the fresh food counter three years ago. It was a new fish, a crisis fish that had been slated to fill the gap created by overfishing. Every year, the average German eats 16 kilograms (35 pounds) of fish, or about 50 percent more than in 1970. Varieties like cod, ocean perch and spiny dogfish are becoming scarce.

Nowadays, the customers standing in front of Wendland's counter know not to buy cod, wild salmon, ocean perch, tuna or North Sea plaice. According to a recent study by the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO), 77 percent of edible fish populations have been fished to the limit or beyond. Even pollack, an inexpensive, white fish commonly used in fish sticks, is become harder to find.

The People's Fish

But customers want inexpensive white fish with low fat content, and the Pangasius has all the beneficial characteristics a fish variety needs for the wealthy world to buy it. It is the new people's fish -- born in Vietnam and bred to suit the tastes of people around the world. It could become the fish of the future -- if it weren't for the fact that mankind is producing the Pangasius to death.

The white and healthy filets of Pangasius in Manuela Wendland's counter are more than just fish filets. They represent a small slice of the global economy. Wendland wraps the Pangasius filet in paper, puts it in a bag, staples the price tag to the bag and says: "This fish swims in the Mekong." In fact, three million tons of Pangasius swim in the Mekong, almost 10,000 kilometers (6,200 miles) away from Wendland's fish stand, where they live in ponds the size of football fields or in cages in the water beneath houses.

This year, Vietnam will export 1.5 million tons of Pangasius filets to the rest of the world, including 143,000 tons to Germany alone. It arrives by ship in the northern ports of Bremerhaven or Hamburg, where it is loaded onto trucks bound for wholesale markets, from which it eventually reaches places like Wendland's or the frozen food sections of many other German supermarket chains as both filets and fish sticks.

Relative to 2006, 22 percent more Pangasius was shipped to Germany in 2007. And if importers have their way, the volume will continue to grow. But, if what the fishermen farming the fish halfway around the world say is true, there might not be as much Pangasius next year.

The Middle Man

One of the importers with a sense of what is happening to the Pangasius is Ulf Blaes. He is standing in a large building on the Mekong River with 1,500 women wearing numbers, white aprons, hoods and masks over their mouths. They look like doctors dissecting fish on long operating tables. "As a wholesaler," says Blaes, "you have to have Pangasius in your product line."

Blaes, a 49-year-old German businessman, runs the Food Company. He works as a middleman in the global food market whose job entails traveling around the world to transform the wishes of customers into demand and then convert the demand into supply. He buys fish from around the globe, including plaice from the world's oceans, zander from Kazakhstan, tuna, barramundi, swordfish and Pangasius from Vietnam.

Blaes mixes himself among the women to get a closer look at their work. Like them, he is wearing an apron, a hood and rubber boots. He travels to Vietnam six times a year to inspect the fish he is buying and the way they are farmed. Each trip involves flying from Germany to Ho Chi Minh City, driving six hours south in his dark Mercedes through small villages and on narrow roads, then taking a ferry across the enormous Mekong River to a fish farm owned by the Ntaco Corporation.

The fishermen arrive in their small boats to meet with Blaes behind the factory. They bring him fish in large tubs with water splashing from the top. The Pangasius industry is now responsible for the livelihoods of 5 million people. Workers in 34 plants can turn the fish into packaged fillets in two hours. The packages are then loaded into containers and shipped to 107 countries.

Blaes is the tallest person in the building and his head sticks out high above those of the Vietnamese workers. He wears canvas tennis shoes. Beneath his work coat, you can see his jeans, his untucked shirt and his Blackberry in his pocket. He uses the device often, reading and typing messages or making calls. His Blackberry connects him from here -- Long Xuyen, a city in the southern Vietnamese province of An Giang -- to the rest of the world. He also uses it to set prices and help him broker trades between the Mekong and the global community of consumers.

An example of the types of messages Blaes types into his Blackberry is: "Color: premium white or light pink. 120 to 230 grams. Five to no more than 10 percent protective glaze." The world wants a fish that is as standardized as a meat patty in a fast food restaurant. This is Blaes's goal -- and, on some days, his problem.

A fish is not an uncomplicated creature. It lives in a body of water that sometimes receives a lot of rain, and sometimes almost no rain at all. Sometimes there is a lot of oxygen in the water, and sometimes not much. Sometimes the fish does well, and sometimes it doesn't.

Global appetite and declining fish populations have made Pangasius a farmed species. But, for centuries, it remained a wild fish that traveled upstream to search for food along the riverbed.

As the fish grew and became more powerful, it reached lengths of up to 1.5 meters (five feet) and weights of up to 45 kilograms (100 pounds). When it was 3 or 4-years-old, it would leave the river's main tributary. The females would deposit their egg sacks and the males their sperm on tree roots in remote, flooded fields. Then, the fish would return to the Mekong and drift back downriver from Cambodia to Vietnam's Mekong Delta. Each year, 20-30 million fish would migrate into the delta region, where they were greeted by fishermen standing ready on the banks to catch the fish with fishing rods, nets and baskets.

French biologists were first to think about bringing the Pangasius onto the world market. They wanted to find out whether the fish could be cultivated, which entailed raising, feeding and breeding it. They wanted to intervene in the slow-moving course of nature.

The biologists built wooden cages, dug deep ponds and developed two species of the fish exclusively for farming purposes. The first was the Basa.

But the scientists soon realized that the Basa grew too slowly. It took an entire year before it weighed the two kilograms (4.4 pounds) it needed to go on the market, and it was also too fatty.

The Crisis of Falling Fish Prices

The second species they developed was the Tra, which spent most of its time swimming along the bottom of the river. But the Tra was a fast grower and only needed six months to reach the right weight. What's more, it also had little fat, was not susceptible to very many diseases, had white meat and was robust. By feeding the fish a mixture of rice bran and insects, the scientists coaxed it to the surface. This was the beginning of modern aquaculture in Vietnam and a new age, one in which an edible fish, the Pangasius, was added to the country's existing exports of coffee, cacao, pepper and crude oil.

Most of the fish went to the United States, that is, until American corn farmers -- who had themselves started farming Pangasius in flooded fields -- began protesting that Vietnamese producers were dumping their fish onto the market. Then, five years ago, the Pangasius-farming industry in the US successfully lobbied for legislation that slapped a 650 percent duty on Pangasius from Vietnam.

This made the American corn farmers happy, but now the Vietnamese fishermen needed a new market for their fish. They eventually found it halfway around the world and began exporting most of their fish to Russia, Spain, the Netherlands, Germany and Poland. In 2001, Vietnam exported 300,000 tons of fillets. Seven years later, that number had jumped to 2.1 million tons.

'Constantly Going Uphill'

The Pangasius transformed the Mekong Delta into a proud region -- and made many fishermen rich. It became a source of affluence and attracted farmers, craftsmen and laborers to the region, including Ky Anh, a businessman. "In the past," he says, "things were constantly going uphill with the fish."

While men work nearby, sawing wood on a Sunday morning, Anh sits at a table with a calculator. A sign on the side of the driveway, which leads down to the bank of the Mekong, reads: "Sawmill, Buying and Selling, Round Logs as Construction Material."

Anh pushes up his visor and sets out a tray of red lemonade and ice. His wife is sitting on a bench, her lips painted a bright red. They own a big car and a big house. Anh can't say whether the wood or the fish has been more profitable. "At first," he says, "I just provided the fishermen with wood for cages. Then I started farming myself."

Houses on stilts stand above the water at the point where the edge of the sawmill reaches the riverbank. Beneath these houses are cages full of fish, which grow so quickly that they have to be removed from the enclosures after only eight weeks. At this point, they are six months old and weigh about one kilogram (2.2 pounds), which makes their filets the perfect size: between 120 and 230 grams (four-to-eight ounces).

If the fish are not removed from the cages at this point, they will continue to grow until they reach a size at which no one wants them anymore -- not the local factory and certainly not brokers like Blaes.

'The Crisis'

"We are hoping for a good price," says Ky Anh.

The price early last year was 12,000 dong (€0.50; $0.65) per kilogram. By June, the price had gone up to 14,000 dong, but it was still too low. And, in November, it fell to 13,000 dong. The only problem, Anh says, is that farming Pangasius costs him 15,000 dong a kilogram.

In the past, he says, he could sometimes get 17,000 dong or even 18,000 Dong a kilogram. That was when the fish was still a success story, "before the crisis," as Anh says.

If you ask Anh where the crisis comes from, he doesn't know -- at least not exactly. He shrugs his shoulders and speculates that the problem might have something to do with inflation or the financial crisis. But one thing he is sure of is that part of the problem can be attributed to the cost of feed.

In the past, when the fishermen sold their catch at the local market in Chau Doc, they knew what drove prices up and down. But now that they produce for the world market, things have become too complex. For instance, the exchange rate is unsteady, and the dong has lost value against the dollar.

In the evening, when darkness descends over the Mekong, Anh returns to his big house and sits down in front his computer to look up prices online. The price of soybeans, the main type of feed for the fish, is up. The beans -- which are produced in the United States, Brazil, Argentina and China -- are a rich source of protein. But that's not a problem exclusive to the Pangasius farmed in Vietnam -- it also applies to other animals around the world, including the cattle used to produce the meat that goes into hamburgers sold at fast food restaurants. Likewise, the fact that soybeans are also used to make biodiesel is also driving prices up.

Each fish has to be fed for four months, and feed makes up 3,000 dong of the total per-kilogram cost. When the fish are six-months-old, the farmers are suddenly faced with the need to get rid of them as quickly as possible -- and at any price.

The Farmers Respond

On Sundays, while Anh goes to work early, the other fish farmers attend a 5 a.m. mass at Pastor Khoa's church, a white building near the river. The men wear light-colored shirts, and the women colorful dresses. Together, they sing, pray and ask for favors under a banner that reads: "Dear God, please answer my prayers."

Anh goes to Pastor Khoa's white church, too, but he does it in the afternoon. There, he prays and asks God for favors. "If things remain this bad," says Anh, "I too will have to shut down my business."

And now that the price of Pangasius has dropped by 3,000 dong per fish, a third of the fishermen in the countryside have given up.

But Anh and 800 other fishermen have kept at it. To protect themselves against the vagaries of the world market, they formed the An Giang Fisheries Association, a professional association of fish farmers and factory owners. The association offered courses, such as "Techniques for Egg Incubation," "Standards and Norms," "Protection against Disease without Antibiotics." The members knew that there were problems a few years ago, and they wanted to make their Pangasius even better and more profitable.

But none of this did any good because higher feed costs forced the fishermen to cut their fish populations in half. Nowadays, the An Giang Fisheries Association is bracing itself against world markets in an effort to safeguard Pangasius revenues.

From Feast to Famine

Le Chi Binh is the chairman of the An Giang Fisheries Association. Today, he is sitting in his office several kilometers downriver from the factory where Ulf Blaes, the German businessman, is inspecting fillets. If the association's plan to safeguard revenues doesn't succeed, Binh says, the fish that brought prosperity to the delta could quickly turn into a big problem for Mekong fishermen.

Smoking a cigarette, Binh looks out the window at the river. "Now we are trying to prevent a situation in which there will soon not be enough fish," he says. In other words, where there was once a surplus, there might soon be a shortage.

First the fishermen could disappear, he says, followed by the factory owners and, finally, by the fish.

Can Pangasius Survive?

"We have asked for help," Binh adds, referring to the association's request for donations in the summer and the petition it submitted to the government. The association wants the government to reduce interest rates. However, since Vietnam is a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO), which prohibits subsidies, this might be a difficult proposition. It also wants the government to order the banks to approve new loans to factory owners and fish farmers that they can use to buy new fish stocks.

In fact, at the moment, sales are so poor that, if they don't get these loans, the farmers and factory owners cannot continue to operate. The government, says Binh, should set a minimum price for the fish, adding that the association has proposed 14,200 dong each. He also points out that, at this price, the fishermen would still be losing money -- but at least it would be a start.

The High Price of Cheap

In recent years, as profits rose, the fishermen built themselves big red-brick houses on Tan Loc Island. Those who couldn't afford to live on the island referred to it as "Trillion-Dong Village." Today, the fishermen have become targets of ridicule because many are now -- unsuccessfully -- trying to sell their houses.

Ironically, the Mekong fishermen who had started out breeding a good variety of fish for consumers around the world now find themselves in the middle of the real-estate crisis.

Binh, who is also a former district secretary for the Communist Party, longs for the security that socialist Vietnam once offered the fishermen in the form of fixed prices -- but without the poverty. And Blaes, the fish broker, wants to force prices down even further so that he can buy cheap, good fish for customers in Germany and take advantage of the market. In addition to being at opposite ends of the market for Pangasius, Blaes and Binh represent two different worldviews.

Blaes says that he pays the factory $3.30 (€2.58) a kilogram. He also pays the laboratories that test the fish, duties and sea freight, which together costs him another €0.25 ($0.20) per kilo. He pays a lot for the fish, says Blaes, so that the world can eat inexpensive fish.

Blaes has put away his Blackberry and is now walking along the worktables, watching the Vietnamese women cut the fish into bite-size pieces for Germany's fish eaters.

He watches the still-living fish drop onto a conveyor belt and then onto the first table, where workers slice first into the gills, then along the spine. A third slice produces one fillet, a fourth the second. Then he walks past long tables where the women are cleaning the fish, removing the skin, the fat and their innards. The fillets are then tossed into small baskets, sorted by size and quality, and screened for red spots and blood. After inspection, the fish pieces are frozen on giant trays at minus 22 degrees Celsius (minus 8 degrees Fahrenheit) -- fillets next to fillets, white on white -- and packed into cardboard boxes, which are taken to the refrigeration building where they are stacked in storage rooms.

"We are scheduled to deliver 25 containers to Bremerhaven at the middle of the month," says Blaes, adding that he sends 3,500 tons a year to Germany. "Pangasius is inexpensive, too inexpensive for air freight," he says.

"At the moment, there is still enough fish," says Binh.

Michael Schulz arrives in Ho Chi Minh City on the same day Blaes is flying back to Germany. He is standing in the lobby of his hotel, showered and ready to go. He is about to head out to the countryside where, as he says, he wants to put his ear to the rail.

Schulz is from the western German city of Dortmund, where he is the head of HMF Food Production, a negotiator for Aldi, the discount supermarket chain and king of cheap food products.

"You look to see what's happening on the world market, and that's how we discovered Pangasius," Schulz says quickly, almost stumbling over his words. "It's certainly an attractive fish, especially when it comes to retail pricing."

For a long time, Schulz says, the fish was not consistent enough for a German discounter. "We need a stabile product," he says, "and that also applies to price." In other words, his company is looking for a fish that looks and tastes the same -- and costs the same -- 365 days a year. "We have this type of product now, an honest product," he says, referring to Pangasius and the fact that it is raised in water with no additives. It has no agents that make it absorb more water. It's all natural. It meets Greenpeace standards. And it comes in 500-gram (a little more than one pound) bags. "It's a beautiful bag," says Schulz.

Aldi's Aldi-South division has already tested Pangasius in some of its stores, "and customers want it," says Schulz. The fish, he says, is now ready -- ready for discounters, for Aldi and for the world. In that world, the borders are no longer an issue; but protection has vanished, too.

There is no longer any protection for fishermen like Ky Anh, who used to get eight cents for 100 grams of Pangasius. Today he earns six cents per 100 grams, which isn't enough to make farming the fish worth his while. Six cents for 100 grams. This is too little to guarantee the survival of the Pangasius, a species once lauded as the fish of the future.

But this is only one way of looking at the world. Another view is part of Michael Schulz's calculations.

If all goes according to plan, in 2009, Aldi will begin selling 500-gram bags of Pangasius in all of its German stores. Each bag will contain three to five fillets, which, with a 5 percent water content, comes to 475 grams of fish. A bag will cost €3.49 ($4.47), says Schulz.

That comes to retail price of 74 cents per 100 grams, or 25 cents less than the price of Pangasius at Manuela Wendland's fresh food counter.

Translated from the German by Christopher Sultan


Read more!

Southern Africa's freshwater species 'in peril'

Yahoo News 19 Mar 09;

ISTANBUL (AFP) – The world's leading conservation agency on Thursday said many species of freshwater fish, shellfish and insects in southern Africa were at threat from water extraction and habitat loss.

A study of 1,279 freshwater species across southern Africa found that 94 of them, or seven percent, are at risk of extinction, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) said at the World Water Forum in Istanbul.

"This figure will skyrocket unless species conservation is considered in development planning," the IUCN warned.

It said the study amounted to an alarm bell in a region where millions depend on rivers, lakes and wetlands for their food and on drinking water purified by aquatic organisms.

"The report is really about a battle for survival, between nature and economics," IUCN's director general, Julia Marton-Lefevre, said at a press conference.

Of the 94 threatened species, 78 are found in South Africa.

The study is one of six assessments of biodiversity in Africa that are being compiled by the IUCN.

Its goal is to identify areas of richness and species that are under threat, thus helping policymakers to answer questions about where human settlement, farming and water extraction should be allowed.

"We are in a unique position in Africa to avoid an extinction disaster," said Marton-Lefevre.

"Most developers have not taken freshwater species into consideration because they simply don't have the information they need... Africa's water resources can be developed without causing thousands of extinctions."

Loss of wetlands for agricultural use, introduced species and over-extraction of water are the main triggers for present species loss, while dam construction and the impacts of global warming loom as the major threats of the future.

William Darwall, manager of IUCN's freshwater biodiversity unit, said many people were unaware of the hidden value of freshwater fish, plants, shellfish and insects.

"Globally it's been valued in the trillions" of dollars, he said. "In Africa, 21 percent of the protein in people's diets is estimated to come from fisheries, so it's extremely important."

The report identifies three "hotspots" of species diversity that should be especially shielded.

These are: the area where the upper Zambezi meets the Kwando and Chobe rivers above Victoria Falls; the Komati and Crocodile river tributaries of the Incomati system in Mpumalanga, South Africa; and the Mbuluzi river basin in South Africa and Swaziland.

Southern Africa’s freshwater species in firing line
IUCN 19 Mar 09

Many freshwater fish, crabs, dragonflies, molluscs and aquatic plants are at risk of extinction in southern Africa if its rivers and lakes are not protected from developers, according to IUCN.

The study by the IUCN Species Programme, in collaboration with the South African Institute for Aquatic Biodiversity and the South African National Biodiversity Institute, shows that seven percent of species are known to be regionally threatened or extinct. But this figure will skyrocket unless freshwater species conservation is considered in development planning.

These species provide food for local people and some of them, such as the mollucs, help purify the drinking water. The study shows that while 77 percent of species are not threatened with extinction, there is not enough information for the remaining 16 percent to determine their threat status.

“Here at the World Water Forum the trend is to think about water supply in terms of irrigation, hydropower and drinking water,” says William Darwall, Manager of IUCN’s Freshwater Biodiversity Unit. "People tend to forget about the species that live in the water but we can no longer afford to do this. We want developers to use the information on the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species to work out how they can minimize the impact on freshwater species when they develop water resources.”

The results from the assessment of 1,279 freshwater species in southern Africa show that the more developed a country is, the more species are threatened with extinction. Of the 94 species threatened in southern Africa, 78 of these are found in South Africa, the most developed country in the region.

“We are in a unique position in Africa to avoid an extinction disaster,” says Julia Marton-Lefèvre, IUCN Director General. “Most developers have not taken freshwater species into consideration because they simply don’t have the information they need. We hope this study will change that and show that Africa’s water resources can be developed without causing thousands of extinctions.”

Three hotspots of species diversity have been highlighted in the report, including the area where the upper Zambezi meets the Kwando and Chobe rivers above Victoria Falls, the Komati and Crocodile river tributaries of the Incomati system in Mpumalanga, South Africa, and the Mbuluzi river basin, also in Mpumalanga, South Africa, and in Swaziland.

Many of southern Africa’s coastal drainages have sites which contain species that only occur in that area, including the Kunene and Kwanza rivers on the west coast of Angola, and the Rovuma and Pungwe and Buzi systems on the east coast of Mozambique.

“If we really want to save these species we must protect the rivers and lakes by looking at river basins as a whole,” says Mark Smith, Head of IUCN’s Water Programme. “We can’t just look at the parts that interest us economically or as natural areas. For our plans to work, we must manage them together, using all the tools we have to meet the needs of people and nature for water.”

The results of this report will be combined with similar studies currently being conducted in the rest of Africa. Case studies will be used to develop a series of Good Practice Guidelines to help developers and governments take freshwater species into consideration when planning water projects in Africa.

The full report is available here: http://cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/the_status_and_distribution_of_freshwater_biodiversity_in_southern_africa.pdf


Read more!

The Red Sea might save the Dead Sea

Douglas Hamilton, Reuters 19 Mar 09;

JERUSALEM (Reuters) - Abundant water from the Red Sea could replenish the shrinking Dead Sea if Jordan, Israel and the Palestinians decide to commission a tunnel north through the Jordanian desert from the Gulf of Aqaba.

The Red Sea-Dead Sea Water Conveyance project would supply the biggest desalination plant in the world, running on its own hydro-electric power and providing Jordan with enough water for the next 40-50 years. Israel and the Palestinian West Bank would also benefit.

A decision on whether to go ahead could come by the end of next year and the likely cost would be in the region of 7 billion dollars.

"The idea of linking the Red Sea and the Dead Sea was first suggested by a British military engineer in the 1880s. That was for hydro-power. But the drivers today are water supply and saving the Dead Sea," said engineer David Meehan , who leads the study team for French consultants Coyne et Bellier.

"Technically and engineering-wise it was always going to be feasible," he told Reuters. "But there are some major issues that could determine its feasibility ultimately."

Three potential systems are being examined: a buried pipeline, a low-level tunnel all the way, and a higher-level tunnel-and-canal system.

Two new feasibility studies are being commissioned by the World Bank this month, acting for the "beneficiary parties," Israel, Jordan and the Palestinian Authority.

If a tunnel is chosen, it would be about 7-8 meters in diameter. Red Sea water would take about 3-4 days to flow 168 km (105 miles), relying entirely on gravity and dropping some 400 meters below sea level, to the lowest point on earth, where the Dead Sea is rapidly retreating.

Some estimates say it could more or less dry up in 50 years if no action is taken. Its level is falling by about one meter (three feet) per year due to a sharp decrease in inflow from the Jordan and other rivers whose waters now irrigate fields and to Dead Sea chemical industry use by Israel and Jordan.

"The level has fallen from 394 meters below sea level in the 1960s to 420 meters below sea level as of mid-2007," said the World Bank. The water surface area is down by a third, from 950 square kilometers to 637 -- about the size of Lake Geneva.

DIFFERENT PRIORITIES

The World Bank said arresting the decline to avert an environmental calamity, and slowly topping up the sea, is the main priority.

"For Jordan it is a water-supply project," said Meehan. "While for Israel it has perhaps as much to do with regional politics. For them, desalinating Mediterranean water is much more practical."

Nearly half of the 2 billion cubic meters of water flowing north each year through the system would be desalinated and made potable. The brine would go into the Dead Sea, whose waters are 10 times more saline than the ocean.

The tunnel would be on Jordanian territory, following the line of the border with Israel. Jordan and Egypt, Israel's next-door neighbor in the Gulf of Aqaba, are the only two Arab countries which have full relations with the Jewish state, and the project in an earlier incarnation was quickly dubbed the "peace canal."

Meehan, who played an important role in the construction of Libya's "great, man-made river project" and other major infrastructure developments, said he "can't see the project being commissioned before 2020." But its feasibility could be established in a year to 18 months.

The main concerns are the effects on marine life in the Gulf of Aqaba of the extraction of such large volumes of water, the effects of that water mixing with the Dead Sea, and the funding of the project, said Meehan.

In addition, Israel has concerns about potential leakage polluting valuable freshwater aquifers in a desert region where it has developed world-leading techniques for cultivation, and "environmentalists don't like the idea of canals which cut off wildlife migration."

The Palestinians have not even asked formally for a share of the desalinated water, he said, possibly because they do not want to prejudice their existing claims to mountain aquifers" supplying the Israeli-occupied West Bank and the Jordan Valley.

"None of these issues can be separated from politics," he said, although both Jordan and Israel say they could go it alone. But that could involve a dispute in international law and funding would become scarce.

TURNING WHITE, THEN GREEN?

The World Bank this month called for tenders on two additional studies to assess the main environmental, and oceanographic issues.

"The outcome of mixing of these two water bodies over a time scale of decades is unknown and is difficult to model and predict," noted the bank's March 13 draft study preamble.

"Clearly, the Dead Sea will change its composition and characteristics as they are known today or were in the past if it receives large volumes of water from the Red Sea."

Some environmentalist critics warn that tampering with nature on such an unprecedented scale could bring disaster: the Dead Sea mighty turn white as gypsum sediment precipitates, then green as microbial blooms flourish.

The studies should determine if these fears are justified. They will also assess the "do nothing" option, modeling the Dead Sea of 2060.

At a March 5 meeting in the sleepy Israeli Dead Sea resort of Ein Gedi, the beneficiary countries stated their continued support for the project "and urged that it continue to be implemented on an accelerated basis."

Meehan said he had encountered a number of amusing suspicions in his meetings with locals along the projected routes, including a Jordanian who wondered if it was an Israeli plot to realize a Talmudic prophecy that "one day fish will swim in the Dead Sea."

At present, there are only microbial forms of life in the famously buoyant waters, where visitors taking a dip can keep their newspapers intact as they read in the sun and float, high and dry.

The Scottish-born engineer said screening and filtration would remove marine life at the Gulf of Aqaba entry to the system, and treatment would remove tiny microbes at the desalination end, so the water entering the Dead Sea would be sterile.

(Editing by Peter Millership)

Shrinking Dead Sea may lose "natural wonders" bid
Douglas Hamilton, Reuters 19 Mar 09;

JERICHO, West Bank (Reuters) - A red light flashes over the Dead Sea entry on a website inviting people to vote for the world's top natural wonders, warning: "this nominee is situated in more than one country."

There is no rule against that, but a chance the shrinking sea can win any votes in the election at www.new7wonders.com will vanish if all three countries involved do not each form an "Official Supporting Committee" by July 7.

Either due to bureaucracy or politics, two states are delaying -- which may jeopardize prospects for the famously buoyant lake, about the same size as Lake Geneva, whose level is dropping at nearly one meter a year.

To date, only Israel has a committee. Jordan and the Palestinian Authority have just over three months to make sure the Dead Sea is one of 77 second-round nominees selected, from which a shortlist of 21 finalists will be chosen.

"We're not sure why there's a delay," said Tia Viering, the communications chief for the contest, known as N7W. "The Dead Sea would have a very good chance if nominated, but we can't talk to a lake, and time is running out."

Jordan benefited handsomely from an election in 2007 of seven New Wonders of the World: visits to the ancient ruins of nearby Petra rose by more than 100 percent after it was chosen, said Suleiman Farajat of the Jordanian archaeological park.

Israeli organizer Seffi Hanegbi has no doubts about the reason for delay. "It's 100 percent politics," he said. "We have to have a meeting of the three official representatives. But if the Palestinians know there's a representative from Israel they won't come," he fears.

"It was a mistake to seek official approval at government level. Mayors or NGOs would have had it done by now," he said. It was also a mistake to involve an Israeli council located in the occupied West Bank, and covering Jewish settlements considered illegal by the Palestinians and the United Nations.

Appreciating the Dead Sea valley should be above politics, Hanegbi says.

It has had a place in human history for thousands of years. Some consider it the cradle of civilization -- where the Biblical cities Sodom and Gomorrah, on the faultline between two tectonic plates, were destroyed by God for their wickedness -- where Lot's wife was turned into a pillar of salt.

POTENTIAL RETURNS

Barely a half-hour's drive from the Old City of Jerusalem, downhill all the way to the lowest spot on earth, the traveler finds water 10 times more saline than the ocean. Sunset on the sandstone bluffs of the Jordan Rift Valley frames the sea between towering walls of shifting pastel color.

N7W expects one billion people to vote online in 2010-11 to chose the seven wonders of nature: "This is a low-involvement project for them that has great potential returns," Viering said. Letters to the Palestinians and Jordanians stressed that point and urged quick action.

But in the West Bank, the Palestinians said they were still awaiting clarification before the government could approve.

"In principle we do not have a problem," said Palestinian Authority Tourism Minister Khouloud Daibes. "We are waiting to hear the details and if they have conditions."

"Once we get that, the government should approve it ... I do not think there will be a problem. It's not a political issue."

Viering believes the delays in Amman and Ramallah are purely bureaucratic and will not prove insurmountable.

"The Jordanians have been incredibly enthusiastic and supportive in the past so I expect it will go ahead," she said.

But Hanegbi says if the Palestinians balk for political reasons, Jordan too may fold its hands out of Arab solidarity.

A MUCH TOUGHER PROJECT

Petra and the Dead Sea are a day's drive from each other, and both lie in easy reach of the Gulf of Aqaba's famed Red Sea beach resorts and crystal clear, coral-reef diving waters.

Israel's Hanegbi believes in the power of cross-border tourism to foster peace. In the 1990s he organized camel treks on ancient routes in the region.

Exploiting the business, environmental and tourist potential of such natural assets, and getting around man-made borders is "making peace instead of just talking peace," he says.

He is also striving to enter the Red Sea as a "wonders of nature" candidate: a task requiring endorsement from eight littoral states -- Israel, Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Eritrea, Yemen and Djibouti.

Viering believes the delay in the Dead Sea's nomination is simply a bureaucratic glitch. But if not, it could be bad news for any broader rescue project that would require long-term commitment, investment and the approval of Red Sea states.

The real red light flashing for the Dead Sea is the fact it is slowly but surely drying up and could be gone in 50 years if no action is taken.

A sharp decrease in inflow from the Jordan and other rivers whose waters now irrigate fields is curbing its water supply: the level in mid-2007 had fallen to 420 meters below sea level from 394 meters in the 1960s, says the World Bank.

As a result, the water surface area has shrunk by one third.

Arresting the decline to avert environmental calamity, and slowly topping up the sea while supplying more water to this parched region are the main aims of an ambitious rescue project.

The "Red Sea-Dead Sea Water Conveyance Project," promoted by Jordan and Israel and endorsed by the Palestinians, would carry water over a 180 km (112 mile) tunnel-canal route probably visible from space.

First suggested 100 years ago, it is still in the "feasibility study" phase. Two additional studies are now about to begin, one assessing how the waters of the two seas would mix, a second looking at the ecological impact on the Red Sea.

The reports are due in 18 months. By then -- provided the Jordanian and Palestinian committees have formed in time -- the Dead Sea may have been chosen a natural wonder of the world.

(Additional reporting by Mohammed Assadi)

(Editing by Sara Ledwith)


Read more!

Asia Climate Policy On Track

Krittivas Mukherjee, PlanetArk 19 Mar 09;

NEW DELHI - Asia's biggest carbon emitters face dual challenges this year that risk undermining their fight against climate change -- a global recession that's crippling domestic business and elections in a pivotal year.

For the moment, however, there is little to suggest they've lost their pace in the drive to embrace cleaner energy policies, or a souring of goodwill toward achieving a broader climate pact at the end of the year to replace the Kyoto Protocol.

Even in Australia, where growing political opposition is threatening the world's most sweeping cap-and-trade system, the government has staked its reputation on getting the scheme through parliament in coming months.

Elsewhere in Asia, the drive toward clean energy seems just as strong.

For China, the world's top carbon polluter, going green makes good business sense.

South Korea thinks the same, while Indian political parties are set to roll out climate change manifestos ahead of elections.

Indonesia has backed a U.N. scheme that could curb deforestation in return for billions of dollars in carbon credits, while India and China have snared the highest number of U.N.-backed clean-energy projects that also yield carbon credits.

As green investment grows, along with signs of accelerating climate change, pressure is rising on nations to seal a broader and tougher post-Kyoto framework in December during U.N.-led talks in the Danish capital, Copenhagen.

"There will be a deal because there is a will for a deal this time around," one of India's top climate negotiators told Reuters on condition of anonymity. He is still in the process of drafting New Delhi's stance for a year-end U.N. climate meeting.

The election of U.S. President Barack Obama has also helped keep Asia's green policy plans on track after he pledged to rein in the United States' greenhouse gas pollution, fund green investment and backed carbon cap-and-trade.

Emerging economies in Asia were more likely to use the financial crisis to help them shift into low-carbon development than developed countries, said Kim Carstensen, director of environmental group WWF's Global Climate Initiative.

Asian economies were directing more of their investment cash toward new infrastructure and factories. They also expected at least part of their climate change efforts to be paid for by rich nations.

"If and when that happens, there are few reasons to choose the dirtier alternatives," Carstensen told Reuters from Copenhagen.

STEELING ASIAN RESOLVE

What the United States does between now and then is crucial.

"If the U.S., under Obama's leadership, rigorously pursues a post-Kyoto Protocol that requires the U.S. itself to significantly reduce their own emissions, this is likely to steel the resolve of Asian nations to do likewise," said Australian climate policy and development expert Matthew Clarke.

"A weak U.S. position will undermine any current goodwill that may exist in Asia to act in the interest of the world," added Clarke, of the School of International and Political Studies at Deakin University in Melbourne.

Asia has three of the world's top five greenhouse gas emitters -- China, India and Japan -- plus industrial powers Australia and South Korea as well as Indonesia, where deforestation and forest fires are a major source of planet-warming pollution.

India, Indonesia and Japan all face elections, but analysts say any changes of government will unlikely upset existing climate policies.

In India and Indonesia, for instance, climate change is not yet a major domestic policy issue.

Japan's Prime Minister Taro Aso has pledged to release mid-term targets for emissions cuts by June while the opposition Democrats have pledged to ramp up spending on clean energy as a way to boost the economy and wants tough emissions reduction targets for 2020.

"The Democrats have been eager on the issue of fighting climate change, so if they win the election, policies are expected to move forward," said Mikiko Kainuma, chief of the climate policy assessment research section at the National Institute for Environmental Studies in Japan.

MAJOR CHALLENGES

Imposing tougher emissions curbs on Japanese industry, though, could be a major challenge for whoever holds office after earlier energy efficiency efforts and years of slow growth.

Of Asia's top emitters, Japan was most worried about imposing extra costs on its industries during a recession, said Mark Kenber, policy director of The Climate Group, a British-based NGO that advises governments and businesses on how to pursue a low-carbon future.

Australia also faces risks to its emissions cap-and-trade legislation. The conservative opposition says it should be delayed because of the recession.

The Greens are pulling in the other direction, saying the government's target to cut emissions by 5-15 percent by 2020 is too soft. Changes to the laws are highly likely before parliament finally backs the scheme, set to start mid-2010.

India, the world's fourth largest carbon polluter, goes to the polls starting next month and the ruling Congress party and the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party say they are working on their inaugural climate change manifestos.

This could affect international climate negotiations before December, mainly because India would be too distracted by the weeks-long polls and forming a new government, Carstensen said.

"I don't believe this will be a deal-breaker issue. India is well-prepared to be a very strong player in the second half of 2009, but it certainly does not make things easier," he said.

Indonesia's position on wanting large amounts of aid to protect its forests and clean up its industries was unlikely to change after this month's election, Kenber said.

All the major emitters in Asia understood they needed to act on climate change, he said, but each differed in their approach.

"China certainly gets it. Acting on climate change can be a source of prosperity," Kenber said, pointing to China being a leading solar panel and wind turbine parts maker.

"I think they are seeing opportunities through acting on climate change and becoming a supplier of the parts that make up a low-carbon economy for the rest of the world," he added.

A concern, though, was rich nations meeting their funding obligations for finance, technology transfer and climate change mitigation because of the recession.

Zhang Haibin, a Chinese climate expert, said there could be U.S. opposition to any plan to give China huge funds and clean-energy technology.

"'Here we are in a financial crisis and China is getting richer, so why are we giving them all of this?' -- That will be a very powerful factor," Haibin said.

(Writing by David Fogarty; Additional reporting by Chris Buckley and Emma Graham-Harrison in Beijing; Chisa Fujioka in Tokyo; Ed Davies in Jakarta and David Fogarty in Singapore; Editing by Bill Tarrant)


Read more!

Warming to speed Antarctica icesheet collapse

Marlowe Hood Yahoo News 18 Mar 09;

PARIS (AFP) – Manmade climate change is set to hasten the disintegration of a massive ice sheet in Antarctica by 100,000 years, boosting sea levels some five metres (16 feet), according to a pair of studies published Thursday.

The research, which matches new ice core data with a simulation of past and future changes in the West Antarctica Ice Sheet (WAIS), reveals for the first time regular cycles of "catastrophic collapse" and reformation reaching back five million years.

Cycles lasted 40,000 years during the first three-fifths of this period, but have since more than doubled in length, explained David Pollard, a scientist at Pennsylvania State University and lead author of one of the studies.

"But with global warming we are cutting short a natural cycle," he told AFP by phone.

"The two studies combined show it is really likely that the WAIS will collapse in the next few thousand years. In the absence of human influence, it would probably happen only 100,000 years from now," he said.

Rising sea levels is arguably the most serious long-term threat from climate change.

The global ocean water mark is likely to go up by at least a metre before the end of the century, recent research has shown.

That is enough to wipe out several small island nations, and to disrupt or displace tens of millions of people living in heavily-populated and low-lying delta areas in East Asia, African and the Indian subcontinent.

Part of that rise will come from thermal expansion as ocean temperatures rise, a process scientists understand well and are able to forecast.

But the world's two great ice sheets sitting atop Greenland and Antarctica remain climate change wild cards, with great uncertainty as to whether -- or how quickly -- they might shed their mass.

A team of more than 50 scientists led by Tim Naish of Victoria University in Wellington, New Zealand extracted sediment samples reaching 600 metres below the surface of the WAIS.

The findings showed a geological metronome of massive change across five million years, and provided the first direct evidence of total collapse.

"Before there were hints of it collapsing like that, but we really didn't know until now," said Pollard, a co-author of the study, published in Nature.

The new data also confirmed that the cycles of ice destruction and formation are closely linked to shifts in the tilt of Earth's axis as it rotates around the Sun, a process called obliquity.

The period covered by the sediment samples -- the early Pliocene -- is of special interest to climate scientists because it so closely resembles the conditions forecast for Earth over the next 100 years.

With global temperatures set to rise about 3.0 degrees Celsius (5.4 degrees Fahrenheit) by 2100, "more significance is being placed on the early Pliocene as an analogue for understanding the future behaviour of the WAIS and its contribution to global sea levels," the study says.

The concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere -- some 400 parts per million (ppm) -- was also in line with projected 21st century levels, which have already hit 385 ppm and are still rising.

In the second study, Pollard and Robert DeConto of the University of Massachusetts in Amherst simulate Antarctic ice sheet variations in a mathematical model over the past five million years in order to track the "grounding line", the shifting border between land and sea ice.

"We found that the dominant mechanism attacking the West Antarctic ice has been variations in ocean melting under its large floating ice shelves," rather than changes in temperature or surface melt, Pollard said.

"One of the next steps is to determine if human activity will make it warm enough to start the collapse," said Pollard.

Antarctic Ice Close To Melting Tipping Point-Study
Michael Perry, PlanetArk 19 Mar 09;

SYDNEY - A large part of the ice covering West Antarctica could be lost if greenhouse gases in the atmosphere increase only slightly from today's levels and ocean temperatures continue to rise, a study released on Thursday says.

Another related study said if the West Antarctic ice sheet collapsed and the East Antarctic ice sheet continued to melt at its marine margins, global sea level would rise seven meters from today's level.

Antarctica stores about 90 percent of the world's freshwater.

Both studies, published in the journal Nature, are a result of extensive drilling into the seafloor under the Ross Ice Shelf by a team of New Zealand, Italian, American and Germany scientists.

The floating ice shelf won't elevate sea levels if melts because it is already displacing water. The real threat comes when the ice sheet behind, which is below sea level, is exposed to the ocean.

The 50-plus core samples, down to 1.2 kilometers (0.7 mile), allowed the scientists to study how previous periods of rising carbon dioxide affected ocean temperatures, ice movements and sea levels.

The cores showed the West Antarctic ice sheet in the Ross Embayment area collapsed and reformed every 40,000 years. It has collapsed 38 times in the past 5 million years.

"Most of it sits below sea level and is very vulnerable to rising ocean and atmospheric temperatures," Tim Naish, Director of Victoria University's Antarctic Research Center in Wellington, said in a briefing on the drilling study.

RISKS

The seabed drill samples also showed changes in the tilt of Earth's axis, placing polar regions toward and away from the Sun, had played a major role in ocean warming and cycles of growth and retreat of the West Antarctic ice sheet, between three to five million years ago, said the scientists.

Around four million years ago, rising carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere, to around 400 parts per million, enhanced the warming effect of the tilt cycles, they said.

"Carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere is again approaching 400 parts per million," said Naish. It is currently around 387 ppm, up from about 280 ppm since the start of the Industrial Revolution.

"Geological archives, such as the ANDRILL (Antarctic drilling) core, highlight the risk that a significant body of permanent Antarctic ice could be lost...as earth's climate continues to warm," said Naish.

Computer modeling of ice sheet behavior and the drilling data found that the ice shelves protecting the West Antarctic ice sheet could disappear in centuries and the majority of the ice sheet could collapse within a thousand years, said Naish.

A study by Pennsylvania State University in the United States said computer modeling based on the core drilling found that oceanic warming was the primary driver of ice sheet melt and that a five degrees Celsius rise was enough to collapse the West Antarctic ice sheet.

The modeling showed that when the West Antarctic ice sheet collapsed, and the much larger East Antarctic ice sheet continued to melt at the edges, global sea level rose seven meters above present day levels, said Pennsylvania University's David Pollard, who led the study.

The two studies have given scientists an insight into Antarctica's glacial history in the early to middle Pliocene period, between 5 million and 3 million years ago, when the earth's temperatures were in the range of those projected for the coming centuries, said an accompanying Nature article.

It said it might take several centuries for the ocean to warm five degrees Celsius, a temperature required to generate enough ice shelf melting to cause significant retreat of the West Antarctic ice sheet.

"But such an outcome could result from the accumulation of total greenhouse-gas emissions projected for the 21st Century, if emissions are not greatly reduced," said the article.

(Editing by David Fogarty)

Temperature Rise May Trigger West Antarctic Thaw
Alister Doyle, PlanetArk 19 Mar 09;

OSLO - The West Antarctic ice sheet may start to collapse if sea temperatures rise by 5 degrees Celsius (9 degrees Fahrenheit), triggering a thaw that would raise world ocean levels by 5 meters (16 ft), U.S. scientists said.

Such a rise in sea levels -- taking thousands of years -- would swamp many coasts and cities and wipe some low-lying Pacific islands off the map.

West Antarctica, the part of the frozen continent most vulnerable to climate change, has thawed several times in the past few million years, most recently 400,000 years ago, according to Thursday's edition of the journal Nature.

The study "suggests the Western Antarctic ice sheet will begin to collapse when nearby ocean temperatures warm by roughly 5 C," David Pollard of Pennsylvania State University and Robert DeConto of the University of Massachusetts wrote.

The study helps plug big gaps in understanding Antarctica's likely reaction to modern global warming by improving knowledge of the history of the ice.

Pollard told Reuters the 5 C estimate for triggering a collapse was a rough guide, based on an computer model. The bigger East Antarctic ice sheet had not thawed in past warm periods studied.

The U.N. Climate Panel has projected a best estimate that world atmospheric temperature will rise by between 1.8 and 4.0 Celsius by 2100 because of emissions of greenhouse gases that could bring floods, droughts, heatwaves and more powerful storms.

Higher rises were possible unless the world reined in the growth of emissions, it said. Oceans temperatures lag far behind the rise in air temperatures.

"The required ocean warmings, of the order of 5 Celsius, may well take several centuries to develop," wrote Philippe Huybrechts of Vrije University in Brussels in a commentary.

"But such an outcome could result from the accumulation of total greenhouse-gas emissions projected for the twenty-first century, if emissions are not greatly reduced," he wrote.

A related paper in Nature suggested that past collapses of the West Antarctic ice were linked to the earth's rotation.

"The pattern of collapse suggests an influence of 40,000-year cycles in the tilt of Earth's rotational axis," Nature said of the study led by scientists in New Zealand.

(Editing by Matthew Jones)


Read more!

$750 billion "green" investment could revive economy: U.N.

Alister Doyle, Reuters 19 Mar 09;

OSLO (Reuters) - Investments of $750 billion could create a "Green New Deal" to revive the world economy and protect the environment, perhaps aided by a tax on oil, the head of the U.N. environment agency said on Thursday.

Achim Steiner said spending should focus on five environmental sectors including improved energy efficiency for buildings and solar or wind power to create jobs, curb poverty and fight climate change.

"The opportunity must not be lost," Steiner, head of the U.N. Environment Program (UNEP), told Reuters of a UNEP study that will be put to world leaders meeting in London on April 2 to work out how to spur the ailing economy.

The UNEP report said investments of one percent of global gross domestic product, or about $750 billion, could bankroll a "Global Green New Deal" inspired by the "New Deal" of U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt that helped end the depression of the 1930s.

Investments should be split between more energy efficient buildings, renewable energies, better transport, improved agriculture and measures to safeguard nature -- such as fresh water, forests or coral reefs, it said.

Thursday's study adds details of spending after UNEP called for a Green New Deal late last year.

Steiner also said that the world urgently needed funds to jump start a U.N. deal to fight global warming, due to be agreed in Copenhagen in December to succeed the U.N.'s Kyoto Protocol beyond 2012.

He floated the possibility of taxing oil in rich nations of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) to help a new pact become the cornerstone of a greener economy.

"If, for argument's sake, you were to put a five-year levy in OECD countries of $5 a barrel, you would generate $100 billion per annum. It translates into roughly 3 cents per liter," he said.

UNNOTICED

"It would be almost, if not totally, unnoticed by the consumer," he said, especially since oil prices have fallen from more than $140 a barrel at mid-2008 peaks to about $40.

A barrel of oil contains 158 liters and OECD consumption is about 20 billion barrels a year, he said. "This is just one example, there may be many others," of funding, he said.

"I am concerned about the prospect of a meaningful deal in Copenhagen if there is not a significant financial package on the table," he said. Cash would encourage poor nations to step up actions to curb rising greenhouse gas emissions.

"The argument that we cannot afford this does not, on any serious analysis, hold much water -- especially given the cost to the global economy of failure to act on climate change," he said.

Carbon markets, which could also be a source of funds to help fight climate change, were unlikely to contribute enough cash in early years of a new climate deal, he said.

Steiner said there were promising signs that economic stimulus packages by many nations, ranging from the United States to China, were being tailored to help a shift toward greener growth and away from dependence on fossil fuels.

The U.N. Climate Panel says that greenhouse gases from burning fossil fuels are a prime cause of warming that will cause more heatwaves, droughts, rising sea levels and more powerful storms.

(Editing by Jon Boyle)

Green investment solution to global crisis
Yahoo News 19 Mar 09;

NAIROBI (AFP) – Investing one percent of global output into five key sectors could achieve a "Green New Deal" and drive the world's recovery from the financial crisis, the United Nations said Thursday.

In a policy brief launched ahead of next month's crucial G20 meeting in London, the UN's environment programme (UNEP) said 750 billion dollars of green investments could cure the world's ailing economy.

"The report fleshes out the multiple economic, environmental and social benefits of investing a significant amount of the three trillion dollars worth of stimulus packages in five areas," UNEP said in a statement.

The keys sectors are energy efficiency in buildings, renewable energies such as wind and solar, sustainable transport such as hybrid vehicles and high-speed rail, protection of ecological infrastructure such as freshwaters and forests, and sustainable agriculture.

"The G20 meeting needs to be a milestone in terms of focusing investments that address the crises of today and those emerging from climate change, natural resource scarcity and lack of decent employment for close to two billion unemployed or underemployed people over the coming decade," UNEP executive director Achim Steiner said.

Steiner, who is also UN under secretary-general, cited the example of energy use in buildings, arguing it could be cut by 80 percent using existing technologies.

He said additional investments in the sector had the potential to reinvigorate the industry and create 3.5 million "green jobs" in the United States and Europe alone.

In what it has termed the great recession, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) said Thursday that the global economy could shrink in 2009 for the first time in 60 years.

As countries launch billion-dollar packages to rescue their economies, Steiner said the time was ideal to operate a shift towards a greener global economy.

"The large scale stimulus investments planned over the coming months and the next two to four years represent a once in a life time opportunity to make a transition to a low carbon, resource efficient society -- this opportunity must not be lost," he said.


Read more!

Obama puts up $2.4 bln for electric vehicles

Yahoo News 19 Mar 09;

POMONA, California (AFP) – President Barack Obama Thursday unveiled a 2.4 billion dollar boost for electric vehicle development, vowing to compete with foreign nations in the race to be world leader on renewable energy.

"We can let the jobs of tomorrow be created abroad or we can create them here in America and lay the foundation for lasting prosperity," Obama said on the second day of a campaign-style swing in California.

Obama said the money would be used to develop next generation plug-in hybrid electric vehicles and advanced battery components and would create tens of thousands of US jobs and reduce reliance on foreign oil.

He set a target of putting a million of the environmentally friendly vehicles on US roads by 2015.

The plan would also give a 7,500 dollar tax credit to people who buy plug-in hybrid vehicles, Obama said, as he toured a plant in southern California developing the new generation transport.

"The nation that leads on energy will be the nation that leads the world in the 21st century," Obama said.

"That's why, around the world, nations are racing to lead in these industries of the future."

The president bemoaned the fact that the United States lagged behind some of its key European and Asian trading partners in the race to develop new generation fuels and vehicles.

"Germany is leading the world in solar power," he said.

"Spain generates almost 30 percent of its power by harnessing the wind, while we manage less than one percent and Japan is producing the batteries that currently power American hybrid cars."

The funds, dispersed by the Department of Energy, will offer up to 1.5 billion dollars to US manufacturers who produce highly efficient batteries and 500 million dollars for firms that produce other components for the vehicles.

A further 400 million dollars will be devoted to evaluating plug in hybrids and building the infrastructure they need to run, including charging stations and training for technicians who will be called upon to repair them.

The funds were made available under Obama's 787 billion dollar economic stimulus law.


Read more!

Copenhagen aims to be carbon neutral by 2025

Yahoo News 19 Mar 09;

COPENHAGEN (AFP) – The city of Copenhagen, which will host a UN climate conference in December, aims to become the world's first carbon neutral capital in 2025, city officials said on Thursday.

Copenhagen aims to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 20 percent by 2015 and be carbon neutral by 2025 by increasing the use of renewable energies.

"It's an ambitious plan, but we want to accomplish our goal in order to help stop global warming by significantly reducing CO2 emissions," the deputy mayor in charge of environmental issues, Klaus Bondam, told AFP.

Since it is nearly impossible to eliminate all CO2 emissions, being carbon neutral means that the city can offset its emissions by investing in Kyoto Protocol-style projects that reduce pollution elsewhere.

Urging Copenhagen residents, businesses and energy suppliers to cooperate with the municipality in the fight for a "green capital", Bondam said the 2025 date was realistic.

"We know that there is a cost, but we are ready to pay it because this is an investment in the future," he said, adding that the city's residents were well-positioned to reach the goal.

They "increasingly choose environmentally-friendly solutions, such as riding their bikes or the bus instead of taking the car," he said.

"Today, about 40 percent of Copenhagen residents ride their bikes to work, and they emit less carbon dioxide than residents in the rest of the country," he said.

The city's action plan comprises 50 concrete initiatives, including plans for the capital's electricity to come from wind power and for its cars to run on electricity or hydrogen.

The city council is scheduled to vote on the plan this summer.

Neighbouring Norway and Sweden have previously announced ambitious plans for their entire countries to be carbon neutral in 2030 and 2050 respectively.


Read more!

Global Carbon Price Unlikely For 10-15 Years: Analysts

Nina Chestney, PlanetArk 19 Mar 09;

COPENHAGEN - A single global price for carbon emissions is not likely for another 10 to 15 years because governments are dragging their heels on legislation, market analysts said on Wednesday.

"By 2025, we could have one single currency," orbeo carbon analyst Emmanuel Fages said at a Point Carbon emissions trading conference in Copenhagen.

The European Union's executive Commission hopes to have a global carbon market in which emissions trading schemes are linked by 2020. It wants to see national schemes in all OECD countries by 2013 and for those to be linked by 2015.

Cap-and-trade schemes force participants, often energy-intensive industries, to buy permits to emit greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, which is produced from burning fossil fuels.

Analysts said a global carbon market would help achieve real emissions cuts in planet-warming greenhouse gases, but the EU's goals were too ambitious and a global price for carbon would only emerge in 2015-20.

"The big issue is the Commission wants to link with the U.S. by 2015. That looks incredibly ambitious," Trevor Sikorski, an analyst at Barclays Capital, said.

Schemes around the world include a regional scheme in the United States called the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative and a voluntary market in Japan.

Australian emissions trading is set to start in 2010 despite a government inquiry and growing opposition to the scheme. Canada is also aiming to launch one in 2010 even though it lacks government legislation. New Zealand has put carbon trading plans on ice after the election of a new government late last year.

A U.S. cap-and-trade bill is being negotiated, with carbon permit auctions by government expected to start from 2013.

In his latest budget proposals, U.S. President Barack Obama expects to generate some $646 billion in revenues from these auctions between 2013 and 2020.

TOO MANY HURDLES?

Linking the schemes in different countries would be complicated but it is thought a single market would help drive deeper emissions cuts and lead to more investment in renewable energy.

The participation of the United States, the most polluting developed nation, would be crucial to achieve a global emissions market, market analysts said.

Legislation will need to be sent to the U.S. Congress within the next few months to stand any chance of being enacted in time for regulators to draw up scheme details by 2012, analysts said, adding that even when the scheme emerges and can be linked to other schemes, there will still be hurdles to overcome.

"Price expectations under a U.S. scheme are fundamentally different to what you expect for the EU. European prices will likely be higher," Sikorski said. "So if the schemes were linked by 2015, that would mean a one-way flow of (carbon permits) from the U.S. to Europe."

The United States could also seek to use a global market to its own advantage.

"The U.S. will seek to reserve the right to change its mind over things. There is a risk of the U.S. increasing or decreasing (offset) imports via linking with the EU. Rather than complete convergence, I rather see a high correlation among carbon assets," said Will Babler at First Capitol.

(Editing by Michael Szabo and Sue Thomas)


Read more!

Soil neglected asset in greenhouse gas fight
Gerard Wynn, Reuters 19 Mar 09;

BEDFORD, England (Reuters) - John Ibbett and pigs go back a long way. "The pig manager pushed me round in a pram," recalls Ibbett, whose family have been farming on the same site since 1939.

Now he's proud his family farm can turn muck into electricity, using new technology paid for by a multi-million pound windfall. His Bedfordia Group is one of only a handful of companies with farm-based biogas plants in Britain.

Scientists complain that the world has so far failed to support agriculture in the fight against climate change, focusing instead on more visible emissions from factories and power plants.

Ibbett raised part of the cash for his multi-million, three-year-old venture from a property sale far beyond the reach of most family-owned farms. Although his is a rarity in Britain, more biogas plants are being established in Denmark, Germany and developing countries.

That momentum could be a precursor for much bigger climate benefits, from changing farming methods to use the soil's capacity to store vast amounts of carbon. Experts say this is an area so far almost entirely ignored by policymakers.

Soils as well as trees can suck carbon out of the air, boosting what experts call terrestrial carbon. Farmers can nurture carbon underground as well as crops above by using longer rotations, not over-grazing pasture and plowing less.

Ibbett's plant, 90 km (56 miles) north of London, traps methane emissions from food and farm waste in giant vats and then burns the powerful greenhouse gas to produce electricity, so preventing it from reaching the atmosphere.

Farmers are famously not short of ideas on how to make money and the managing director of Bedfordia Group's farming business is turning his marketing skills to a climate premium.

Trying to sell part of the farm's annual production of 23,000 pigs for bacon to supermarket group J. Sainsbury, Ian Smith estimates the Bedfordia pigs are one-third less carbon-emitting than others.

First, the methane emissions from their manure is trapped and burned. Second, the electricity produced replaces high-carbon power. Third, the final product is a soil additive which displaces more energy-intensive nitrogen fertilizer.

"They like the concept of a low-carbon pig, but even with our size of business it's quite difficult," Smith said of the supermarket's response so far, referring to economies of scale the supermarket seeks.

GLAMOUR

Low-carbon pigs may not easily fly, but directly curbing greenhouse gas emissions from farming is important. Farming contributes as much to global warming as all the world's planes, cars and trucks, and that will increase as the world tries to feed an extra 3 billion people by 2050.

Scientists also want more focus especially on the soil at U.N. climate talks which resume in two weeks' time in Bonn and are meant to thrash out by December a new climate treaty to replace the Kyoto Protocol.

In addition, academics have revived interest in a millennium-old technology to plough into the soil a carbon-rich type of charcoal made from heating plant, food or animal waste, called biochar.

"I think we're already beyond the safe level of greenhouse gas concentrations and the difference could be met through this terrestrial carbon approach," said Thomas Lovejoy, biodiversity chair at the Heinz Center for Science, Economics and the Environment.

The sticks and carrots policymakers use to drive the climate fight have so far almost exclusively focused on energy.

But soil could store as much as one-tenth of all the carbon that households and industry spew into the atmosphere, and so buy time in a gradual, global shift away from fossil fuels.

One reason the sector has not yet captured the public imagination may be that pig manure and soil are not the stuff of public relations dreams.

"Politicians can understand planting a tree and watching it grow...that it removes the carbon dioxide from the atmosphere," said Pete Smith, lead author for agriculture on the U.N.'s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. "In agriculture, it's not immediately visible."

All plants including trees and crops draw carbon dioxide out of the air as they grow, but trees, not soil, have been a focus for this. Farming is deep in the shadow of forests at U.N. climate talks aimed at agreeing a new treaty.

"If you look across all the (economic) sectors together, farming has equivalent mitigation potential to the energy sector and to transport and industry," added Smith. "We really need to get agriculture in there (the climate talks)."

1 BILLION TONNES

Farming accounts for half of all man-made methane emissions worldwide -- from ruminant livestock such as cows and sheep and from stored manures -- and 60 percent of the world's emissions of nitrous oxide, a greenhouse gas some 300 times more powerful than carbon dioxide derived from using nitrogen fertilizers.

Combined, curbing these greenhouse gases and using soil sinks could remove the equivalent of up to 1 billion tons of carbon emissions annually. Storing carbon in the soil would account for about 90 percent of that.

The idea of sucking greenhouse gases from the atmosphere, rather than just curbing emissions, is gaining credibility and support as scientists say they have underestimated the urgency of fighting global warming.

Analysts estimate that the burning of forests, plowing soils and degrading grasslands has released 200-250 billion tons of carbon in the past 300 years, about 25 times annual carbon emissions from burning fossil fuels now.

A reward scheme for systems that locking up stored carbon -- like the carbon-offsetting schemes that operate under the Kyoto Protocol -- are being explored in the United States.

U.S. Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack told farm unions last month farmers may be able to earn similar credits for locking carbon in the soil, under President Barack Obama's planned $80 billion cap and trade scheme.

But in Britain, the marketing for Bedfordia is taking time.

"I'm still talking to two supermarkets," said Smith. "Part of the problem is people getting their head around it."

(Editing by Louise Ireland and Sara Ledwith)


Read more!