Study claiming 6,500 deaths in Malaysia due to haze refuted

NICHOLAS CHENG The Star 19 Sep 16;

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia has refuted a Harvard and Columbia University study, claiming that the 2015 South-East Asian haze had caused 6,500 deaths in the country.

The study, which is expected to be published in the Environmental Research Letters (ERL) journal, also claims that there have been 100,300 premature deaths in the region from the haze; 91,600 in Indonesia and 2,200 in Singapore.

The numbers vastly contradict the official count, which only reported 19 deaths in Indonesia and none in Malaysia and Singapore.

Deputy Health director-general Datuk Dr S. Jeyaindran was sceptical of the findings of the study.

“We had no deaths last year directly related to the haze,” he added.

He said the Ministry had done a study on suspended particulate matter in the air from open burning and its effects on the human body, and found that apart from irritable symptoms, no grave health risks were likely.

“Of course we had increased number of conjunctivitis and respiratory track infection but its mostly due to the fact that some haze contained sulpher dioxide and nitric oxide which comes from the burning of fossil fuel,” he said.

The annual haze that originates from Indonesia, usually would blow PM10 or PM5 concentrated particulate matter, which is less than 10 microns and mostly causes irritation.

“We didn’t find any increase in the number of acute respiratory ailments from the haze. This has been going on year on year and our data shows there is no increase,” he Dr Jeyaindran said.

Little is known about the methodology of the study, though Bloomberg reported that the number of deaths was “derived from a complex analysis that has not yet been validated by analysis of official data on mortality”.

An expert team who reviewed the paper for Bloomberg were also reserved in their comments, calling it “preliminary” and “not precise” but said it should serve as a wake up call for the region which saw its worst environmental incident since the 1997 haze.
The fires generated around 600 million tonnes of greenhouse gasses - roughly equivalent to Germany’s entire annual output and economically stripped the three countries involved of US$9bil.

“If nothing changes, this killer haze will carry on taking a terrible toll, year after year. Industry and government must take real action to stop forest clearing and peatland drainage for plantations,” said Greenpeace Indonesia forest campaigner Yuyun Indradi, in response to the study.


Malaysia refutes Harvard study that haze killed 6,500
NICHOLAS CHENG The Star 20 Sep 16;

KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia has refuted a Harvard and Columbia University study claiming that the 2015 South-East Asian haze caused 6,500 deaths in the country.

The study, which is expected to be published in the Environmental Research Letters (ERL) journal, also claimed that there were 100,300 premature deaths in the region due to the haze; 91,600 in Indonesia and 2,200 in Singapore.

The numbers cited contradicted official numbers, which only reported 19 deaths in Indonesia and none in Malaysia and Singapore.

“No such thing!” Deputy Health director-general Datuk Dr S. Jeyain­dran said when asked about the findings.

“We had no deaths last year directly related to the haze,” he added

He said the Health Ministry conducted a study on suspended parti­culate matter in the air from open burning and its effects on the human body, and found that apart from irritable symptoms, no grave health risks were likely.

“Of course, we had increased number of conjunctivitis cases and respiratory tract infections but it’s mostly due to the fact that some haze contained sulphur dioxide and nitric oxide, which comes from the burning of fossil fuel,” he said,

The annual haze that originates from Indonesia, usually would blow PM10 or PM5 concentrated particulate matter, which is less than 10 mi­­crons. These mostly cause irritation.

“We didn’t find any increase in the number of acute respiratory ailments from the haze. This has been going on year on year and our data shows there is no increase,” Dr Jeyaindran said.

Little is known about the metho­dology of the study, though Bloom­berg reported that the number of deaths was “derived from a complex analysis that has not yet been validated by analysis of official data on mortality”.

An expert team who reviewed the paper for Bloomberg reserved its comments, calling it “preliminary” and “not precise” but said it should serve as a wake-up call for the region, which saw its worst environmental incident since the 1997 haze.

The fires generated around 600 million tonnes of greenhouse gas – roughly equivalent to Germany’s entire annual output and economically stripped the three countries affected of US$9bil (RM37.2bil).

“If nothing changes, this killer haze will carry on taking a terrible toll year after year. Industry and government must take real action to stop forest clearing and peatland drainage for plantations,” said Greenpeace Indonesia forest campaigner Yuyun Indradi in response to the study.