Climate progress eludes ministers, protesters held

Reuters 14 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN (Reuters) - Environment ministers struggled to nudge forward climate talks in Copenhagen on Sunday, and police detained more than 250 protesters on a second day of mass action.

Church leaders handed a petition with half a million signatures to the United Nations and prayed for climate justice, while hundreds of demonstrators marched through the city center for a second day to remind world leaders of the huge public pressure for a successful deal at the Dec 7-18 talks.

"We are telling them: Hey you, you who are sitting there making the decisions, the world is waiting for a real agreement," South African Nobel Peace laureate Archbishop Desmond Tutu told a crowd in the city center.

The day after a huge demonstration flared into violence and prompted the largest mass arrest in Danish history, police shut down a small march they said had not been authorized, detaining almost all who had joined it for disturbing the peace.

More than 90 ministers had met informally, on their day off from official negotiations between 190 nations, to try to break an impasse between rich and poor over who is responsible for emissions cuts, how deep they should be, and who should pay.

There was a positive atmosphere, but the talks apparently achieved little beyond a consensus that time is running out.

"Everyone realizes the urgency of what we are undertaking but we need to move faster," said British Energy Minister Ed Miliband.

Swedish Environment Minister Andreas Carlgren said he had not expected solutions on Sunday. "We have defined to each other where our absolute limits are," he told reporters.

Countries like China and India say the industrialized world must make bigger cuts in emissions and help poor nations to fund a shift to greener growth and adapt to a warmer world.

Richer countries say the developing world's carbon emissions are growing so fast it must sign up for curbs in emissions to prevent dangerous levels of warming.

SUMMIT ADDS TO PRESSURE

The talks will culminate in a summit on Thursday and Friday that President Barack Obama will attend, adding to the pressure on negotiators to reach a deal.

The head of the Asian Development Bank, Haruhiko Kuroda, warned governments that failure to reach a climate deal in Copenhagen could lead to a collapse of the carbon market, which would hit efforts to deal with climate change.

Tutu handed a petition with over half a million signatures, calling for a "fair, effective and binding climate deal," to Yvo de Boer, head of the U.N. Climate Change Secretariat.

De Boer told the crowd he hoped public pressure could persuade leaders to set aside their concerns about the global economic crisis and tackle the urgent threat of climate change.

The Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, called for political courage at a service in Copenhagen's cathedral, attended by Danish royalty, which was followed by a "bell ringing for the climate" in churches around the world.

"We have not yet been able to embrace the cost of the decisions we know we must make ... but we have an obligation to future generations," Williams told the congregation.

Police have released all but 13 of nearly 1,000 people detained after a march on Saturday, a police spokesman said.

The demonstration by tens of thousands of people was largely peaceful but violence erupted toward evening when demonstrators smashed windows and set fire to cars.

Some of those detained said they were unfairly held and badly treated by police, and the waves of new arrests angered activists who said they were peacefully exercising their rights.

A Reuters witness saw no violence at the small anti-capitalist "hit production" march.

"They're just trying to stifle any kind of protest and they are mass arresting any demonstrators. Also today, there was nothing going on and suddenly police started arresting people," said protester Peter Boulo at Sunday's "hit production" march.

(Writing by Emma Graham-Harrison, additional reporting by Anna Ringstrom, John Acher, David Fogarty and Richard Cowan; editing by Tim Pearce)


Read more!

The push for 350: Contradictions and carbon levels

Seth Borenstein, Associated Press Yahoo News 14 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN – As police cracked down on climate protesters, church bells tolled 350 times Sunday to impress on the U.N. global warming conference a number that is gaining a following, but is also awash in contradictions.

Conference negotiators went behind closed doors in talks to pin down an elusive new pact on climate, talks in which the figure 350 looms as a goal for true believers, but one that appears impossible based on progress so far.

It refers to 350 parts per million of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, the highest concentration that some leading scientists say the world can handle without sparking dangerous climate effects.

"It's the most important number in the world," said Bill McKibben, founder of the environmental activist group 350.org. "It's the line between habitability on this planet and a really, really desolate future."

Not everyone buys into that. But an entire environmental group has sprung up around the number, pushing 350 as a goal, sporting it on T-shirts and flags waved by throngs of protesters that marched to the conference center over the weekend. About 100 nations at the U.N. climate summit have signed on to the idea of heading for 350.

Actually, the world has lived with more than 350 for a while.

The last time the Earth had 350 ppm of carbon dioxide in the air was a generation ago, in the fall of 1989. This year CO2 pushed over the 390 level. When scientists started measuring carbon dioxide in 1958 it was 315.

Since the atmosphere passed the 350 level, ice sheets have been melting and other dramatic changes have been happening. Prominent scientists — notably NASA's James Hansen, one of the earliest to warn about global warming, and Rajendra Pachauri, head of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change — have said 350 is the only safe level of carbon dioxide in the air.

Still, many economists, political leaders, and even some scientists believe that the worst effects of global warming can be avoided even with less stringent actions.

But there is general agreement among negotiators and climate scientists that continued global warming will lead to dramatic changes that mean more widespread drought in some regions, greater flooding along coastlines, stronger storms and the loss of species.

On Sunday, hundreds of churches around the world had signed up to ring bells at 3:50 p.m. in their respective time zones.

"It was an incredibly powerful moment and to know that there are bells ringing all over Europe, up to Greenland, down into the south Pacific and every corner of the planet," McKibben said moments after the bells stopped ringing in Copenhagen.

As they tolled, more than 40 government environment chiefs and other high-level negotiators were meeting at the Danish Foreign Ministry. They were trying to bridge the gap between their positions in informal talks before the second and last week of negotiations gets under way. The week will end with the arrival of President Barack Obama and more than 100 other national leaders for the final hours of negotiation.

Sharp divisions remain between rich and poor countries on greenhouse emissions cuts and financing for developing nations to deal with climate change and shift to cleaner energy.

"I think there was recognition around the table of the urgency of what we need to achieve in the coming days," Britain's Climate Change Secretary Ed Miliband said after Sunday's talks. "I think there needs to be more movement from everyone, more imagination, and I think we will all be striving for that."

Australia's Climate Change Minister Penny Wong also said a lot of work remains to be done.

"It's going to be tough to get an agreement by Friday but that's what we have to do," she told a news conference.

According to participants, the closed-door consultations focused on about a half-dozen plans on financing for poor countries to deal with climate change. One joint proposal by Mexico and Norway calls for a "Green Fund" for climate financing, starting with $10 billion a year in 2013, and increasing to $30 billion to $40 billion a year by 2020

Separately, a proposal aimed at saving the world's tropical forests suffered a setback Sunday, when negotiators ditched plans for faster action on the problem because of concerns that rich countries aren't willing to finance the plan. A deal on deforestation — a sizable global warming factor — is considered a key component of the larger pact.

For a second day in a row, police cracked down on climate activists marching through the Danish capital. More than 200 were detained as police stopped an unauthorized demonstration headed toward the city's harbor and carried out a security check of some of the participants.

Meanwhile, nearly all of the 1,000 detained on Saturday — from Europe, Africa, Asia, and the U.S — were released without charges. Thirteen of them were arraigned in court and faced preliminary charges of assaulting police or were let off with a warning for wearing masks, which are outlawed during demonstrations in Denmark, or carrying box-cutters or other sharp objects.

Reducing carbon dioxide levels to 350 would mean reversing the trend of the past couple of centuries. Carbon dioxide stays in the atmosphere for as long as 100 years. And the emissions cuts currently being pledged by developed countries, including the United States and European nations, are aimed at having CO2 levels peak at around 450, not 350, in coming decades.

And even that may not be possible. Some economists say the world should plan to stop at 550.

Economist Henry Jacoby, co-director of MIT's Joint Program on the Science and Policy of Global Change, has said that even 450 is "totally impossible, there's no way we can do that."

To get down to 350, civilization has to remove massive amounts of carbon dioxide from the skies, something talked about but not yet achieved. Trees and oceans suck CO2 from the atmosphere, but that process is overwhelmed by emissions from burning coal and oil. McKibben said it would probably take 40 years to get down to 350 even if emissions stopped today.

"It may be on the edge of impossible," he said Sunday. "We could do it. At the moment, there's no sign that we are going to do it."

MIT management professor John Sterman said scientifically 350 makes sense, even if economically it seem unreachable.

"We ought to have a goal of 350 and realize we're already above that," Sterman said.

___

Associated Press writers Jan M. Olsen, John Heilprin and Karl Ritter contributed to this report.


Read more!

Best of our wild blogs: 13 Dec 09


Aposematism in Butterflies
from Butterflies of Singapore

Eyes for you
from The annotated budak

Last Weekend of November @ MNT
from Beauty of Fauna and Flora in Nature

A snake and a barbet in a hole
from Bird Ecology Study Group

Songs and calls of the Tiger Shrike
from Bird Ecology Study Group

Sleeping next to activists in Copenhagen
from Reuters Environment blog


Read more!

Keeping watch over wildlife

Straits Times 13 Dec 09;

Once a month, intrepid nature lover Ben Lee, 48, leads 10 to 25 volunteers to patrol nature areas such as Bukit Batok Nature Park and Pulau Ubin, and nature reserves like Bukit Timah.

Their quarry: poachers or illegal wild animal trappers.
Mr Ben Lee (above) pointing out waterbirds in the swamp to Terence Goh on a nature appreciation trip. He believes that many people would like to take ownership and do the right thing. -- ST FILE PHOTO

In 2000, Mr Lee founded the group, Nature Trekker Singapore, to provide a platform for nature conservation and appreciation.

He said: 'In 2000, I was at Khatib Bongsu when I saw people trapping birds and netting fishes without anyone stopping them.

'If nothing is done to stop such activities, the public may perceive them as legal, which is not right.'

Mr Lee leads patrols every month for three to four hours each time.

He said that Nature Trekkers Singapore now has more than 3,000 members, up from 2,968 in June last year.

One success story Mr Lee cited was his discovery of four to five big animal traps on Pulau Ubin over two years from 2005. It led to their removal.

He has seen the rise of similar citizen patrols since he started his group, with many small nature or environmental groups being formed.

He said: 'I believe that many people would like to take ownership and do what they feel is right instead of simply relying on the authorities.

'An individual can't do much but a non-profit organisation is better positioned to take action.'

Shuli Sudderuddin

Tracking down cat abusers
Shuli Sudderuddin, Straits Times 13 Dec 09;

News that yet another cat has been viciously killed by an animal abuser is always a call to action for Ms Pauline Tan.

The 36-year-old financial consultant, together with two like-minded friends, has taken to patrolling neighbourhoods where cat abuse cases have been reported.

They hand out fliers asking for help in looking for the culprit, who is typically someone from the area.

Four years ago, Ms Tan and her two friends started a group, Paw Pledge, to help catch and sterilise stray cats.

Around that time, they also noticed that cat abuse was on the rise.

They decided to take the initiative to start anti-cat abuse patrols, and to help the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals distribute fliers to create public awareness about such abuse.

The fliers cite actual incidents and sometimes offer a reward for information.

Each patrol lasts a few hours and takes place whenever abuse is reported.

Paw Pledge also catches, neuters and releases cats in the neighbourhoods.

Said Ms Tan: 'We started with the aim of raising funds for sterilisation, but the number of abuse cases seems to be rising rapidly.

'Cats cannot fight back when attacked, so we are fighting on their behalf.'

Added Paw Pledge member Fiona Yuen, 35, who works in sales: 'When abuse happens in a neighbourhood, we can't afford to have kittens running around any more as they may be next. So we get the cats in the area sterilised.'


Read more!

Shell launches new chemical plant

Robin Chan, Straits Times 12 Dec 09;

"The Government had been aware of the project's environmental impact before it made its carbon emissions proposals"

SHELL'S multi-billion-dollar integrated petrochemicals complex came a step closer to realisation yesterday, with the official launch of a new chemical plant on Jurong Island.

The mono-ethylene glycol (MEG) plant is Shell's largest, with a production capacity of 750,000 tonnes a year.

It is also the first to use a more efficient process that converts ethylene to MEG in a more environmentally friendly way, consuming less steam and producing less carbon dioxide and by-products.

Trade and Industry Minister Lim Hng Kiang told the opening ceremony: 'Against the backdrop of the Copenhagen summit, such environmentally friendly processes will increasingly become a necessity.'

The Government pledged last week to cut carbon emissions by 16 per cent from its 'business as usual' levels if a deal is reached in Copenhagen. This is despite Singapore contributing only 0.2 per cent of the world's global carbon emissions.

Shell Chemicals' vice-president for new business development and ventures, Mr Iain Lo, told a press conference that the Government had been aware of the project's environmental impact before it made its carbon emissions proposals.

'Specifically for this project, we have already done an environmental assessment study,' Mr Lo said. 'That has been provided to the Government, so it's quite apparent the impact this project has on total emissions in Singapore.'

Mr Lo said Shell had already reduced its own emissions levels to 30 per cent below its 1990 levels.

'A lot of programmes around reducing flaring, increasing energy efficiency, are things we are doing to reduce our own carbon footprint,' he said.

Plans for a second styrene monomer/propylene oxide (SMPO) plant also seem to be on hold for now.

Mr Lo said: 'The downturn has clearly affected the timing of investments. We'll have to wait for the investment outlook to improve before we make a decision.'

While declining to say at what capacity the MEG plant will be running, Mr Lo said Shell was comfortable that it has 'sufficient customers to lift the capacity of the plant'.

The chemical MEG is widely used in manufacturing - from making the polyester used in shirts, to plastic bottles.

It will be exported mainly within the region, where 70 per cent of the world's output is consumed and is growing at 6 per cent a year. Global demand last year was 18 million tonnes.

The MEG plant, which began operations last month, will pipe its own ethylene from nearby Pulau Bukom to Jurong Island upon completion of the Shell Eastern Petrochemicals Complex's (SEPC) main facility - an 800,000 tonne ethylene cracker plant on Bukom on track for a first quarter of next year completion.

The SEPC is Shell's largest investment in Asia and includes upgrading of Shell's Bukom refinery, as well as a new 155,000 tonnes a year butadiene plant on Bukom.

While Shell has declined to state the exact value of its investment in the SEPC beyond 'a few billion dollars', unofficial figures value it at US$3 billion (S$4.1 billion).

Shell has had a presence in Singapore for more than 120 years.

Shell opens new mono-ethylene glycol plant on Jurong Island
Rachel Kelly, Channel NewsAsia 11 Dec 09;

SINGAPORE : Petrochemical giant Royal Dutch Shell on Friday said it will operate its new mono-ethylene glycol (MEG) plant in Singapore at reduced rates, in line with weak demand for petrochemicals.

But it expects to ramp up capacity at the so-called "MEG plant" early next year, when remaining parts of the Shell Eastern Petrochemicals Complex come on stream.

Shell would not say how much the complex costs, but reports have estimated it could be several billion US dollars.

Demand for MEG in the region has been growing at around 6 per cent annually, along with increasing consumer spending.

Shell believes its new MEG plant, which is part of the Shell Eastern Petrochemicals Complex, will position it to meet that demand.

Most of the MEG produced in Singapore will be consumed in the Asia Pacific, which accounts for 70 per cent of global consumption.

Ben Van Beurden, executive vice president, Shell Chemicals, said: "Together, our investment here and in China reinforces Shell's strategy to selectively grow our chemicals business to meet the needs of our Asia-Pacific customers."

The annual MEG production capacity of the plant is 750,000 tonnes, which is enough to produce over two million tonnes of polyester - or the equivalent of 7 billion shirts.

Shell said the plant will be the first to implement its patented processing technology which boosts commercial yields of MEG from ethylene in more environmentally-friendly ways.

Shell estimates that the process uses 20 per cent less steam and produces 30 per cent less waste water compared with traditional thermal conversion MEG plant with the same capacity.

Officiating at the opening of the MEG plant, Trade and Industry Minister Lim Hng Kiang said Singapore is committed to widening its lead as a global chemicals hub.

Mr Lim said: "Singapore is pressing ahead with investment in infrastructure to further enhance the integration of our energy and chemical industry ecosystem. We will enhance the robustness of operations on Jurong Island and optimise the use of precious resources such as energy, land and water."

Shell is among the largest foreign investors in Singapore. Its massive Shell Eastern Petrochemicals Complex includes the new MEG plant, a new Ethylene Cracker Complex, a butadiene plant, and modifications to the existing Pulau Bukom Refinery. - CNA/ms

Shell cautiously optimistic over $3b petrochem complex
Its ability to use feedstock from Bukom refinery makes it competitive
Ronnie Lim, Business Times 12 Dec 09;

SHELL Chemicals is 'cautiously optimistic' on market prospects for its new US$3 billion Singapore petrochemical complex that will be fully operating by the first quarter of next year, its London-based chief told BT yesterday.

While the Singapore project will run smack into a supply overhang, as new petrochemical complexes in the Middle East and China start up next year, global economies, especially China, are starting to recover, Shell executive vice-president Ben van Beurden told BT in an interview. 'There are plenty of signs for optimism. We can conclude that the worst is behind us.'

Shell is also confident that its new Shell Eastern Petrochemicals Complex (SEPC) here - its single biggest chemical investment and its biggest complex in this region - will be competitive given its ability to use cost-advantaged feedstock from Shell's Bukom refinery, with which it is highly-integrated.

This will give SEPC the flexibility to use different feedstock, from the heaviest and cheapest hydrowax to liquefied petroleum gas, as the economics shift.

SEPC will further strengthen Singapore's position as Shell's largest oil/petrochemicals manufacturing centre in the Asia-Pacific and 'underlines our intent to remain a leading petrochemical producer in this region', said Mr van Beurden.

He spoke to BT following the official opening of Shell's 750,000 tonnes per annum (tpa) mono-ethylene glycol (MEG) downstream plant on Jurong Island - an integral part of the SEPC investment.

Giving an indication of the MEG project's scale, he said that the plant can, for example, make sufficient intermediate feedstock to produce more than two million tpa of polyester - enough to make almost seven billion shirts. MEG also goes into making furnishings, polyethylene bottles, anti-freeze and coolants among other products.

'There's no market risk for MEG,' Shell Chemicals vice-president Iain Lo said at a press conference. Global MEG demand is expected to grow 1.5 per cent annually and 5.6 per cent in China in the coming five years, he said. Most of the MEG produced in Singapore is destined for the Asia-Pacific.

But the MEG plant will account for only about half the ethylene output from Shell's new 800,000 tpa cracker.

While Shell continues discussions with other downstream parties to make use of the remaining ethylene and propylene produced by the cracker, 'they are saying they need to wait a bit to see what happens (with markets)', Mr van Beurden said.

'Still, we are basically sold out for next year and are confident the plant will run at high utilisation,' he said, adding that some ethylene will go to local users, including returns to ExxonMobil under a swap deal, while some will be exported to north-east Asia next year and in 2011.

'But our objective is to keep the ethylene in Singapore (for other future downstream plants at SEPC) for the project's long-term robustness,' Mr van Beurden said.

Reflecting the still-uneven market recovery for various petrochemicals, Mr Lo said that the economic downturn has affected the timing of another planned investment by Shell - a potential US$500 million styrene monomer/propylene oxide (SMPO) plant that can use some of the feedstock from the SEPC cracker.

'Singapore remains a possibility for the project, but while there is some demand pick-up, we have to be confident about the outlook (for SMPO) first,' he said.

Some of the cracker's other product streams - such as isobutene and raffinate 1 - were also supposed to have been taken up by Germany's Lanxess for its planned synthetic rubber plant on Jurong Island, but that project has been delayed too.

'But this won't affect us immediately,' Mr van Beurden said, as alternative customers have been found. Lanxess last indicated that it will start building its 400 million euro (S$818.5 million) plant here around mid-2011 - a two-year delay.

Shell moves to start a chain reaction here
Its investments may attract new players; LPG terminal for Qatar gas possible
Ronnie Lim, Business Times 14 Dec 09;

(SINGAPORE) Shell Chemicals is looking at more value-added, downstream investments in Singapore which will be a catalyst for a significant, new 'high-purity chemicals corridor', and potentially attract more supporting players here, its London-based head said.

An example of a downstream investment is the production of high-purity ethylene oxide (or EO, used for making detergents and soaps).

Disclosing this in an interview, Ben van Beurden, its executive vice-president, also confirmed that Shell and its new Qatari partners in its earlier Petrochemical Corporation of Singapore joint venture, together with other parties here and the Singapore government, are looking at a possible LPG terminal here, to import the gas feedstock from Qatar, for the petrochemical industry here and the region.

'For Shell, Singapore is an absolute key, strategic site - which becomes ever more integrated and robust, and a platform to attract additional investments,' he told BT.

Mr van Beurden was here last Friday to officiate at the opening of the group's latest mono-ethylene glycol (MEG) plant - part of its new US$3 billion Singapore petrochemical complex, which will be fully operational by Q1 next year.

What Shell intends to do is to add value to this just-started MEG plant or an earlier ethylene glycols plant here. ' . . . we are studying the option of making higher-purity EO' at one of the plants, he said.

'There is a very clear market for high purity EO - which through ethoxylation, or putting EO on alcohols - is used for products like detergents or soaps. This is a very important region for doing this, because the alcohols come from palm-grown oil, so a lot of players are looking for high purity EO and facilities to do that.'

While he declined to give any investment numbers, he said that the overall payback will be significant. 'You are talking of very significant investment in this new cluster . . . because besides trade and employment etc, it attracts many small- and medium-sized industries as well.'

Furthermore, EO is also used to make polyols (a natural oil derived from vegetable oil and used to make polyurethanes), he added, and this ties in with the propylene oxide produced at its Seraya Chemicals plant here.

'We can also look at more things to do with the propylene oxide out of Seraya . . . So you see, once you have strong foundations, you find good reasons to add more things to it.'

Last month, state-owned Qatar Petroleum International (QPI) - with which Shell has a lot of dealings - took a half-share in Shell's stakes in Petrochemical Corporation of Singapore and The Polyolefin Company. BT later reported that this had to do with the possibility of Qatari liquefied petroleum gas being supplied to Singapore.

Confirming this, Mr van Beurden said that 'there have been a number of discussions with all parties concerned . . . Qatar, other market players here and the Singapore government on how it will make sense to bring in LPG from Qatar as a feedstock for the petrochemicals industry and it certainly looks extremely attractive for all parties concerned.'

'It is an extremely difficult thing to pull off . . . but we are all talking, and figuring how this should look like.

'We will need to aggregate demand from a number of players for it to have sufficient scale to make sense for an LPG import facility to be built and for it to be a very attractive and strategic outlet for the Qataris. But everybody is directionally in agreement that we should work on this,' he added.

While it is still early days, the Shell Chemicals chief added that such a terminal could potentially also service the wider Asian region, with Singapore becoming an important LPG hub.


Read more!

Ultra-smart systems give homes greener hue

Jessica Cheam, Straits Times 13 Dec 09;

Copenhagen: The principles behind making�a home�green are not rocket science. Turning off the power mains, using sustainable materials and furniture, installing energy-efficient applian-ces, and recycling as much as possible are but some fundamental rules to follow.

In the near future, however, green homes will be ultra-smart, enabling households to save as much as 30 per cent in energy bills, said Mr Martin Manniche, chairman and chief technology officer of Singapore-based GreenWave Reality.

In that future, smart software will determine exactly how much energy each household appliance is using and when an appliance is getting old and starts using more energy than usual.

A computerised home energy system will automatically charge appliances during off-peak periods, when energy is cheaper.

Such innovations and more were discussed during a forum last week at the Smart Green Home Symposium in Copenhagen.

The impact of a smart green home system on a country's reduction of emissions is profound, said Mr Manniche. Households contribute about 30 per cent to an average country's emissions.

And Singapore has caught on.�

Chairman of A*Star's Science and Engineering Research Council, Mr Charles Zukoski, told The Sunday Times that the agency is driving research into such technologies and working with companies such as GreenWave on commercialisation.

'The potential for energy saving is huge, and Singapore will be able to reduce its carbon footprint. A lot of policies have been put in place to pursue this,' said Mr Zukoski, who also spoke at the forum.

Trials of GreenWave's smart home systems are set to reach Singapore next June, under the the Energy Market Authority's multi

million-dollar test-bedding project to build Singapore's first smart grid.

GreenWave, which originated in Denmark, is a partner under the scheme, and Mr Manniche is optimistic of its success in Singapore.

'Singapore's strong IT and grid infrastructure makes it ideal to test this out, Singaporeans also love their gadgets and are tech-savvy, I think they will catch on,' he said.


Read more!

'Green' restaurants not all that green

Bhagyashree Garekar, Straits Times 13 Dec 09;

Washington - Al Gore likes to walk in with his daughter. The Clintons drop in now and then. 'We are waiting for the Obamas,' says Ms Nora Pouillon with the confidence that becomes the chef and proprietress of America's first and the capital's only true-blue organic restaurant.

As a conscientious guardian of that label, Ms Pouillon does daily what most restaurants do four times a year - change her menu. She is legally bound to feature what is seasonal, fresh and at hand. At this time of the year, root vegetables are plentiful, so turnips, parsnips and carrots are on her recycled paper menus. Asparagus, a spring vegetable, is banned from the kitchen for now. If it is the weekend, duck is on. Maybe scallops and crabs. Steaks and ribs are regulars.

In a year when the world is the closest it has ever come to a global pact on curbing climate change, the fervour for a low-carb - as in low-carbon - diet is growing. Restaurants that call themselves 'green' and offer eco-friendly menus are sought after and springing up to fill the gap. Under House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's Green the Capitol project, the Congress cafeteria includes sustainable seafood and organic, locally grown produce. Served on compostable plates with cutlery to match.

Still, a truly green restaurant is the stuff of myths. Many claimants have but a limited range of sustainably produced offerings, and often what is advertised as 'green' has dubious credentials.

Restaurant Nora comes fairly close to the ideal. For starters, its organic�fruits, vegetables, meats, coffee, chocolate, salt and sugar all come from producers who�do not use synthetic fertilisers, pesticides, antibiotics or hormones which harm the environment.

Water flows from taps with filters, not ecologically unfriendly plastic bottles. Carpets are recycled. The paint on the walls is non-toxic; termite control is through approved organic chemicals. Dishes are washed in bio-degradable detergents. Waiters wear organic clothing, and the laundry is done on the premises for fear that outsourcing it may bring in uninvited showers of non-organic chemicals.

'Where I don't squeeze is electricity,' says Ms Pouillon. 'I have museum-quality antique Amish quilts on the walls, and we like to project that, so we don't do dim-wattage bulbs.'

To be greener, should she not eschew oranges from Florida or pay for their haulage in carbon offsets? And should she not feature only a little meat, for is that not more energy-intensive to produce than vegetables? She agrees, but adds that any portion of animal protein served in her restaurant comes with at least three vegetable portions.

And vegetarian choices are plentiful on the menu. A diner can, in other words, customise his degree of green. Ms Pouillon has been ahead of the game and is ready to meet him more than halfway.

'When I applied for certification 12 years ago, they had to invent the rules and the standards for certifying restaurants as organic. It took them two years to do that, and I got my label in 1999,' she says.

Since then, she has opened up her doors and books, year after year, to inspectors from Oregon Tilth, a non-profit�organic certifier in the United States. What that process�guarantees is that at least 95 per cent of all the food served is organic, with the US Department of Agriculture defining what constitutes organic produce. Those are stringent criteria to meet, and it is no wonder that hers is among just four or five certified organic restaurants in all of the US.

'It is difficult, the trouble I have to take to source my supplies, plan my menu,' she says.

Much less of a science is green certification of restaurants, which would mean it serves only what is locally and sustainably produced in order to minimise global warming-causing carbon emissions in the transport, storage, refrigeration and waste disposal processes involved. For now, there are no universal definitions, no industry or government standards for what makes a restaurant green.

And when it comes to it, is it only the food that has to be green for a restaurant to be so described? Must not the backend restaurant practices also be so? Is it reasonable to expect that a green restaurant is efficient in its use of energy, has eco-friendly waste disposal practices and packs food in biodegradable containers?

And how far is it the responsibility of the restaurant to verify how green its suppliers really are, given that there are no standard definitions of what constitutes green farming practices either?

Thus, for instance, when the menu says the produce was sourced from a family farm, it may conjure up the vision of a small, non-polluting farmstead. But by some definitions, family farms include multi-million-dollar businesses that are run off thousands of acres. They can be as polluting as factory farms that foul the air with methane and the water with poor waste management practices.

Animals could be mainly fed corn that�requires large amounts of fertiliser and pesticides, both of which are manufactured from fossil fuels. And eating corn increases cattle's methane emissions from flatulence because these animals did not evolve to subsist on it.

The reality, at least here and now, is that most restaurants that claim to be green are only somewhat so. But that is better than nothing.


Read more!

Manatees dying at a record pace in Brevard County, Florida

Many Brevard cases involve younger sea cows
Jim Waymer, Florida Today 12 Dec 09;

A record 105 manatees died in Brevard County this year, almost twice as many as the next highest county and a quarter of the manatees to perish statewide.

Brevard has more habitat; therefore, more manatees tend to live and die here than in any other Florida county.

But biologists are worried about the high numbers that keep dying young. Along the Space Coast, almost half died within a year of birth.

Statewide, 413 sea cows have died this year, putting the species on pace to break the previous record of 417 deaths, set in 2006.

"It's virtually certain that's going to happen," said Pat Rose, executive director of Save the Manatee Club, an advocacy group based in Maitland. "I would love it if that did not happen."

Brevard's total surpassed the previous county record of 87 manatee deaths, also set in 2006, by 20 percent.

Thirteen died here because of cold snaps.

Boats killed six manatees, only 5 percent of the county's overall death toll, and 91 manatees statewide, or 22 percent.

But "perinatal" deaths topped the causes with 48 in Brevard, or 45 percent, and 114 statewide, about 28 percent.

Florida defines perinatal deaths as those that happen before the manatee grows to be 5 feet long -- typically, within a year of birth. The category can include deaths caused by complications with birth and disease.

Boaters against go-slow manatee zones attribute this year's high death toll to a growing manatee population. The record deaths came in the same year the state counted a record 3,802 manatees statewide. The boaters say slow zones do little to protect a species they see thriving.

Manatee conservationists chalk up the statewide deaths from boat strikes and record overall deaths as proof that the species is in peril.

Rose acknowledges that the record perinatal deaths in Brevard may be evidence of robust manatee numbers here.

"But it can't really explain the magnitude of that," he said. "I think it's a really bad year. You don't get these kind of spikes in perinatal deaths without something bad happening."
(2 of 2)

But state biologists don't know what that is. They, like Rose, say the high statewide perinatal deaths can't be explained by population growth alone.

The 101 perinatal deaths last year, however, represented an even higher portion of the overall deaths, almost 30 percent. A total of 337 manatees died statewide in 2008.

This year, the biggest portion of deaths deemed perinatal was in animals too decomposed to tell what killed them.

"It's really hard to say something really statistical about those perinatal deaths because they are really based on the size of the manatee, so it has a big mix of causes," said Martine DeWit, associate research scientist at the Fish and Wildlife Research Institute in St. Petersburg.

This year's perinatal deaths in Brevard nearly tripled the previous 20-year average of about 17.

DeWit suspects that the increase may signify more manatees being born this year. But she stops short of declaring a "recovery."

"I wouldn't call it the species recovering. It could be that the population numbers are growing," she said. "That doesn't mean the population is recovering because there are so many threats to manatees."

Those include red tide, declining warm water springs and seagrass disappearance.

"The overall numbers are relatively high this year. And nothing is really jumping out. We didn't have a big red tide die-off this year," DeWit said. "But what was really obvious this year is that we had really strange cold weather peaks."

The state attributes 54 manatee deaths, about 13 percent, to cold stress in 2009, including 13 deaths in Brevard. That was the second highest on record in the county. The highest was 28 cold stress deaths in 1990.


Read more!

ASEAN ministers seek lower transport emissions

(AFP) Google News 12 Dec 09;

HANOI — Southeast Asia and Japan have endorsed plans to reduce transport pollution, especially on the region's congested roads, according to documents released after a two-day meeting in Vietnam.

Transport ministers from the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) "agreed to implement measures to mitigate climate change especially in the land transport sector and promotion of energy efficiency and sustainable urban transport in ASEAN cities," they said in a joint statement.

Ministers ended the annual talks in Hanoi on Friday.

Southeast Asian cities are notoriously congested with motor vehicles. Jakarta and Ho Chi Minh City are among the region's major metropolises that lack urban rapid transit networks.

In a separate statement after talks with a senior Japanese transport official, the ministers said they had also endorsed an action plan for environmental improvement in the transport sector, to be implemented from 2010 to 2014.

It will provide a framework for the 10 members of ASEAN and Japan to systematically "realise low-carbon and low-pollution transport systems for achieving sustainable social and economic development."

Senior officials are to finalise ways of implementing the plan, the statement said.

Vietnam assumes the rotating chairmanship of ASEAN at the beginning of next year.


Read more!

Antarctic nations plan tough new shipping controls

Ray Lilley, Associated Press Yahoo News 12 Dec 09;

WELLINGTON, New Zealand – Countries that manage Antarctica plan tough new controls on ships visiting the southern oceans and the fuels they use to reduce the threat of human and environmental disasters as tourist numbers rise, officials said Saturday.

The new code will reduce the number of ships carrying tourists into the region by requiring that all vessels have hulls strengthened to withstand sea ice. Officials and ship operators said a ban on heavy fuel oil will effectively shut out big cruise ships.

Experts from among the 47 signatory nations to the Antarctic Treaty — the world's main tool for managing the continent — and the International Maritime Organization discussed plans to impose a mandatory Polar Code to control all shipping in the region at a meeting in the New Zealand capital, Wellington.

The safeguards are seen as necessary to limit accidents in the region, where blinding sleet, fog, high winds and treacherous seas pose major dangers for ships and huge problems for rescuers located thousands of miles (kilometers) from remote Antarctic waters.

The code will cover vessel design, safety equipment, ship operations and crew training for ice navigation, meeting chairman and New Zealand Antarctic policy specialist Trevor Hughes said.

The nearly completed Polar Code is expected to be in place by 2013, he said. Once approved, it would operate on a voluntary basis until it is ratified by treaty states and becomes legally binding.

While existing rules bar tourists or tour operators from leaving anything behind — like garbage or human waste — and require protection of animal breeding grounds, there are no formal codes on the kind of vessels that can use the waters or the kinds of fuel and other oil products they can carry.

In March, the International Maritime Organization, the United Nations' shipping agency, is to ratify a ban on the carriage or use of heavy fuel oil in Antarctica. It is to come into effect in 2011.

The moves follow a huge growth in tourist traffic as people flock to see the world's last great wilderness.

Annual tourist numbers have grown from about 10,000 a decade ago to 45,000 last year. Tourists can pay between $3,000 and $24,000 for a two-week trip. Some travel on ships carrying up to 3,000 passengers that also take many tons of heavy fuel oil, chemicals and garbage that can pollute the region.

Nathan Russ, operations manager of Antarctic eco-tourism company Heritage Expeditions, said the proposed heavy fuel ban "will most likely regulate the biggest cruise ships out of Antarctic operations" because of the costs involved in switching to lighter fuel.

The Antarctic Treaty, first signed in 1959, is the main tool for regulating what is the world's only continent without a native human population. New Zealand is one of the dozen founding members of the treaty, along with the United States, Russia and Britain. The treaty now has 47 signatories.


Read more!

The Science of Climate Negotiations

As negotiators in Copenhagen work to complete a global agreement, how much are they taking science into account?

David Biello, Scientific American 12 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN—One thing is clear under this city's low, leaden skies: a ton of carbon dioxide emitted in India is the same as a ton of carbon dioxide emitted in the U.S. And while some notable contrarians are present here at the United Nations' climate summit, their presence is not felt as all those countries that do not rely on oil accept the basic physics of a molecule of carbon dioxide trapping heat in the atmosphere. But what is less clear is how the various negotiators from 193 countries are incorporating new developments in the scientific understanding of climate change and its progress, particularly as various draft texts of what an agreement might look like circulate through the crowded halls of the Bella Center.

"Our starting point is the environment," says Karl Falkenberg, director general of the environment at the European Commission. "What we're looking for here is an outcome that effectively deals with climate change and the consequences of climate change that we are seeing everywhere on the globe."

The general consensus seems to be that global emissions of greenhouse gases must be cut by 50 percent from 1990 levels by 2050 with developed countries and bodies such as those in the European Union (E.U.), Japan and the U.S. making larger cuts to allow developing countries, such as China and India to grow. "Different commitments we can accept but they need to be verified in a coherent manner," Falkenberg says. "Continued carbon-based economic growth in developing countries is contributing to poverty not alleviating it."

But under previous agreements, such as the original United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change agreed upon in 1992, developed countries' emissions were supposed to peak in 2000 and thereafter decline. Instead, "emissions have risen since 2000," notes Indian ambassador Chandrashekhar Dasgupta. In fact, concentrations of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere rise by roughly 2 parts-per-million a year, having reached roughly 387 ppm to date. And some scientists, such as NASA climatologist James Hansen, argue that anything above 350 ppm is dangerous, given impacts such as melting Arctic sea ice that are happening much faster than scientists had anticipated.

"We need to have targets that are science-based," Falkenberg says. The E.U. has settled on targets of keeping warming from exceeding a 2 degree Celsius rise in average temperatures (average temperatures have already warmed 0.7 degree C), which roughly equates to CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere of 450 ppm.

Of course, many scientists feel that on present efforts the world will greatly exceed 450 ppm. "The world is going to have to create a carbon pie eventually and divide it up," says geochemist Wallace Broecker of Columbia University's Earth Institute. "A total amount of CO2 that each country will be able to add to the atmosphere."

And that's where the argument really starts. "For developed countries, when it comes to emissions space, their fundamental attitude is what is mine is mine. What I've taken away from you I've got to keep," says Yu Qingtai, ambassador from China. "For us, the developing countries, our position is our emissions space is under occupation and we want them back."

Of course, China emits the largest amount of greenhouse gases of any nation in the world, but on a per person basis it lags well behind the U.S., E.U. and Japan. "Every human being has an equal right to the resources of the atmosphere," says Dasgupta, arguing for a per person emissions limit. "How will this resource, which for the first time in history has become a resource which is limited in supply, how is to be divided in the global community?"

Of course, scientists such as Stanford University climatologist Stephen Schneider note that the impacts of climate change will fall most heavily on the poorest countries, which have the least capacity to adapt. Already, argues Quamrul Islam Chowdhury, the negotiator for Bangladesh, some 5 to 10 percent of his country will be washed away by climate change. "It will have also a huge impact not in terms of development but also in terms of human rights, migration and displacement."

"We are on the front lines of climate change," adds Crispin Gregoire, climate negotiator from Dominica. "Some of our islands will disappear. We accept that. We want an agreement that will address our survival."

And that means emissions cuts for everyone. "The question is not whether it is desirable to reduce the rate of growth of emissions in developing countries. Of course it is," Dasgupta says. "The question is who pays?"

The European Union, for its part, hopes that it's example might prove instructive with the launch of an emissions trading regime that has put a price of roughly 11 EU$ on every metric ton of carbon dioxide emissions. "The EU economy has been delinked effectively from the growth of further CO2 emisions," Falkenberg notes, pointing to economic growth of roughly 2.5 percent in 2007 paired with a decline in emissions of roughly 4 percent.

But it remains unclear how often words about commitments to combat climate change match real actions. "In international cooperation to fight climate change there is no shortage of legally binding documents. We have the Convention, we have the Kyoto Protocol," Yu says. "If you look at these basic documents there have been a list of commitments that have gone by without being met. So if we are going to have a positive outcome from Copenhagen it must make a difference when it comes to taking real action to match what we promise as sovereign nations."


Read more!

Tens of thousands march for tough action on climate

Marlowe Hood Yahoo News 13 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN (AFP) – Tens of thousands of activists demanding a planet-saving climate deal blazed a path to the door of the UN talks on Saturday in a raucous, festive rally that was also marked by sporadic violence and more than 960 arrests.

In a four-hour march to the Bella Center, where the conference was underway, a crowd estimated by police to number more than 30,000 pounded out calls for carbon cuts, social justice and a taming of global capitalism.

One protestor dressed as Santa Claus held up a banner saying global warming was occurring twice as fast in the Arctic as the rest of the world.

"My Rudolf cannot take it any more," he said, referring to the red-nosed reindeer of the famous Christmas song.

Other demonstrators sported banners that read: "There is no planet B," "Change the politics not the climate," and "Nature does not compromise".

"Each year 300,000 people are dying because of climate change," Kumi Naidoo, executive director of Greenpeace International, told the marchers. "This is not about adaptation, it is about survival."

"We cannot allow carbon traders to damage the world," added Nigeria's Nnimmo Bassey, chair of Friends of the Earth International.

"There is no such thing as clean coal or clean crude. Leave the oil in the soil, leave the coal in the hole," he said, leading a chant.

Police estimated the turnout at more than 30,000, while Danish television put the estimate at up to 100,000.

Climate Justice Action, a group involved in organising Saturday's demonstration, accused police of "violating human rights by detaining people in bitter cold, cuffed and forced into seated positions on the ground".

Rally organisers had repeatedly urged the crowd to remain non-violent.

But within minutes of the start, a disciplined band of hundreds of masked youths dressed head-to-toe in black threw bricks and firecrackers, smashing windows in the city centre.

Police moved in quickly, arrested a handful of the agitators, later identified as members of militant groups from northern Europe known as Black Blocs.

"Black Blocs members were seen at 1:41 pm picking up cobblestones that they later hurled near the former Stock Exchange, at several foreign ministry windows" and a bank, a police statement said.

Over the course of the day a total of 968 protesters were taken into custody, police said.

Four hundred were Black Blocs militants and most of these were foreigners, "showing that there was a hard core of activists who came to Copenhagen to sow disorder," a police spokesman told AFP.

About 150 people were released from custody late Saturday after questioning, the police statement said.

Later Saturday, a police officer was injured and four cars were burned out during clashes at a squat in Christiania, in central Copenhagen.

Related article: US, China face off at talks

Within the congress hall, Nobel Peace Prize winner Archbishop Desmond Tutu led children in creating "a sea of candles" representing a call from generations imperilled by climate change.

The march capped demonstrations scheduled in 130 cities around the world aimed at stoking pressure on leaders called to seal a landmark deal on climate change in the Danish capital next Friday.

Australia, the developed world's highest per-capita polluter, kicked off the chain with up to 50,000 people taking to the streets nationwide, organisers said.

In Indonesia, activists rallied outside the US embassy in Jakarta to urge the superpower to support developing nations.

In the Philippines, hundreds of protesters wearing red shirts banged on drums and sang songs outside Manila's City Hall demanding global action on climate change.

Connie Hedegaard, a former Danish climate minister who is chairing the 12-day Copenhagen marathon, said the demonstrations reflected a public mood that politicians could not ignore.

"It has taken years to build up pressure that we see around the world, and that we have also seen unfolding today in many capitals around the world," she said.

"That has contributed to making the political price for not delivering in Copenhagen so high that I am absolutely convinced that leaders consider very carefully whether they want to pay that price."

Nearly 1,000 held after Copenhagen climate rally
Reuters 12 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN (Reuters) - Police detained nearly 1,000 people in Copenhagen on Saturday during mass demonstrations to demand that negotiators at U.N. talks agree a strong treaty to fight global warming.

Tens of thousands of people marched through the city as part of a global "Day of Action" of climate rallies from Australia to the United States, but violence flared at one stage when demonstrators smashed windows and set fire to cars.

Riot police detained more than 900 people around the Danish capital after black-clad activists threw bottles and smashed windows. A police spokeswoman said the number had climbed to 968 shortly after 10 p.m. (2100 GMT).

Police said four cars were set on fire during the evening. One policeman was hurt by a stone and a Swedish man injured by a firework.

"You don't have to use that kind of violence to be heard," said Connie Hedegaard, the Danish minister presiding at the U.N. talks. She condemned rioters after welcoming the main march at a candlelit vigil outside the conference center.

One activist group accused the police of abuse after they detained around 400 black-clad demonstrators at the back of the march and forced them to sit on a road for hours in near-freezing temperatures, hands bound behind their backs.

The main demonstration was led by dancers, drummers and banners proclaiming: "There is no planet B" and "Change the politics, not the climate." Some activists were dressed as penguins with signs reading: "Save the Humans!"

They marched to the conference center on the outskirts of the city, where negotiators from 192 nations are meeting from December 7-18 hoping to agree a new U.N. climate pact.

Organizers said up to 100,000 people took part in the march, hoping their rally and others round the world would put pressure on a concluding summit of 110 world leaders on Thursday and Friday.

SNOWMAN

In the main march, some held a giant inflatable snowman as a symbol of the threat of largescale melting icecaps and glaciers.

The U.N. panel of climate scientists says the accelerating loss of vital masses of ice, caused by rising temperatures resulting mainly from burning fossil fuels, will lead to rising sea levels, floods, desertification and heat waves.

The demonstration won wide praise.

"They marched in Berlin, and the Wall fell. They marched in Cape Town, and the wall fell," South African Nobel Peace Prize winner Archbishop Desmond Tutu told a candlelit vigil. "They marched in Copenhagen -- and we are going to get a real deal."

"There is a lot to fight for in the remaining week of negotiations," said Kumi Naidoo, chair of the organizing group "TckTckTck." Activists want the talks to agree a full legal treaty -- a goal most governments say is out of reach.

Elsewhere, thousands of Australians held a "Walk Against Warming." Naidoo said 4,000 events, such as marches or candlelit vigils, were being held from Fiji to Nepal to show support for deep cuts in greenhouse gas emissions.

In Copenhagen, Caroline, a Danish girl aged 7, carried a homemade sign saying: "Look after our world until I grow up."

"Mountains are changing, glaciers are melting," said Nepalese Sherpa Pertamba, who came to Denmark to demonstrate with a group of 30 mountaineers. "Now is the time to think about future generations."

In Sydney, protesters carried placards reading: "I like clean energy and I vote," "No meat, no heat" and "No new coal mines," a reference to Australia's status as one of the world's leading exporters of coal.

Inside the conference hall in Copenhagen, delegates claimed progress on some fronts but the hardest decisions on sharing out curbs on greenhouse gas emissions and funding to help the poor are likely to be left for the summit.

"We have made considerable progress over the course of the first week," said Denmark's Hedegaard. She said she would hold talks on Sunday with 48 environment ministers. "We still have a daunting task in the next few days," she added.

Hedegaard said negotiators had made progress with texts such as defining how new green technologies like wind and solar power can be supplied to developing nations, and in promoting the use of forests to soak up greenhouse gases.

But delegates said there were deep splits on raising funds for poor nations and sharing the burden of CO2 cuts.

Yvo de Boer, head of the U.N. Climate Change Secretariat, said he hoped for more action by all.

"China is calling on the United States to do more. The United States is calling on China to do more. I hope that in the coming days everyone will call for everyone to do more."

(Additional reporting by Sunanda Creagh, Erik Kirschbaum, Laure Bretton, writing by Alister Doyle; editing by Tim Pearce)

968 detained at climate rally urging bold pact
John Heilprin, Associated Press 13 Dec 09;

COPENHAGEN – Tens of thousands of protesters marched through the chilly Danish capital and nearly 1,000 were detained Saturday in a mass rally to demand an ambitious global climate pact, just as talks hit a snag over rich nations' demands on China and other emerging economies.

The mostly peaceful demonstrations in Copenhagen provided the centerpiece of a day of global climate activism stretching from Europe to Asia. Police assigned extra officers to watch protesters marching toward the suburban conference center to demand that leaders act now to fight climate change.

Police estimated their numbers at 40,000, while organizers said as many as 100,000 had joined the march from downtown Copenhagen. It ended with protesters holding aloft candles and torches as they swarmed by night outside the Bella Center where the 192-nation U.N. climate conference is being held.

There have been a couple of minor protests over the past week, but Saturday's was by far the largest.

Police said they rounded up 968 in a preventive action against a group of youth activists at the tail end of the demonstration. Officers in riot gear moved in when some of the activists, masking their faces, threw cobblestones through the windows of the former stock exchange and Foreign Ministry buildings.

A police officer received minor injuries when he was hit by a rock thrown from the group and one protester was injured by fireworks, police spokesman Flemming Steen Munch said.

Earlier, police said they had detained 19 people, mainly for breaking Denmark's strict laws against carrying pocket knives or wearing masks during demonstrations.

Inside the Bella Center, the European Union, Japan and Australia joined the U.S. in criticizing a draft global warming pact that says major developing nations must rein in greenhouse gases, but only if they have outside financing. Rich nations want to require developing nations to limit emissions, with or without financial help.

Swedish Environment Minister Andreas Carlgren, representing the 27-nation EU, told The Associated Press that "there has been a growing understanding that there must be commitments to actions by emerging economies as well."

He said those commitments "must be binding, in the sense that states are standing behind their commitments."

Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh said his country — the world's No. 5 greenhouse gas polluter — will not offer more than its current pledge to slow its growth rate of emissions. It has offered to cut greenhouse gases measured against production by 20 to 25 percent by 2020.

"National interest trumps everything else," Ramesh told the AP. "Whatever I have to do, I've said in my Parliament. We'll engage them (the U.S. and China). I'm not here to make new offers."

China has made voluntary commitments to rein in its carbon emissions but doesn't want to be bound by international law to do so. In China's view, the U.S. and other rich countries have a heavy historical responsibility to cut emissions and any climate deal in Copenhagen should take into account a country's level of development.

Alden Meyer of the Union of Concerned Scientists told the AP that rich nations are trying to re-negotiate the deal they reached two years ago on the island of Bali, calling on developing nations to limit emissions with financial help.

"It's going to blow up in their faces," he said. "The rich countries are trying to move the goal posts. And developing countries are not going to agree to that, no matter how loudly the rich countries demand it."

The tightly focused negotiating text was meant to lay out the crunch themes for environment ministers to wrestle with as they prepare for a summit of some 110 heads of state and government at the end of next week.

U.S. delegate Jonathan Pershing said the draft failed to address the contentious issue of carbon emissions by emerging economies.

"The current draft didn't work in terms of where it is headed," Pershing said in the plenary, supported by the European Union, Japan and Norway.

But the EU also directed criticism at the U.S., insisting it could make greater commitments to push the talks forward without stretching the legislation pending in Congress. Both the U.S. and China should be legally bound to keep whatever promises they make, Carlgren said.

Thousands also marched in a "Walk Against Warming" in major cities across Australia and about 200 Filipino activists staged a festive rally in Manila to mark the Global Day of Action on climate change. Dozens of Indonesian environmental activists rallied in front of the U.S. Embassy in Jakarta.

Environmentalists staged stunts and protests in 100 piazzas across Italy, from Venice's St. Mark's Square to a historical piazza in downtown Rome. They carried banners that read "stop the planet's fever" and asked passers-by to sign a petition calling on world leaders to reach a deal to reduce emissions.

In Copenhagen, Archbishop Desmond Tutu, a Nobel Peace laureate, and Greenpeace leader Kumi Naidoo were among those ratcheting up the pressure for a fair, ambitious and binding treaty.

Naidoo exhorted politicians to act bravely by crafting a fair, ambitious and binding treaty, so they can later "look their children and grandchildren in the eyes" and tell them they did the right thing. "Failure to do so will be the worst political crime that they would have committed," he said.

At a candlelight vigil on the conference grounds, Tutu compared the mass demonstrations outside to other popular movements that made a mark in history.

"We want to remind you that they marched in Berlin and the wall fell," Tutu said. "They marched in Cape Town and apartheid fell. They marched in Copenhagen and we are going to get a real deal."

Demonstrators chanted and carried banners reading "Demand Climate Justice," "The World Wants A Real Deal" and "There Is No Planet B," navigating for miles along city streets and over bridges past officers in riot gear, police dogs and the flashing lights of dozens of police vans.

Inside the Bella Center, delegates gathered around flat-screen TVs showing both the larger peaceful rally and the police crackdown on the young activists. Riot police tied them up with plastic cuffs and made them sit down on a closed-off street before busing them to a detention center set up for the climate conference.

Britain's Ed Miliband, the climate change secretary, said dealmakers have a long ways to go. "There are difficult issues to overcome," he said, "around emissions, around finance, and around transparency and they are all issues we need to tackle in the coming days."

But conference president Connie Hedegaard sought to reassure people that world leaders have come to seriously confront climate change.

"It has taken years to build up the pressure ... that we're also seeing unfolding today in many capitals around the world," Hedegaard said. "And I believe that that has contributed to making the political price for not delivering in Copenhagen so high."

___

Associated Press writers Jan M. Olsen, Karl Ritter and Arthur Max contributed to this report.


Read more!