Best of our wild blogs: 19 May 08


Green Events Guide
a new guide to planning an eco-friendly event by Asia Is Green and Eco-Singapore, on the AsiaIsGreen blog

Upcoming Chek Jawa specials this week
Screening of "Remember Chek Jawa", talk by Loh Kok Sheng on "Life and Death on Chek Jawa" and free guided walk on the Chek Jawa boardwalk on the wildfilms blog

Turtles at Cyrene
on the flying fish friends blog

Great Egret fishing
on the bird ecology blog

Discovering the Southern Ridges
A new web resource on the NParks website with links to more information about these features: Hilltop Walk, Forest Walk, Marang Trail, Alexandra Arch, Faber Walk, Floral Walk & HortPark - the gardening Hub, Henderson Waves, Canopy Walk


Read more!

Fishing has him hooked: Fishing in Singapore

Berton Lim, New Paper 19 May 08;

WHENEVER he can afford the time, Home United midfielder Tengku Mushadad would rent a boat at Changi Village with his friends and go boat fishing.

The 23-year-old said: 'Boat fishing is my favourite pastime.

'My father introduced fishing to me when I was six. Since then, I am hooked because it gives me peace of mind like no other hobby can.'

Like most recreational fishermen, Tengku Mushadad started off with angling. Angling is the practice of catching fish with a hook.

However, an incident last year prompted him to venture into deeper waters instead.

Tengku Mushadad recalled: 'I was fishing at Punggol Track 17.

'Soon, there was a strong tug on my line. I lifted the rod and tried to reel in the fish, but it just wouldn't budge.

'The fish was about 60m from my position. I used up a lot of strength, and just when I was about to succeed, my line snapped!

'That was very frustrating because it took me two long hours.'

He continued with a laugh: 'From then on, I decided to spend my time cruising the saltwater around Pulau Ubin and Pulau Tekong.'

Compared to angling, boat fishing provides its enthusiasts convenient access to prime areas that are too far away from the bank.

It also allows fishing for deep-water fish, such as lake trout.

'My friends and I rent the boat in 12-hour blocks,' revealed Tengku Mushadad.

'There are usually eight of us who go for this boat fishing trip together. We will start at 8am and end at 8pm. It costs $270.'

According to Tengku Mushadad, the companionship provided by friends during a fishing jaunt is valuable.

He explained: 'The sun is very hot in the morning, while sleepiness and fatigue starts to set in at night.

'Chatting with my friends helps me forget these.'

Tengku Mushadad also feels boat fishing teaches him several lessons in life.

'Most of all, it made me become more patient,' he opined with a smile.


Read more!

Ireland to hunt nightmare fishing nets in north Atlantic

Yahoo News 18 May 08;

Ireland is to tackle the growing problem of so-called "ghost nets" that are destroying fish stocks in the northeast Atlantic Ocean, the Irish Sea Fisheries Board said Sunday.

The organisation said a series of pilot clean-up schemes, involving one Spanish and three Irish ships contracted to retrieve some of the thousands of kilometres of lost, dumped and abandoned nets, will run from June to September.

The scheme -- Operation Deepclean -- is being funded by the European Union at a cost of more than 500,000 euros (775,000 dollars) and will also seek to estimate the extent of the problem off the British and Irish coasts.

"The retrieval exercise will alleviate the problem of ghost fishing and help prevent further fish being caught in these nets," said Dominic Rihan, from the Irish Sea Fisheries Board.

"We also hope to get an estimate of the amount of lost nets in the particular areas."

"Ghost nets" are so called because they drift in the ocean after being abandoned or dumped and some have been found to be still catching fish and ensnaring other marine life for up to three years.

The fish are caught and die in the nets. The effect has been devastating with stocks of deepwater sharks falling to about 20 percent of original levels in less than 10 years.

It has been a growing environmental problem since the mid-1990s when a fleet of up to 50 vessels began gillnet fishing on the continental slopes in areas like Rockall and the Hatton Bank.

Most of the boats are based in Spain but registered in Britain, Germany and non-EU countries like Panama.

But although they seek to catch monkfish and deepwater shark, they also snare other species like halibut and ling.

No one is certain of just how many ghost nets there are either floating or fouling the seabed.

A joint Irish, Norwegian and British study from 2002 estimated that 1,254 kilometres (620 miles) of 600 by 50 metre (1,970 by 164 feet) sheets of nets were being lost every year but there was a reluctance to talk about the problem in the industry.


Read more!

Explorers Marvel At 'Brittlestar City' On Antaractica Seamount

Explorers Marvel At 'Brittlestar City' On Seamount In Powerful Current Swirling Around Antarctica
Underwatertimes.com News Service 18 May 08;

Washington, D.C. (2008-05-18 18:36:00 EST) Census of Marine Life-affiliated scientists, plumbing the secrets of a vast underwater mountain range south of New Zealand, captured the first images of a novel “Brittlestar City” established against daunting odds on the peak of a seamount – an underwater summit taller than the world’s tallest building.

Its cramped starfish-like inhabitants, tens of millions living arm tip to arm tip, owe their success to the seamount’s shape and to the swirling circumpolar current flowing over and around it at roughly four kilometers per hour. It allows Brittlestar City’s underwater denizens to capture passing food simply by raising their arms, and it sweeps away fish and other hovering would-be predators.


Discovery of this marine metropolis, announced today along with important new insights into seamount geology and physics, highlighted a month-long April expedition to survey the Macquarie Ridge aboard the Research Vessel Tangaroa of New Zealand’s National Institute of Water & Atmospheric Research, host of the Census of Marine Life seamount programme, CenSeam. The voyage was largely funded by the New Zealand Foundation for Research, Science and Technology.

Formed at least 12.5 million years ago, Macquarie Ridge stretches 1,400 km south from New Zealand to just above the Antarctic Circle. A multi-disciplinary scientific team from New Zealand and Australia extensively sampled this intriguing ecosystem deep beneath waves familiar to fishing trawlers but rarely reached by scientists.

Macquarie Ridge is one of a few places where the Antarctic Circumpolar Current is detoured in its endless clockwise churn at the globe’s southernmost latitudes – playing a vital part in the global ecosystem, merging and mixing waters of the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific Oceans.

Usually corals and sponges dominate seamount peaks, filtering food that arrives on the current. Biologists aboard the Tangaroa believe Brittlestar City is the first dense aggregation of another filter feeder, the brittlestar, ever found atop a seamount, and they credit the summit’s shape and extraordinary current circumstances there, 750-meters above the ocean floor.

They photographed brown-black brittlestars numbering hundreds per square meter and estimate tens of millions of them populate the 100 square km flat top of the seamount.

Brittlestars are echinoderms, relatives to starfish, sea cucumbers, sea lilies, and sea urchins. The two brittlestar species observed were tentatively identified via photographs sent from the ship to the Museum Victoria in Melbourne, Australia.

There, taxonomist Tim O’Hara determined that the smaller, densely packed brown-black brittlestar species, found living arm tip to arm tip on the sand and cobble substrate of the peak, were likely Ophiacantha otagoensis or Ophiacantha fidelis.

Larger orange-red species discovered down the seamount’s flanks, filmed waving arms in the current to collect passing food, were likely Ophiacantha rosea.

“We were excited to see such a huge assemblage of brittlestars on the Macquarie Ridge seamount. Not only is it amazing to see a vast array of one type of organism but the implications of the find for our understanding of the relative uniqueness of seamount assemblages are potentially far-reaching.” said ecologist Dr. Ashley Rowden of NIWA.

Piecing together the Brittlestar City ecosystem

The ship towed special sleds to collect seamount organisms. Thousands of specimens of all kinds were gathered from eight seamounts in over 30 sled collections and now fill almost 1,600 vials, jars and bags, to be sent from NIWA to taxonomists in New Zealand, Australia and overseas.

Full identifications may take many years. The eight biologists on board believe some species collected have never before been recorded in the region while some may be new to science.

A Deep Towed Imaging System (DTIS) vehicle, meanwhile, designed and constructed at NIWA by Peter Hill, was “flown” over the seafloor, snapping still photos and high definition video of the animals and their habitat. DTIS captured over 20 hours of video and thousands of photos of a part of Earth never seen before by humankind.

An abundance of deepwater cardinal fishes (Epigonus species) was found sheltering below a rock ledge on the seamount. In the lee of the rock, biologists believe, the fish could both conserve energy and access food.

Several Morid cods (family Moridae) were found in the folds of a large bubblegum coral (nearly two meters high, and likely hundreds of years old). These fish were also believed to be finding shelter from the current and perhaps benefiting in other ways from their close association with the coral.

Oceans worldwide contain an estimated 100,000 seamounts rising at least one km above the seabed; fewer than 200 have been sampled in any detail.

Undersea mountains can be highly productive and biodiverse, sometimes host unique species and serve as feeding grounds for fishes, marine mammals and seabirds. They also may serve as important way stations for marine migrations. The scientists’ work sheds light on factors underpinning seamount biodiversity, suggesting ways to improve their environmental management.

The odd shape and circumstances of Brittlestar City seamount

Tangaroa’s acoustic “multibeam” technology mapped the sizes, shapes and depths of the Macquarie Ridge.

The Brittlestar City seamount displayed several geological faults affecting its shape and geomorphology. The odd rectangular edge of its southern peak was formed by the intersection of two perpendicular faults. Because the upper surface is relatively flat, experts believe it was once at sea level, or slightly submerged. The flat topography suggests wave erosion occurred during the last ice age 18,000 years ago, when sea level was low. Although the base of Brittlestar City seamount is 850 meters below surface, its peak is just 90 meters underwater.

Intrigued by the dynamics of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current as it passed over and through ridge gaps, physicists aboard the Tangaroa calculated its speed over the top of the seamount at a “rattling” 2 knots (about 4 km per hour).

“This current is estimated to be 110 to 150 times larger than all the water flowing in all the rivers of the world,” says Dr. Mike Williams of NIWA. “In terms of the world’s oceans, New Zealand sits right beside the motorway.”

The Macquarie Ridge creates a strategic marine junction. “Understanding this current will shed light on how much water flows into the Pacific as opposed to continuing to circumnavigate Antarctica. This is important for understanding, and ultimately predicting, the impact of potential changes in the current on climate throughout the Southwest Pacific.”

Data was collected from nine strings of metering instruments, anchored a year earlier in two gaps or "choke points" in the Ridge, through which the current squeezes. Experts were astonished to find the current had pushed the top instruments on some strings to a depth of one kilometer below the surface.

Scientists also took this ocean area’s temperature and salinity readings for the first time since the 1960s, looking for climate-related changes, and obtained water samples to measure and compare levels of marine life nutrients.

Underwater mountain a sanctuary for sea life
Paul Eccleston, The Telegraph 19 May 08;

Biologists have found a vast colony of sea creatures living on an underwater mountain close to the Antarctic.

Tens of millions of starfish-like brittlestars cling together at the 2,500ft summit, which is higher than the world's tallest building.

Scientists were so astonished at the vast numbers of the brown-black creatures covering the 60 sq mile flat top of the mountain - known as a seamount - that they christened it Brittlestar City.

The ecosystem was found on an expedition to survey sea life on the 12 million-year-old Macquarie Ridge, which stretches almost 900 miles south from New Zealand to just above the Antarctic Circle.

Thousands of specimens were gathered and will be sent for classification. The biologists believe some species collected have never before been recorded in the region while others may be new to science.

Dr Ashley Rowden, an ecologist who took part in the survey, said: "Not only is it amazing to see a vast array of one type of organism but the implications for our understanding of the relative uniqueness of seamount assemblages are potentially far-reaching."

Millions of tiny starfish inhabit undersea volcano
Ray Lilley, Associated Press Yahoo News 20 May 08

Marine scientists surveying a large undersea mountain chain were amazed to find millions of tiny starfish swirling their arms to capture food in the undersea current.

An expedition by 19 scientists, including five from Australia, studied the geology and biology of eight Macquarie Ridge sea mounts. They are part of a string of underwater volcanoes — dormant for millions of years — that stretches 875 miles from south of New Zealand toward Antarctica.

The scientists also investigated the world's biggest ocean current — the Antarctic Circumpolar Current — amid expectations they would find evidence of climate change in the Southern Ocean.

While the expedition's cameras found a wide range of corals, a high density of cardinal fish and the huge coral, the vast collection of brittle stars was the highlight of the voyage.

"I've personally never seen anything like this — all these animals, the sheer volume — all waiting for food from the current," expedition member and marine biologist Dr. Mireille Consalvey said Monday. "It challenged what we as scientists thought we knew."

Expedition leader and marine biologist Ashley Rowden said starfish usually cover only slopes away from the top of the undersea mountains.

"It got us excited as soon as we saw it," Rowden said of the site, dubbed "Brittle Star City."

The starfish are about 0.4 inch across, with arms about 2 inches long.

The expedition began March 26 and returned to port in New Zealand's capital Wellington on April 26.

Melbourne-based marine biologist Tim O'Hara, a brittle star specialist, said the vast collection of brittle stars, or ophiuroid ophiacantha, is "like a relic of ancient times."

"Normally fish would prey on them and eat them ... so for whatever reason there's a lack of fish predation there and it's seen this particular animal flourish," he said.

O'Hara, who was not part of the voyage, said the speed of the sea current in the area may partly explain why fish were not feeding on the tiny animals.

The Circumpolar Current merges the waters of the Atlantic, Indian and Pacific oceans and carries up to 150 times the volume of water flowing in all the world's rivers, oceanographer Mike Williams said.

Australian oceanographer Steve Rintoul, who was not involved in the expedition, said there have been few measurements of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current, which "strongly influences regional and global climate" by carrying vast amounts of water and heat across oceans.

Fewer than 200 of the world's estimated 100,000 sea mounts that rise more than a half a mile above the sea floor have been studied in any detail.

'Brittlestar City' discovered on underwater mountain
Yahoo News 19 May 08;

A unique colony of tens of millions of starfish-like creatures has been discovered on a mountain peak lying below the ocean in sub-Antarctic waters south of New Zealand, scientists said Monday.

Tens of millions of brittlestars are estimated to inhabit the vast, flat-topped marine mountain colony, dubbed Brittlestar City by scientists, New Zealand's National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA) said.

Scientists from New Zealand and Australia also collected some species never before recorded from the underwater peak -- known as a seamount -- on the Macquarie Ridge, which stretches 1,400 kilometres (870 miles) underwater from south of New Zealand to near the Antarctic Circle.

They photographed hundreds of brown-black brittlestars on every square metre (yard), and estimate tens of millions of them populate the 100-square-kilometre (39-square-mile) flat top of the seamount.

The brittlestars live arm-tip to arm-tip on the summit, 750 metres above the sea floor and 90 metres below the sea surface.

Their arms wave in the current, catching food which floats past on the circumpolar current, flowing at a rapid four kilometres an hour as it forces its way between peaks in the Macquarie Ridge.

"We were excited to see such a huge assemblage of brittlestars on the Macquarie Ridge seamount," said ecologist Dr Ashley Rowden of the NIWA.

He described the vast colony of brittlestars as amazing and said it would make a significant contribution to understanding life found on seamounts.

Corals and sponges are usually the dominant life forms on seamount peaks, filtering food that arrives on the current.

Biologists on the believed "Brittlestar City" was the first ever find of its kind on a seamount, attributing the unique discovery to the unusually flat shape of the peak and the rapid current.

"This current is estimated to be 110 to 150 times larger than all the water flowing in all the rivers of the world," said Mike Williams of NIWA.

"In terms of the world's oceans, New Zealand sits right beside the motorway."

The discovery was made during a month-long expedition on NIWA's research ship in April.

It is part of a study of seamounts being done as part of the Census of Marine Life, an ambitious global survey to document the life of the world's oceans.


Read more!

Study says global warming not worsening hurricanes

Seth Borenstein, Associated Press Yahoo News 19 May 08;

Global warming isn't to blame for the recent jump in hurricanes in the Atlantic, concludes a study by a prominent federal scientist whose position has shifted on the subject.

Not only that, warmer temperatures will actually reduce the number of hurricanes in the Atlantic and those making landfall, research meteorologist Tom Knutson reported in a study released Sunday.

In the past, Knutson has raised concerns about the effects of climate change on storms. His new paper has the potential to heat up a simmering debate among meteorologists about current and future effects of global warming in the Atlantic.

Ever since Hurricane Katrina in 2005, hurricanes have often been seen as a symbol of global warming's wrath. Many climate change experts have tied the rise of hurricanes in recent years to global warming and hotter waters that fuel them.

Another group of experts, those who study hurricanes and who are more often skeptical about global warming, say there is no link. They attribute the recent increase to a natural multi-decade cycle.

What makes this study different is Knutson, a meteorologist with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's fluid dynamics lab in Princeton, N.J.

He has warned about the harmful effects of climate change and has even complained in the past about being censored by the Bush administration on past studies on the dangers of global warming.

He said his new study, based on a computer model, argues "against the notion that we've already seen a really dramatic increase in Atlantic hurricane activity resulting from greenhouse warming."

The study, published online Sunday in the journal Nature Geoscience, predicts that by the end of the century the number of hurricanes in the Atlantic will fall by 18 percent.

The number of hurricanes making landfall in the United States and its neighbors — anywhere west of Puerto Rico — will drop by 30 percent because of wind factors.

The biggest storms — those with winds of more than 110 mph — would only decrease in frequency by 8 percent. Tropical storms, those with winds between 39 and 73 mph, would decrease by 27 percent.

It's not all good news from Knutson's study, however. His computer model also forecasts that hurricanes and tropical storms will be wetter and fiercer. Rainfall within 30 miles of a hurricane should jump by 37 percent and wind strength should increase by about 2 percent, Knutson's study says.

And Knutson said this study significantly underestimates the increase in wind strength. Some other scientists criticized his computer model.

MIT hurricane meteorologist Kerry Emanuel, while praising Knutson as a scientist, called his conclusion "demonstrably wrong" based on a computer model that doesn't look properly at storms.

Kevin Trenberth, a climate scientist, said Knutson's computer model is poor at assessing tropical weather and "fail to replicate storms with any kind of fidelity."

Trenberth, climate analysis chief at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colo., said it is not just the number of hurricanes "that matter, it is also the intensity, duration and size, and this study falls short on these issues."

Knutson acknowledges weaknesses in his computer model and said it primarily gives a coarse overview, not an accurate picture on individual storms and storm strength. He said the latest model doesn't produce storms surpassing 112 mph.

But NOAA hurricane meteorologist Chris Landsea, who wasn't part of this study, praised Knutson's work as "very consistent with what's being said all along."

"I think global warming is a big concern, but when it comes to hurricanes the evidence for changes is pretty darn tiny," Landsea said.

Hurricane season starts June 1 in the Atlantic and a Colorado State University forecast predicts about a 50 percent more active than normal storm season this year. NOAA puts out its own seasonal forecast on May 22.

In a normal year about 10 named storms form. Six become hurricanes and two become major hurricanes. On average, about five hurricanes hit the United States every three years.

'Fewer hurricanes' as world warms
Mark Kinver, BBC News 18 May 08;

Hurricanes and tropical storms will become less frequent by the end of the century as a result of climate change, US researchers have suggested.

But the scientists added their data also showed that there would be a "modest increase" in the intensity of these extreme weather events.

The findings are at odds with some other studies, which forecast a greater number of hurricanes in a warmer world.

The researchers' results appear in the journal Nature Geoscience.

The team from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (Noaa) Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory (GFDL) said its findings did not support the notion that human-induced climate change was causing an increase in the number of hurricanes and tropical storms.

"There have been some studies published that have suggested that this is the case, but this modelling study does not support that idea," observed lead author Tom Knutson.

"Rather, we actually simulate a reduction in hurricane frequency in the Atlantic."

Eye of the storm

Although the study projected that there would be fewer extreme weather events in the future, Dr Knutson said that these storms were likely to be more powerful.

"The model is simulating increased intensity of the hurricanes that do occur, and also increased rainfall rates.

"This is something that has been seen in previous studies, and the IPCC use this [scenario] as a likely projection for future climate warming.

"These changes in intensity are still fairly modest in size."

A previous study by Noaa scientists showed a 4% increase in storm intensity for every 1C (1.8F) increase in sea surface temperature. Yet, he explained, this study suggested only a 1-2% increase.

A sea surface temperature (SST) above 26.5C (79.7F) is one of the key factors in the formation and feeding of a hurricane.

Over recent decades, the surfaces of most tropical oceans have warmed by up to 0.5C (0.9F), which the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) believes has been caused by an increase in greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere.

In November 2006, the global community of tropical cyclone researchers gathered at a workshop organised by the World Meteorological Organization to consider the impact of human activity on the frequency and intensity of cyclones.

In a concluding statement, the researchers said that although there was evidence both for and against the existence of a detectable anthropogenic signal in the tropical cyclone climate record, no firm conclusion could be made.

One reason for the uncertainty is the changes in observation methods used to record Atlantic hurricanes - a record that dates back to 1850.

From 1944, air reconnaissance flights were used to monitor tropical storms and hurricanes. This development allowed researchers to monitor a much greater area and not rely on ships' logs and storms reaching land.

And from the late 1960s, satellite technology has been used to monitor and track hurricanes.

Therefore, a reliable record of past hurricane activity only stretches back about 35 years.

Natural variations that affect SSTs - such as El Nino and La Nina episodes and the Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation - add to the difficulty of identifying the influence of human-induced climate change on the frequency and intensity of hurricanes.

Model mechanics

Dr Knutson's colleague and co-author, Isaac Held, said the team's model used a different approach to previous efforts, which gave them a high degree of confidence in their results.

"Most of the literature to date on hurricanes and climate change has used statistical techniques," he said.

"You've had time series of hurricane activity and time series of sea surface temperatures, and people correlate them."

Because there was a high degree of confidence that the sea surface temperature trend was going to continue to rise, Dr Held explained, people had "tried to conclude that hurricane activity will increase rather dramatically in the future".

"We tried to simulate the fundamental fluid dynamics and thermodynamics that control hurricane genesis in the Atlantic in a numerical model to a very high resolution."

He added that the team ran data from the past 25 years through the model, and it returned results closely correlated to what actually occurred.

"It is interesting and important to understand why it is that this model is capable of simulating an increase in hurricane activity that we have seen in recent decades, yet it predicts a decrease in the future.

"This implies that we cannot simply extrapolate the past 25 years into the future."

Dr Knutson said that he did not expect the study's findings to end the scientific debate surrounding the impact of human-induced climate change on tropical storms.

"We do not regard this study as the last word on this topic," he told reporters.

"The main point that we want to emphasise is that there is no evidence in this study that we are seeing large greenhouse-gas-driven increases in Atlantic hurricane or tropical storm frequencies."


Read more!

Concern over small biomass option

Mark Kinver, BBC News 16 May 08;

Small-scale biomass power plants can have a greater environmental impact than other renewables, a study says.

UK researchers found that although the facilities offered carbon savings, they produced more pollutants per unit of electricity than larger biomass plants.

They suggested the way the feedstock was transported produced proportionally more pollutants than larger sites.

The findings challenged the view that such schemes offer an green alternative to grid-based electricity, they added.

Supporters of community biomass schemes say the power plants are sustainable because the fuel, such as wood chips, can be sourced from the local area.

Study co-author Patricia Thornley, from the Tyndall Centre for Climate Research at the University of Manchester, said the results did surprise the team.

"The fact that the carbon savings were pretty constant across the technologies, yet the emissions varied hugely was a surprise," she told BBC News.

The researchers examined 25 different biomass power generation systems, some of which were established technologies, while others were still at the development stage.

"Models were used to produce key indicators that summarised the performance of each bio-energy system," Dr Thornley explained.

Described as the most comprehensive study of its kind to date, four airborne pollutants - carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides, particulates and volatile organic compounds - were tracked across each system's life cycle - from field to power plant.

There were three main reasons for small biomass plants (less than two megawatts (MW)) producing more pollutants per unit of electricity than facilities larger than 5MW.

"The efficiency of smaller plants is generally lower," Dr Thornley observed.

"Therefore they are producing less electricity for every unit of pollutant they emit."

She added that small-scale plants also tended to use gas engines in the generation process, which also emitted pollutants.

Right solutions

"Perhaps the most interesting aspect is that small plants tend to use smaller scale transport systems, like tractors.

"These generally produce higher levels of pollutants than specialised haulage vehicles per tonne of material moved.

"Hence, particularly for nitrogen oxide and particulates, a larger proportion of the additional emissions from small plants are upstream of the conversion plant and relate to short distance haulage.

"Each of these reasons carries for the different systems studied, but the general trend is that the small systems do tend to perform worse than the larger ones."

The researchers, who presented their findings to the UK Energy Research Centre's sustainable energy conference in Oxford, hoped their findings will help policy makers and planners.

"Every energy option has pros and cons and you have to choose the right application," Dr Thornley explained.

"Where local communities are considering bio-energy, it is important they know that it does really matter much which system they choose in order to save carbon or create jobs - they are all pretty even on those measures.

"However, people often assume that small plants are more environmentally friendly than larger ones, yet these results show that is not necessarily the case."


Read more!