Reef fish get lost as climate changes

Michael Perry, Reuters 6 Mar 08;

SYDNEY (Reuters) - Climate change might be causing reef fish to get lost, unable to return to breeding grounds from the open ocean, which could have profound implications for the survival of reef ecosystems, Australian scientists say.

Climate change-induced environmental stress, including warmer and more acidic seawater, could be hindering the development of the ear bones in young reef fish, which rely on sound for navigation, the marine experts said on Friday.

The scientists from the James Cook University and the Australian Institute of Marine Science found that fish with asymmetrical ear bones struggle to return to their home reef.

"In our opinion, ear bone asymmetry in the early life stages of reef fish interferes with their capacity to find and settle on coral reefs," fish ecologist Monica Gagliano said in a statement.

Fish at the end of their "ocean stage" after hatching navigate by homing-in on reef-associated sounds, such as the gurgling of fish and the snapping of crustaceans, said the scientists, whose study was published on Friday in the British scientific journal Proceedings of the Royal Society.

Vertebrate animals make sense of sounds by comparing differences in the acoustic signal between their two ears. To do this well, ear structures must be relatively symmetrical. Asymmetrical ear bones do not appear to make the fish deaf, but might interfere with the ability of the fish to hear effectively.

The scientists said ear bone asymmetry could be closely linked to rising sea surface temperature and acidity, caused by high atmospheric carbon dioxide levels, as well as localized stresses. Oceans absorb CO2 from the atmosphere, acting as a giant sink for the greenhouse gas.

Fish ear bones, like fish skeletons and reef-building corals, are made from calcium carbonate. When seawater becomes more acidic, there is less calcium carbonate available for building calcium-based structures, including fish ear bones.

LOST AT SEA

The scientists studied damselfish, which are abundant on Australia's Great Barrier Reef and western Australia's Ningaloo Reef, and found that at hatching, 41 percent of a sample group of fish had symmetrical ear bones and 59 percent asymmetrical.

When the scientists examined the ear bones of fish returning from open ocean to settle on the reef a few weeks later, far fewer asymmetrical fish made their way back to the reef.

The scientists also found that those with asymmetrical ear bones that did make it to the reef took longer to do so than their symmetrical counterparts.

"There is a degree of asymmetry that is acceptable in the population, some is natural," said scientist Martial Depczynski.

"Not all the babies are created equal and not all of them are going to make it, even in pristine environments," said Depczynski.

But Depczynski said the already high mortality rate among reef fish hatchlings was likely to rise even higher if young fish could not navigate by sound.

The scientists said they suspected asymmetrical ear development might be responsible for a drop in the number of damselfish in recent years, but more study was needed.

"Five years ago we used to see them in the thousands, now they are not so plentiful," said Gagliano.

(Editing by David Fogarty)

Reef fish eavesdrop to find home
BBC News 7 Mar 08;

Coral reef fish spend weeks scouting out a new neighbourhood before they move in - just like human house buyers do, Edinburgh scientists have revealed.

The fish use their acute sense of hearing to eavesdrop on locations before deciding where to live.

Edinburgh University researchers studied shoals of fish near the Great Barrier Reef off Australia.

They found damselfish, cardinalfish, emperors and blennies chose communities by the "reef noise" they give off.

They then choose one based on their needs - in much the same way that a human would choose a new neighbourhood based on local schools or work commitments.

Very young fish - those who have just developed as larvae in the open sea - choose locations with invertebrates such as shrimp, which give off a high frequency sound, and hide in holes snatching passing food.

As they grow older, scientists say the fish become "more aware" of the social groups and communities they would like to live in.

They are then drawn towards reefs populated with fish - which produce a lower pitched sound - where they can find shoal mates, forage for food and expand their territories.

The research shows that these natural "cues" are important for determining how communities are established.

Shipping, drilling, mining and active sonar are all adding to levels of noise pollution, but the impacts on community structure are not known.

Dr Steve Simpson, of Edinburgh University's school of biological sciences, said: "These findings show that hearing is crucial for the survival of fish.

"Reef noise includes the sounds of invertebrates and fish feeding, and so provides other fish with direct information about the residents on the reef."

The research, funded by the Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) , the Fisheries Society of the British Isles (FSBI) and the British Ecological Society, has been published in the journals Coral Reefs, Animal Behaviour and Proceedings of the Royal Society.


Read more!

White killer whale spotted off Alaska

Mary Pemberton, Associated Press Yahoo News 7 Mar 08;

The white killer whale spotted in Alaska's Aleutian Islands sent researchers and the ship's crew scrambling for their cameras.

The nearly mythic creature was real after all.

"I had heard about this whale, but we had never been able to find it," said Holly Fearnbach, a research biologist with the National Marine Mammal Laboratory in Seattle who photographed the rarity. "It was quite neat to find it."

The whale was spotted last month while scientists aboard the Oscar Dyson, a National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration research ship, were conducting an acoustic survey of pollock near Steller sea lion haulout sites.

It had been spotted once in the Aleutians years ago but had eluded researchers since, even though they had seen many of the more classic black and white whales over the years.

Fearnbach said the white whale stood out.

"When you first looked at it, it was very white," she said Thursday.

Further observation showed that while the whale's saddle area was white, other parts of its body had a subtle yellowish or brownish color.

It likely is not a true albino given the coloration, said John Durban, a research biologist at NOAA's Alaska Fisheries Science Center in Seattle. That's probably a good thing — true albinos usually don't live long and can have health problems.

Durban said white killer whales have been spotted elsewhere in the area twice before: in 1993 in the northern Bering Sea around St. Lawrence Island and in 2001 near Adak in the central Aleutians. There have also been sightings along the Russian coast.

While Alaska researchers have documented thousands of black and white killer whales in the Bering Sea and the Aleutians during summer surveys, this was something new and exciting, Durban said.

"This is the first time we came across a white killer whale," he said.

The scientists observed several pods over a two-week period. The white whale was in a family group of 12 on a day when the seas were fairly rough. It was spotted about 2 miles off Kanaga Volcano on Feb. 23.

The ship stayed with the whale for about 30 minutes.

"Everybody actually came out and was taking pictures," Fearnbach said. "It was a neat sighting for everybody."

The whale appeared to be a healthy, adult male about 25 to 30 feet long and weighing upward of 10,000 pounds.


Read more!

No way to fix climate without private sector: UNDP

Reuters 7 Mar 08;

HELSINKI (Reuters) - The private sector must be encouraged to help developing countries combat climate change now, before it becomes too severe to handle, the head of the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) said.

Kemal Dervis said that while public transfers in form of official development assistance should be used to assist in "adaptation," or protection against potential catastrophes, the private sector should help finance long-term solutions.

"The shared mitigation costs will have to go through market mechanisms and will have to involve very strongly the private sector," he said on Thursday evening after giving a lecture on climate change.

"If there is no mitigation....then the impact on developing countries 20-30 years from now will become much more severe and the adaptation needs, climate proofing, building dams against floods, changing agricultural crops...will become huge and impossible to handle."

Developing countries such as India and China are already trying to reduce their carbon emissions, mainly to save on energy, but have baulked at doing more without technological and financial help from Europe, Japan and the United States.

Dervis also said that while the private sector involvement could come from the developing countries themselves, it should be supported by international financing mechanisms.

"We must build incentives that if you come up with a technology that does reduce emissions, you profit from it," he said, adding that by doing so rich countries would win as well.

"If rich country companies can get some of the emission reductions indirectly by investing in poor countries, you have a solution whereby they continue to produce more profitably at home, but also lead towards cleaner energy work."

(Reporting by Agnieszka Flak; editing by Philippa Fletcher)


Read more!

Vague Indonesian decree gives poachers leeway to plunder sea

The Jakarta Post 6 Mar 08;

FISHY BUSINESS: Indonesian-registered fishing trampers from Thailand are docked at a port belonging to fishing firm PT Maritim Timur Jaya. They were detained last December for alleged poaching (JP/Rendi A. Witular)

While Indonesia is still struggling to curb rampant illegal logging, the country also faces poaching on the open seas where wars between competing interests are often difficult to detect.

As crime scenes of illegal fishing are extremely remote and environmental destruction hard to measure, no kingpins of poaching syndicates have ever ended up in either jail or court.

On Tuesday, though, Indonesia and 10 other countries issued plans in Bali to jointly combat illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing.

The Jakarta Post's Rendi Akhmad Witular investigates the story behind illegal fishing, traveling to backwater Tual Island in Maluku province, a haven for the fishing industry. Here are the reports.

The police combat-type patrol boat 001 Ambon stands by to prevent 14 fishing vessels from slipping out of a port on Tual Island after the police detained the vessels for alleged poaching.

With the patrol boat's only weapon being an old shotgun, the 12 crew members have to ensure also that none of the 306 crew members of the detained vessels escape on smaller boats.

The 001 Ambon is the only vessel available for patrolling the open sea; and it is tasked with supervising almost the entire eastern part of Indonesia.

The 001 Ambon adds to the 20 vessels of the same type operated by the ministry of fisheries and maritime affairs to patrol the nation's 93,000 square kilometers of water, about the size of Hungary, and protect them from poaching.

Despite the lack of supervision facilities in place, the ministry grants fishing licenses that often end up in the hands of dishonest fishing companies.

A document obtained by The Jakarta Post from the ministry highlights the handling of licenses granted to local fishing companies working with foreign ones.

Ministry investigators have determined the document is valid in terms of internal administrative procedures. It indicates that licenses are being granted improperly, whether negligently or on purpose.

The document contains authorization from the ministry's director general of fishing and licenses, Ali Supardan, for fishing operations involving both local fishing firm PT Mina Jaya Bahari and a Thai fishing tramper, the Ocean Empire.

The 1,884-gross-ton tramper -- a vessel that receives and stores fish from other vessels -- has a 3,465-cubic-meter storage capacity.

The license granted by Ali, valid from Aug. 31, 2007, to Aug. 30, 2008, gives the tramper the right to dock in Tual, Merauke and Timika.

However, on Nov. 26, the tramper and several other vessels were detained by the police off Tual Island in Maluku for alleged poaching.

According to the National Police's deputy chief for special crimes, Sr. Comr. Sadar Sebayang, the tramper was receiving catches for export directly from fishing vessels. This violates regulations that require fishing vessels to transport catches to land-based processing plants first.

The regulations are aimed at stimulating employment and tax revenue in the fishing sector.

Because catching vessels cannot travel far on the open sea, police say, trampers are used in poaching operations to pool and transport illegally collected fish out of Indonesia to neighboring countries, especially Thailand.

According to the document, the decision by Ali to allow the tramper access to Indonesian waters was based merely on a private agreement involving a group of companies desiring the use of a tramper to transport processed catches for export.

Based on regulations, local and foreign joint-venture companies are required to have a processing plant before they are allowed to export fish.

However, pursuant to a 2006 decree signed by fisheries minister Freddy Numberi, an exception applies to fishing firms whose processing plants are not yet operational.

For wholly owned local firms the on-shore processing requirement is waived for a one-year period and such firms are allowed to export their catches directly.

These loopholes appear to relieve the authorizing agency -- in this case the director general of fishing and licenses -- from the duty to verify the compliance of fishing firms.

"It remains unclear whether the ministry is sloppy in granting licenses to troubled firms, or if there is a deliberate attempt on the part of some officials here to make way for poaching," said a senior ministry official who asked for anonymity, fearing dismissal for disclosing the information.

"Firms whose vessels are detained during a crackdown typically don't have processing units. They lease trampers and load their catches there for direct export. This is illegal," he said.

Ali denied he bent the rules to provide opportunities to dishonest firms to fish illegally.

"Overseas trampers are allowed to operate here ... local firms need them to transport their processed fish for export. But trampers must dock in the harbor to upload the fish."

He said he dealt with numerous applications and did not remember Ocean Empire's. "I only give licenses to trampers that comply with existing procedures."

Col. (ret) Firman, an executive for Mina Jaya, also denied police accusations his firm had violated any regulations. He said the tramper uploaded catches in the harbor, supervised closely by customs officials and officials from the fishery ministry.

According to the senior ministry official, while the 2006 decree had the appearance of protecting Indonesia from foreign fishing firms, in reality, by allowing foreigners to effectively hide behind Indonesian operations, it made it easier for them to poach here.

"The decree was made hastily. The directorate general of supervision had not yet given its approval when the decree was unexpectedly signed by Minister Freddy, (based) merely on the input of the directorate general of fishing and licenses," said the official.

The supervision directorate, he said, had demanded to see the draft of the decree in order to detect loopholes, as well as to prepare a clear-cut supervision system to detect and prevent irregularities in the granting of licenses.

Hanafi Rustandi, chairman of the Indonesian Seafarers Union, said while the minister claimed that foreign-sponsored local firms could help empower the country's fishing fleet, "our fishermen remain in backwaters while foreigners rake in proceeds from the sea".

From 1996 to 1998, Freddy was the commander of the naval base overseeing Papua and Maluku, including the resource-rich Sea of Arafura and fishing areas near Tual Island.

The ministry is now in the process of revising the 2006 decree, but loopholes remain in the draft revision, especially related to the direct export of certain fish -- such as tuna -- in connection with the land-based processing exception.

The draft effectively allows fishing vessels to net tuna at will and directly transfer them to trampers for export. This will make supervision difficult, especially when the loading takes place at sea.

The one-year waiver that exempts 100 percent locally owned fishing firms from having processing plants is another loophole that remains open in the current draft.

Ali acknowledged that the problematic language remained, but said immediate revision wasn't needed.

"We have left clauses in place for the next revision of the decree .... If you ask me whether we need a breakthrough in the new decree (to prevent poaching), I guess that won't be necessary right now."


Read more!

Best of our wild blogs: 7 Mar 08


Leaf Porter Crab
delightful writeup on the labrador blog

Voyage of the Tawny Coster
a gorgeous butterfly on the butterflies of singapore blog

Eurasian Tree Sparrow feeding fledglings
on the bird ecology blog

The Next Big Ideas in Conservation
on the nature conservancy website

Don’t panic: Earth speaks out on global warming
What would it have to say about global warming? “I’ll be absolutely fine”. Humans seem to be confusing the health of the planet with the survival of their own species. With a suggestion for a new slogan, on the Reuters Environment blog


Read more!

Arriving soon at Changi: T4

Leong Wee Keat, Today Online 7 Mar 08;

The "vast amount" of reclaimed land to the east of the airport could be a site for expansion.

LESS than two months after Changi Airport welcomed T3 to its fold, plans to build a new terminal, T4, are already in the works.

A $10-million upgrade of the Budget Terminal also starts in July, after last month's announcement of a $500-million makeover for Terminal 1. These plans are part of the Transport Ministry's strategy for Changi Airport to stay ahead of its rivals, such as those in Kuala Lumpur, Hong Kong and Dubai.

"It is critical ... that we take decisive steps to strengthen Changi's position as a leading air hub in the region," said Minister of State for Transport Lim Hwee Hua in Parliament yesterday.

She revealed that master planning for Terminal 4 (T4) had started but did not say more.

Aviation analysts told Today the development of a new passenger terminal could take 20 years. The Singapore Management University's assistant professor Terence Fan said this "would be trickier" than developing T3 had been.

"The major arterial road accessing the passenger terminals is already flanked on all three sides by the terminals," he said. The "vast amount" of reclaimed land to the east of the airport could be a site for expansion.

Government Parliamentary Committee chairman for transport Cedric Foo urged airport managers here to pay attention to details and make travel into Singapore "frictionless and seamless".

In light of ultra-long-haul planes being developed, MP Lam Pin Min asked if Changi's strength of high connectivity as a transit hub would become irrelevant.

Ms Lim assured the House that her ministry would continue its efforts to enhance Singapore's air hub status. Even as two airlines left Changi's fold last year, the Government will continue to reduce costs and provide incentives for them to grow their traffic out of Changi, through the Air Hub Development Fund.

The Government will continue to pursue air services liberalisation, said Ms Lim. Last year, Air Services Agreements with 18 countries, including Open Skies Agreements (OSAs) with five countries, were expanded.

The opening up of the Singapore-Kuala Lumpur route to the low-cost airlines last month was a result of the bilateral air services consultations last year, she said.

Last year, Low-Cost Carriers contributed 3.6 million or around 10 per cent of Changi's passenger traffic, and half its overall traffic growth. Further growth could be on the cards as Asean members have set a goal of lifting flight restrictions between capital cities this year.

To keep ahead of this, the Budget Terminal will be expanded, from its capacity of 2.7 million passengers per annum to 7 million passengers. Work will start in July and is expected to be completed by early next year. There will be more check-in counters, boarding gates and baggage handling equipment.

Apart from paying attention to hardware, Changi is also mindful of the software aspects of customer service, said Ms Lim. CAAS has been regularly monitoring key performance indicators such as the amount of time passengers would need to clear immigration, security screening, and collect their baggage. And Changi Airport has been meeting the targets set, she said.


Read more!

Oceans to fall, not rise, over millions of years

Alister Doyle, Reuters 6 Mar 08;

OSLO (Reuters) - Sea levels are set to fall over millions of years, making the current rise blamed on climate change a brief interruption of an ancient geological trend, scientists said on Thursday.

They said oceans were getting deeper and sea levels had fallen by about 170 meters (560 ft) since the Cretaceous period 80 million years ago when dinosaurs lived. Previously, the little-understood fall had been estimated at 40 to 250 meters.

"The ocean floor has got on average older and gone down and so the sea level has also fallen," said Bernhard Steinberger at the Geological Survey of Norway, one of five authors of a report in the journal Science.

"The trend will continue," he told Reuters.

A computer model based on improved understanding of shifts of continent-sized tectonic plates in the earth's crust projects more deepening of the ocean floor and a further sea level decline of 120 meters in 80 million years' time.

If sea levels were to fall that much now, Russia would be connected to Alaska by land over what is now the Bering Strait, Britain would be part of mainland Europe and Australia and Papua island would be the same landmass.

The study aids understanding of sea levels by showing that geology has played a big role alongside ice ages, which can suck vast amounts of water from the oceans onto land.

DOWN NOT UP

"If we humans still exist in 10, 20 or 50 million years, irrespective of how ice caps are waxing and waning, the long term ... is that sea level will drop, not rise," said lead author Dietmar Muller of the University of Sydney.

Over time, Muller told Science in a podcast interview there would be fewer mid-ocean ridges and a shift to more deep plains in the oceans as continents shifted. The Atlantic would widen and the Pacific shrink.

Still, the projected rate of fall works out at 0.015 centimeters a century -- irrelevant when the U.N. Climate Panel estimates that seas will rise by 18-59 cms by 2100 because of global warming stoked by human use of fossil fuels.

"Compared to what is expected due to climate change, the fall is negligible," said Steinberger. Cities from Miami to Shanghai are threatened by rising seas that could also swamp low-lying island nations in the Pacific.

Rising temperatures raise sea levels because water in the oceans expands as it warms, and many glaciers are melting into the seas.

Antarctica and Greenland now contain enough ice to raise sea levels by 50 meters if they all melted, the article said. If all ice on land were gone in 80 million years' time, the net drop in ocean levels would be 70 meters rather than the projected 120.

The study challenges past belief that sea levels might have been only 40 meters higher than today in the Cretaceous period by arguing that measurements from New Jersey in the United States had underestimated the fall.

It said that the New Jersey region had itself subsided by 105 to 180 meters in the period, skewing the readings.

(Editing by Andrew Roche)

Sea Levels to Plunge Long Term, Study of Dino Era Says
John Roach, National Geographic News 6 Mar 08;

About 80 million years ago—a time when dinosaurs ruled the Earth—global sea levels were roughly 560 feet (170 meters) higher than they are today, according to a new study.

If sea levels were that high now, vast regions would be flooded: most of northern Europe, large sections of South America, the East Coast of North America, and parts of Australia.

In Washington, D.C., the tip of the Washington Monument would poke just above the water. The base of the 555-foot-tall (169-meter-tall) obelisk is currently 30 feet (9 meters) above sea level.

The finding stems from more than a decade of effort to virtually reconstruct ancient ocean basins to understand how their size and depth have changed since the Cretaceous, which lasted from 145.5 to 65.5 million years ago.

The result is a dramatic image of historic sea level change that goes beyond what is expected in the coming decades due to rapid global warming-induced ice cap melting.

"There're natural processes that also contribute to sea level change and are in fact independent of ice cap melting," said Dietmar Müller, a geologist at the University of Sydney in Australia.

In fact, the data reveal that the long-term trend in sea levels since the Cretaceous has been downward, said Müller, who led the study appearing in tomorrow's issue of the journal Science.

When this trend is extrapolated out 80 million years from now, it suggests that even if all of today's ice caps were to melt, sea levels would be 230 feet (70 meters) lower than they are today.

Rising and Sinking

Pictured on today's globe, that much of a sea level drop would mean that Indonesia would be largely connected to mainland Southeast Asia.

Furthermore, all the continents would be larger, so today's coastal cities would be stranded inland.

But it's hard to know exactly what Earth's landmasses might look like in 80 million years, because in addition to sea level changes, plate tectonics should significantly shift the continents.

Some plates will bump and grind, others will drift apart, and still others will dive under landmasses and melt within Earth's hot interior.

According to the new study, a key factor in sea level change is the creation and spreading of new ocean crust along underwater mountain chains called mid-ocean ridges, Müller said.

"As the ocean floor moves away from the hot and shallow mid-ocean ridges into parts of the abyssal plains, it cools and sinks," he explained.

Currently the mid-ocean ridges lie, on average, 1.6 miles (2.5 kilometers) beneath sea level, while the abyssal plains sit 3.7 miles (6 kilometers) deep.

"That's a huge difference, and if you change the relative proportion of mid-ocean ridges and abyssal plains in the ocean basins, you change [the ocean's] volume, and this is what we have tried to reconstruct," he said.

The team found that, during the late Cretaceous, huge mid-ocean ridges wrapped around the planet, making the global ocean much shallower on average than it is today.

In particular, a mid-ocean ridge system in an ancient ocean called Panthalassa—the precursor to the Pacific—was a crucial force driving sea level change through time, Müller said.

Much of that system no longer exists, which largely explains why sea levels have fallen over the last 80 million years.

Going forward, the researchers' model suggests the Atlantic Ocean will continue to grow and the Pacific Ocean will shrink as more mid-ocean ridges disappear.

"As time goes by, we will therefore increase the volume of the ocean basins because it will become deeper than average, so this will result in a long-term sea level drop," Müller said.

Commendable Job

Kenneth Miller is a geologist at Rutgers University in New Jersey.

He has also worked on late Cretaceous sea level estimates, and he commended Müller and colleagues' work.

"In ten years this is still going to be the most widely cited paper on this topic," he said, adding that the latest estimate for Cretaceous-era sea level is more reasonable than any other in the published literature, including his own.

According to Miller, studies like this are important to gain an understanding and appreciation of how plate tectonics drive sea level changes over million-year time scales.

But Miller cautioned against comparing the long-term, plate tectonic-driven changes in sea level to the short-term dangers from melting ice caps.

"The main effect for people who care about what's happening into the future is to understand how fast the ice caps are melting," he said.

And many studies have shown that the ice caps are melting rapidly, pushing sea levels higher.


Read more!

Small Vietnamese Tanker Spills Oil, 14 Crew Missing

PlanetArk 7 Mar 08;

HANOI - A small Vietnamese oil tanker capsized off the south-central coast, spilling fuel oil and leaving 14 crew missing, provincial officials said on Thursday.

The officials in Binh Thuan province said the tanker Duc Tri was carrying 1,700 tonnes of fuel oil, about 30 tonnes of which have leaked 50 km (32 miles) off the popular beach resort of Mui Ne on March 2.

"The search for the missing is still ongoing and rescuers are also trying to contain the oil spill," an official in the Binh Thuan province information centre said by telephone.

She said one crew member had been rescued. Binh Thuan is about 300 km (186 miles) northeast of Ho Chi Minh City.

The oil spill was about 2 square nautical miles, state media quoted Trinh Vu Anh, Deputy Director of the Southern Oil Spill Prevention Centre, as saying.

Last year, oil spills struck more than 20 provinces, including central Danang and south-central Nha Trang. Vietnamese media reported that nearly 2,000 tonnes of oil were scraped off the beaches and water.

The causes were mostly mysterious, according to a series of investigations, which speculated oil came from a leaking oil rig, damaged tanker or oil and gas platforms in the South China Sea.

(Reporting by Nguyen Nhat Lam; Editing by Grant McCool)


Read more!

Is there a place for cyclists in Singapore transport system?

Li Xueying, Straits Times 7 Mar 08;

THE British government will invest £140 million (S$390 million) over the next three years to boost cycling as a means of public transport. In Chicago, the mayor himself cycles to work, setting an example for the city. Paris has distributed thousands of low-cost rental bikes.

What about Singapore, asked Ms Irene Ng (Tampines GRC).

The Land Transport Authority (LTA), she charged, has been 'reluctant to provide leadership in developing bike-friendly infrastructure and policies, or to take bicycles seriously'.

'Its moves towards facilitating the use of bicycles have been tentative and piecemeal at best,' she said.

What it should do, said the MP, who is the patron of the Singapore Amateur Cycling Association, is to commission a 'serious study' to examine how congested cities have integrated bicycles seamlessly into their transport system.

In Singapore, she noted, the debate on the role of bicycles has centred on whether cyclists should share footpaths with pedestrians.

'But this masks the real issue - whether cyclists have a place in Singapore's transport system.'

The situation is especially urgent, in view of how 541 cyclists or pillion riders were killed or injured last year, as Ms Ng noted. This is a 44 per cent increase from 2005.

Also calling for more action on this front, Mr Teo Ser Luck (Pasir Ris-Punggol GRC) suggested a comprehensive set of dedicated cycling tracks and cycle lanes islandwide.

Responding to the two MPs, Minister of State for Transport Lim Hwee Hua said Mr Teo's call is 'not feasible', given Singapore's land constraints.

'The issue is not whether cyclists have a place in our transport system, but how do we allocate space among competing users that will best make use of our limited land,' she said.

She reminded them of several measures the LTA will implement, for instance, better bicycle parking facilities at MRT stations and bus interchanges.

On the issue of studying other cities' experience, the LTA 'will continue' to do so. But she added: 'It is important that we tailor the experience of overseas cities to our local context.'


6-month trial to let cyclists bring foldable bicycles on trains, buses
Channel NewsAsia 7 Mar 08;

SINGAPORE : There will be a six-month trial from the middle of this month to allow cyclists to carry their foldable bicycles on board trains and buses.

In addition, to make it more convenient for cyclists to use public transport, there will also be better bicycle parking facilities at MRT stations and bus interchanges in housing estates.

Announcing the good news for cyclists in Parliament on Thursday, Minister of State for Transport Lim Hwee Hua said the government recognised that cycling provides an additional if not alternative mode of transport.

This is especially for intra-town travel and to key transport nodes, like the MRT stations and the bus interchanges.

So as part of plans to promote greater use of public transport, a one-year pilot will also be carried out next year at MRT stations and bus interchanges in Pasir Ris, Tampines and Yishun.

Mrs Lim said this would allow the Land Transport Authority to gather feedback so as to better understand the usage patterns and needs of the cyclists before extending the facilities to all other MRT stations and bus interchanges.

However, she drew the line at providing dedicated cycling lanes.

Mrs Lim explained, "Given our land constraints, it is not feasible to provide a comprehensive set of dedicated cycling tracks or cycle lanes island-wide. We have to ask ourselves if this is the best way to make full use of our...very limited space.

"The issue is not whether cyclists have a place in our public transport system, but how do we allocate space amongst competing users that will best make use of our very limited land."

The issue of better facilities for cyclists was brought up by MP Irene Ng of Tampines GRC as well as Mr Teo Ser Luck, the Parliamentary Secretary for Community Development, Youth and Sports. - CNA/ms


Read more!

Vital for Singapore to pursue renewable energy policy

Letter from Tan Tze Kiang, Straits Times Forum 7 Mar 08;

I AM disappointed by the response on Monday to the question of solar power by Minister of State for Trade & Industry S. Iswaran, who is also chairman of the International Advisory Panel on Energy ('Singapore gives solar energy sector a $20m boost').

Except for maintenance cost, solar power is a renewable resource that is almost free, once installed. So it is hard to understand Mr Iswaran's argument that subsidies will dampen price signals when energy is free. As long as the sun shines, there is no risk of over-consumption or waste.

His point about a consistent energy policy is regressive. Instead of a blanket approach, we should fine-tune the policy by studying individual energy sources. If the Government is sophisticated enough to formulate means testing for all Singaporeans, it can create a multi-tiered approach to alternative energy subsidies.

While I appreciate the importance of researching and developing alternative energy sources that will lower costs for all Singaporeans, the Government should subsidise those who are willing to pay the relatively heavy start-up costs for a cleaner and greener environment.

Mr Iswaran sees strong economic growth as the best response to the uncertain global energy outlook. This essentially means buying our way into meeting our energy needs. But oil executives, geologists, investment bankers, academics and others have warned the world of high oil prices, and the ensuing fallout, for some years now.

'Peak oil', where oil production reaches its limits, is no longer a theory. Pursuing alternative energy sources is not just an environmental issue but has huge economic repercussions too. Pursuing a renewable energy policy is the only way to create a sustainable economic and environmental future.

My main concern is the notion that economic growth will suffer if we aggressively pursue an alternative energy policy. We face a climate crisis. Money spent to address this problem should not be seen as a subsidy any more but an investment in long-term growth. The technology is already available to make solar energy a viable option.

As Nobel Prize-winning environmental advocate Al Gore has said: 'Political will is a renewable resource.'


Read more!

Free-market principle hurts some pedigree dogs in Singapore

Letter from Grace Peh (Mrs), Straits Times Forum 7 Mar 08;

I REFER to the article, '1,521 pedigree dogs dumped' (Feb 28). I was at the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA) two weeks ago and was shocked at the number of huskies there.

Why is it inappropriate to impose a restriction on the breed and number of dogs coming in to Singapore? Huskies are cold-climate dogs and Singapore has a tropical climate. How many owners of huskies actually live in landed properties with lots of space for the dogs to run around?

Some points to note:

# Young huskies make good pets if given plenty of space to run and play. But their high demand for exercise and activity makes them a poor choice for urban residents;

# In more humid regions, huskies are prone to develop ear and related infections;

# If several huskies are kept in the same lot, they tend to be vocal, howling and barking at each other and any other dogs in the vicinity unless they are trained to be quiet. In crowded neighbourhoods, this can be a nuisance to neighbours;

# Huskies make relatively poor household dogs; and

# They may be considered hyperactive by sedate humans, running in circles inside a house when bored or cramped. If left alone in a dwelling for long, they may engage in destructive behaviour out of boredom, mischief or malice.

In drawing up rules, we should consider the welfare of dogs and their suitability in our tropical climate. How many more dogs will be dumped or put to sleep just because their owners suddenly had no time for them or found them too troublesome to care for?

Related articles

A cute puppy is not just a status symbol

Letter from Tan Ai Ling, Today Online 4 Mar 08;

If you want pets, please adopt one that has been abandoned
Time for pet owners to reflect on their actions

Today Online 29 Feb 08;
Letter from TAN CHEK WEE
Letter from MARIANNE MAES

SPCA requests AVA to restrict import, breeding, sale of pedigree dogs
Channel NewsAsia 27 Feb 08;


Read more!

Indian City Aims to Poison 100,000 Stray Dogs

Hilal Ahmed, Associated Press National Geographic News 6 Mar 08;

Authorities in Indian Kashmir have begun poisoning stray dogs in an anti-rabies drive that aims to kill some hundred thousand dogs in the region's main city, Srinagar, officials said Thursday.

Animal rights activists vowed to go to court to stop the slaughter, saying it is an illegal and cruel solution to a problem that could be better addressed with other methods.

With the world's highest rabies fatality rate, India has grappled with ways to control the millions of stray dogs that live on its streets.

In Srinagar, city officials vowed to press ahead with the plan already under way to poison strays with strychnine. (See a map of India.)

"These dogs have become a big nuisance and they are threatening humans," said Riyaz Ahmad, the Srinagar city health officer who is organizing the killing.

It was not clear Thursday how many dogs have already been killed.

Crying Children, Dying Dogs

Animal activists aimed to stop the poisoning drive, said Javaid Iqbal Shah, the deputy head of the Srinagar Society to Prevent Cruelty to Animals.

Shah said using strychnine was particularly cruel, causing terrible suffering to the dogs, crippling their nervous systems and choking them.

"I have seen children cry when they pass by these dying dogs," he said.

Shah said he had proposed the city sterilize strays instead but acknowledged that his organization had only managed to neuter 400 dogs in the last two years.

Feral Packs and Community Pets

India accounts for more than 60 percent of the world's estimated 35,000 annual rabies deaths, according to the World Health Organization, and stray dogs are often blamed.

In some areas, dogs form feral packs that have attacked people. However, other strays are "community pets," semi-tame animals that are cared for and fed by local residents.

Other cities have struggled unsuccessfully to curb the stray-dog problem, with a variety of solutions.

India's high-tech hub of Bangalore called off a drive to slaughter strays amid allegations that untrained workers were stoning, strangling, and beating the dogs to death.

In New Delhi, one city councilor suggested shipping the country's strays to Korea, where dog meat is considered a delicacy.


Read more!

All talk, little action to save Sumatran tiger and other wildilfe

Mata Jeli: A Perspective on Indonesian Affairs
All talk, little action to save endangered wildlife
Bruce Gale, Straits Times 7 Mar 08;

A SOLDIER shot dead a Sumatran tiger caught in a trap, skinned it and distributed its meat to villagers in January. The incident, in the Bengkalis regency of Riau province, took place after the animal was trapped in a pig snare. But instead of saving the tiger, which is in danger of extinction, the soldier reportedly fired nine bullets into its body and head.

Two villagers who witnessed the shooting were angry enough to report the matter to the Sumatran Tiger Conservation Programme Foundation. But there were probably quite a few other villagers present who reacted differently. In recent years, protected animals such as tigers and elephants have entered local settlements in Bengkalis regency after wildlife habitats in protected rainforests had been damaged by illegal loggers. The animals have killed people, goats and buffaloes.

Conflict between humans and protected animals has become a regular feature of life in Bengkalis, as in several other parts of Riau.

Over a period of several weeks last month, about 40 wild elephants destroyed farms and devoured crops in Balaimakam village. Villagers responded by burning tyres at various points in the settlement to drive them away.

Villagers in other parts of the regency have reacted more aggressively. According to the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF), villagers in Mandau reportedly poisoned or poached 13 elephants last year.

The attacks on human settlements are a direct result of the fact that the natural habitats of these animals are shrinking. When the Forestry Ministry created Riau's Balairaja conservation forest in 1986, for example, it consisted of about 18,000ha. But a WWF 2006 survey showed that only 200ha were left, the rest having been converted into oil palm plantations and human settlements.

The WWF also says that the number of elephants in the province has dropped from an estimated 210 about 25 years ago to 192 now. The Sumatran tiger is even more critically endangered, with fewer than 400 believed to be left in the wild anywhere.

Orang utans are illegally hunted or sold into captivity. According to the Forestry Ministry, deforestation has led to the deaths of 3,000 orang utans per year across the archipelago since the 1970s. Current data suggests that there are only about 6,650 Sumatran orang utans and 55,000 Borneo orang utans remaining in the wild.

Although Indonesia has ratified the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species and enacted a variety of laws designed to protect endangered animals, conservation has yet to become an important issue for either government officials or the public.

Indeed, Mr Toni Suhartono, director for biological diversity affairs at the Forestry Ministry, admitted last year that the government wasn't really sure how many species in the country were facing extinction.

'We don't even have exact data on the animal species kept in the country's zoos,' he told the media at a dialogue session, adding that it was difficult to obtain financing for conservation programmes.

Further evidence of the lacklustre official effort surfaced last month when TRAFFIC, a British wildlife monitoring body, released the results of its 2006 survey on the illegal trade in tiger parts. The report said that tiger teeth, claws, whiskers and bones were on sale in souvenir and antique shops and traditional Chinese pharmacies in 28 cities and towns across Sumatra.

TRAFFIC added that it provided the Indonesian government with details of the traders involved in April last year, but the authorities had not taken any action against them.

But while official efforts to deal with the problem often seem half-hearted, there have been some encouraging developments. In April last year, for example, the Lampung provincial government announced plans to relocate thousands of residents from villages that had been attacked by elephants in the South Bukit Barisan National Park. Most of the villagers were squatters who had moved into the area as a result of forest conversion to palm oil plantations and illegal logging.

Responding to pressure from the international community, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono also announced an ambitious conservation strategy at the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Bali last December. Supporters said it could save as much as one million hectares of virgin rainforest scheduled for conversion into palm oil plantations.

Under the programme, which lasts until 2017, the carbon dioxide saved through avoided forest deforestation would be traded on the carbon market and the money used to conserve orang utans and boost the country's economy.

The conservation plan, however, does not address the issue of illegal logging, which remains one of the main causes of the destruction of wildlife habitats. One UN report released last year noted that the use of bribery or armed force by logging companies was common, and that park rangers had insufficient numbers, arms, equipment and training to cope.

The point was underlined by Mr Suhartono in November last year, when he told the media that only seven rangers patrolled Riau's 38,576ha Tesso Nilo National Park. A more reasonable number, he believed, would be 38 rangers - one ranger per 1,000ha.

'There is a stark difference,' he said, 'between our needs and the number of workers (we have)'. Wood from the park was allegedly delivered to Sumatran pulp and paper mills in 2003 and 2004.

Security at border areas, including international airports and seaports, needs to be stepped up in order to deter wildlife smuggling. According to Senior Police Commissioner Sadar Sebayang, such illegal activity also takes place in more remote border areas where there is little or no law enforcement.

Apart from the trade in tiger parts and live orang utans (which some non-governmental organisations say can fetch around US$40,000 each in Europe), Mr Sebayang noted that scaly anteaters have been smuggled to Malaysia from Medan and snakes to Hong Kong from Bali. Turtles have also been illegally transported to China and Taiwan.

Official promises of action, including the conservation plans announced in Bali last year, have been greeted with scepticism by most NGOs. But for those who prefer to live in hope, a 2007 Unesco report entitled Last Stand Of The Orang Utan holds out a morsel.

The 52-page report describes Jakarta's 2006 decision to train specially equipped ranger units to protect national parks as a 'promising counter-measure'. But it hastens to add that the programme requires substantial strengthening, given the scale of the problem.


Read more!

Wet weather clears haze over Singapore

Satellite data shows drop in number of fires in Indonesia creating the smoke
Tania Tan, Straits Times 7 Mar 08;

SAY goodbye to the haze - for now.

The skies over Singapore have not only cleared, but they have also opened up, dumping 90mm of rain on parts of the island over the past week.

The wet weather that got rid of the haze - caused by slash-and-burn clearing of forests in Indonesia - is expected to stick around, said the National Environment Agency (NEA).

Moderate to heavy showers can be expected till the middle of this month, as the inter-monsoon season rolls in, said the NEA's Meteorological Service.

The rain has given Singaporeans at least a temporary respite from the smoke, which caused the air quality here to hit the moderate range last week.

The haze was sparked by smoke from forest fires in Sumatra.

The levels, though, were still a far cry from the worst haze episode in recent memory.

In October 2006, the PSI (Pollutant Standards Index) hit an unhealthy 150.

A reading of 101 to 200 can lead to sneezing, coughing or eye irritation among healthy people, and respiratory problems among those with breathing difficulties.

Last week, it hovered in the 50s. Yesterday's reading was 33.

Satellite data from the National University of Singapore (NUS) has shown a drop in Indonesian 'hot spots' - locations of fires or potential blazes.

'It has been very quiet in the past week, with a combined hot-spot count over Sumatra and Kalimantan of fewer than five every day,' said Mr Chia Aik Song, a scientist at the NUS' Centre for Remote Imaging, Sensing and Processing.

Heavy cloud cover over Sumatra also suggests rainfall, which would douse any fires in the region, he added.


Read more!

Outcry over cheap rents for forests in Indonesia

Govt is offering mining companies land to collect rent for state coffers
Salim Osman, Straits Times 7 Mar 08;

JAKARTA - A NEW decree offering open-pit mining companies cheap rents for Indonesia's 'protected' forests has sparked an uproar and a growing environmental campaign against the practice.

Under the decree, signed by the President last month, companies can rent forest for an annual rate of just 3 million rupiah (S$460) per hectare, or 300 rupiah per square metre.

Mr Rully Syumada of Walhi, the Indonesian Forum for the Environment, has now organised a campaign to get the public to rent as much forest land as possible, before the mining companies can get their hands on it.

And he says: 'It's so cheap and far below the market value of the forest land. With 300 rupiah, you can buy pisang goreng (banana fritters).'

Environmentalists also fear the mines will be just the thin end of the wedge, with the decree also opening the land up to exploitation for oil and gas drilling, and the construction of electricity transmission towers and toll roads.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has defended the decree, signed on Feb 4, as a follow-up to decrees set by the Megawati administration allowing 13 mining firms to operate in protected forests.

He says it will encourage mining firms to immediately contribute to state coffers.

But critics point to the fact that, unlike the earlier decrees, it does not limit rights to certain companies, something confirmed by Energy Minister Purnomo Yusgiantoro last Friday when he said the scheme was open to any company which could pay the rent.

And the executive director of environmental group Greenomics Indonesia, Mr Elfian Effendi, says the mining sector would contribute only 0.17 per cent of the 1.5 trillion rupiah state budget for the year.

He says this is a far lower sum than what the environmentalists claim is the ecological cost of 70 trillion rupiah a year when protected forests are opened up to mining.

And he has accused the government of 'looking for so many ways to allow open pit mining in protected forests'.

So far, Mr Rully's move to block the mining companies has received support from Dr Din Syamsuddin, head of the second largest Muslim organisation Muhammadiyah and singer-cum-social activist Franky Sahilatua, who each donated 30 million rupiah to be used to rent 10ha of protected forest for two years.

Former environmental minister Nabiel Makarim, also donated 50,000 rupiah, saying that the decree 'will only allow businesses to destroy the forests'.

Meanwhile, the government has insisted on going ahead with enforcing the regulation, saying the fees collected could be used to 'regenerate' the country's ailing forests.

But Mr Rully told The Straits Times the decree was simply an 'about turn' by the government, coming hot on the heels of a strong commitment during the run-up to the Bali climate change meetings in December to preserve and restore Indonesia's forests.

'The President has not been consistent in his stand,' he said.

'He promised to protect the forest but now he has signed a decree that will destroy our forest and contribute to global warming.'

Indonesian mining rules alarm green groups
Reuters 7 Mar 08;

JAKARTA (Reuters) - An Indonesian conservation group said on Friday the government should be ashamed for approving a decree allowing mining companies operating in tropical forests to pay as little as $200 a hectare to rent more land.

Under a presidential decree issued on February 4, mining firms, including open-pit miners, will be able to pay between 1.8 million and 2.4 million rupiah ($200-$265) per hectare (2.5 acres) for forest land used for activities such as housing, roads, mine sites and waste dumps.

Indonesia had the fastest pace of deforestation in the world between 2000-2005, according to Greenpeace, with an area of forest equivalent to 300 soccer pitches destroyed every hour.

"Indonesia should be ashamed of itself," said Siti Maemunah of the Mining Advocacy Network, a conservation group.

She said the decree left open the prospect of more firms getting permits to operate in forests, adding that President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono appeared not to recognize the huge environmental problems facing the country.

She called for the decree to be revoked and also noted it was issued weeks after Indonesia hosted a U.N. climate change conference in Bali at which curbing deforestation was a top issue.

Indonesian green group Walhi has also protested the move.

Since Monday, the Jakarta-based NGO has collected donations from almost 600 people to buy more than three million square meters of protected forest before mining companies get to it.

The money has been presented to the government and the campaign will open to international supporters next week, said Walhi forest campaigner Rully Syumada in Jakarta.

COMPENSATION FUND

Previously, firms had to provide new land to compensate for the use of forest areas, at twice the scale of the mining area for operations in Java and the same elsewhere in Indonesia.

But under the new decree, mining firms, during their contract period, pay into a compensation fund that would be used to replant forests, forestry ministry spokesman Ahmad Fauzi said.

"It's impossible to find new land to replant the forest that they have taken (for mining). We can't make rules which are not applicable. It may spark protest from the public," Fauzi said.

The decree applies to 13 mining firms that four years ago were allowed to resume operations in forest areas -- including Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold which operates the massive Grasberg mine in Indonesia's remote Papua province that has been a frequent source of controversy over its environmental impact.

Indonesia's forestry law issued in 1999 prohibited open-pit mining in protected forest areas. But in 2004, Indonesia's fourth president, Megawati Sukarnoputri, issued a decree to allow the companies to resume operations in protected areas.

It was not clear whether the new decree will be extended to allow other mining companies to apply for permits to operate in protected forests.

The decree also applies to oil and gas companies, as well as companies involved in power transmission, hydro and geothermal power, and toll road operators.

"Permits will depend on the energy and mines ministry. But as long as they use our forest, they have to pay," Fauzi said.

The Indonesian Coal Mining Association said the latest decree could help spur flagging investment in the mining sector.

"It would not immediately spur new investment but it will increase appetite," association chairman Jeffrey Mulyono told reporters late Thursday.

Indonesia has some of the world's largest deposits of coal, copper, tin, nickel and gold, and is keen to earn more from the sector, particularly as strong demand from China and India has been driving prices up for many commodities to record levels.

(Reporting by Muhammad Al Azhari, Fitri Wulandari and Sally Pranowo; Editing by Ed Davies and David Fogarty)

($1 = 9,055 rupiah)

Related article

More protected Indonesian forests up for grabs

Ika Krismantari, The Jakarta Post 1 Mar 08;


Read more!

Global warming not cooling travelers' wanderlust

Sylvia Westall, Reuters 6 Mar 08;

BERLIN (Reuters) - Global warming's threat to the existence of the exotic resorts and beaches tourists crave has not dented holidaymakers' appetites for pollution-producing, long-haul trips, experts said at Berlin's annual tourism fair.

In his opening speech to the International Tourism Exchange fair earlier this week, German Economy Minister Michael Glos said climate change was a serious problem for the future of the travel industry.

A Deutsche Bank report demonstrated how the industry would suffer if the effects of global warming, including rising temperatures and water shortages, hit popular holiday destinations such Spain and Australia.

According to United Nations' research, tourism accounts for 5 percent of world carbon dioxide emissions, which scientists have linked to rising atmospheric temperatures.

But exhibitors at the fair say tourists so far are not that worried about the environmental cost of their holidays.

"There is heightened awareness, but does that mean people are willing to change their approach to travel? The answer is no," said Geoff Buckley, managing director of Australia's tourism board.

Online travel agency Expedia says it has seen no decline in the number of people taking long-haul flights and that climate worries are a peripheral concern for travelers.

"People are concerned about climate change but they don't want to change their habits," said Expedia spokeswoman Claudia Ressel, who added that holidaymakers were happier to contribute to carbon-offsetting schemes rather than travel less.

Two of Germany's largest tourism groups, Thomas Cook and TUI said they will do more to promote carbon-offsetting schemes for customers booking flights. But interest in such voluntary schemes, where others are paid to cut emissions on the airlines' behalf, has so far been small.

Another area that has failed to take off yet is eco-tourism in which people opt for train over air travel and make shorter journeys, said Klaus Liedtke, editor of National Geographic Deutschland magazine.

German tourism companies say business is booming, despite an expected slowdown in national economic growth, with the tourism industry expected to grow by 3 percent to 4 percent this year.

And travel groups argue exotic destinations in developing countries would take a severe economic hit if they were to fall out of favor with tourists.

"Tourism is an easy target," said Nancy Cockerell from the Travel Business Partnership consultancy. "But it's both the culprit and the victim."

(Editing by Mary Gabriel)


Read more!

Manmade flood from US dam unleashed in Grand Canyon

Amanda Lee Myers, Associated Press Yahoo News 7 Mar 08;

Four arcs of water unleashed from a dam coursed through the Grand Canyon on Wednesday in a flood meant to mimic the natural ones that used to nourish the ecosystem by spreading sediment.

More than 300,000 gallons of water per second were released from Lake Powell above the dam near the Arizona-Utah border. That's enough water to fill the Empire State Building in 20 minutes, said Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne.

"This gives you a glimpse of what nature has been doing for millions of years, cutting through and creating this magnificent canyon," Kempthorne said after he pulled the lever releasing the water from Glen Canyon Dam, upstream from Grand Canyon National Park.

The water gushed from two of four giant steel tubes in parallel arcs into the Colorado River. By afternoon, water poured from all four tubes, creating a churning pool beneath the sheer, sandstone canyon walls rising hundreds of feet.

The water level in the Grand Canyon rose 2 to 15 feet in some places. After the flood ends Friday, officials hope the water will leave behind sediment and restore sandbars as it goes back to normal levels. Officials have flooded the canyon twice before, in 1996 and 2004.

Before the dam was built in 1963, the river was warm and muddy, and natural flooding built up sandbars that are essential to native plant and fish species. The river is now cool and clear, its sediment blocked by the dam.

The change helped speed the extinction of four fish species and push two others, including the endangered humpback chub, near the edge.

Shrinking beaches have led to the loss of half the camping sites in the canyon in the past decade. Since Glen Canyon Dam was built, 98 percent of the sediment carried by the Colorado River has been lost, Grand Canyon National Park Superintendent Steve Martin said.

Martin said manmade floods need to occur every time there's enough sediment to do so — about every one to two years depending on Arizona's volatile monsoon season.

"The science is really clear that's what we need to do," Martin said.

The Grand Canyon Trust, a Flagstaff-based group that has been critical of the federal Bureau of Reclamation's management of the dam, also is calling for more regular high flows.

"The power industry is driving the Bureau of Reclamation more than anything else, as opposed as to what's best for the canyon," trust spokesman Richard Mayol said.

Scientists will document habitat changes and determine how backwater habitats are used by the chub and other fish. Another study will look at how higher water flows affect the aquatic food base.


Read more!

China Province Seeks Dams Despite Environment Fears

PlanetArk 7 Mar 08;

BEIJING - China's southwestern province of Yunnan is still hoping to build controversial dams and hydropower plants on the upper reaches of the Salween River, a senior official said on Thursday, despite environmental concerns.

Premier Wen Jiabao in 2004 ordered an environmental study of the proposed dams on the river known in China as the Nu, after environmental officials and scientists mobilised opposition to the plans.

At that time, many critics of the project -- which is near a World Heritage site, leading the United Nations to express concern -- assumed it was entirely dead.

But Yunnan officials eager to promote economic growth, and energy officials eager to slake China's thirst for electricity, have continued to promote the dams.

Bai Enpei, Yunnan's Communist Party boss, told Reuters in an interview on the sidelines of China's annual meeting of parliament that the dams would bring much needed income to the area, which in turn would help environmental protection.

"We are actively pushing the development of hydropower plants, including on the Nu River," he said. "But their construction must take into account those downstream. And the environment must protected. The people must also benefit.

"Some oppose and some support the Nu River projects. I am on the supporting team," Bai added.

"If you have never been, you would wonder how you could build dams in such a beautiful area. But that's not the case. It's in a remote border area, and the trees around have almost all been felled. Only if there is economic development can there be money to protect the environment," he said.

"So building dams is good for both the local people and the environment," Bai added.

Environmental groups say the projects would displace ethnic minority peoples, destroy a unique ecosystem and affect people living downstream in Myanmar and Thailand.

Many other Chinese dam projects have become mired in controversy, not least the massive Three Gorges Dam, where Chinese officials have said areas around it were paying a heavy, potentially calamitous environmental cost.

Bai said work still needed to be done to convince Myanmar about the dams, but he didn't think that would be a problem.

Persuading environmental groups to drop their opposition could be a harder task, he admitted, but added he thought it unfair not to bring development to the local people.

"You cannot expect the people of the Nu River to keep wearing animal skins and bring in everyone to have a look in the name of ecotourism," Bai said. "They also have the right to exist, and to development."

The government would ensure that money earned from the power produced would be ploughed back into the community, he added, although critics say the power generated will be shipped off to factories and developments in more prosperous provinces.

"We have to do this, not only for the Nu River, but for other rivers too," Bai said, refering to the plan to spend a proportion of the hydroplants' income on local people.

But Beijing will only sign off on the scheme if the province can show it has consulted widely, including with Myanmar and non-governmental bodies, he said.

"We will step up work in this regard," Bai added, though he said he did not know when construction might start.

(Editing by Sanjeev Miglani)


Story by Ben Blanchard


Read more!

New Book Puts Cost of Saving Planet at $190 Billion

PlanetArk 7 Mar 08;

LONDON - What would it cost to wipe out world poverty, guarantee universal health care, stabilise population growth and roll back the ravages of global warming?

About $190 billion a year, or the equivalent of a third of US annual military expenditure, a prominent environmental economist says in a new book.

"Once you accept that climate change, population growth, spreading water shortages, rising food prices etcetera are threats to our security, it changes your whole way of thinking about how you use public resources," Lester Brown told Reuters in an interview.

From eradicating adult illiteracy to restoring fisheries and stabilising water tables, the head of the Earth Policy Institute think tank in Washington calculates the cost of saving civilisation in a new edition of his best-selling "Plan B".

The $190 billion price tag compares with $1.2 trillion that world governments spent on military budgets in 2006. The United States splurged the most with $560 billion.

Describing a planet on the brink of environmental meltdown, Brown calls for a "great mobilisation" to fight climate change, equivalent to the Allied wartime effort to beat Nazi Germany.

Plan A would be for the world to continue on its present course. Plan B is Brown's strategy to stabilise climate, stem runaway population growth, eradicate poverty and restore damaged ecosystems.

Brown argues that failure to achieve any one of these goals would result in defeat overall.

"I don't think Plan B is perfect, but it's the only plan out there -- the only alternative to business as usual," he said.

"One might think that the World Bank or the UN or someone would have a plan that takes into account how systems are interacting and what that translates into, but the reality is this is the only one."


"ECOLOGICAL HONESTY"

The centrepiece of Brown's blueprint for change is a detailed plan to cut global carbon dioxide emissions by 80 percent by 2020 to keep a lid on future temperature rises.

He also calls for a restructuring of the world economy -- and tax systems in particular -- to make markets "ecologically honest", meaning that commodity prices should reflect indirect environmental costs.

Take the price of water, which Brown argues is too cheap to discourage countries from exhausting vital sources.

"The thing to keep in mind is that it takes 1,000 tonnes of water to produce one tonne of grain," he said.

"Seventy percent of all the water we use in the world -- that we pump from underground or divert from rivers -- is used in irrigation. Not everyone has connected the dots to see that a future of water shortages will be a future of food shortages."

Brown, who has authored or coauthored more than 50 books, was one of the first economists to warn that the boom in biofuels could be a threat to global food security.

"In this new world where the price of grain is tied to the price of oil, if the price of oil goes up, so grain goes up," he said. "And that is a threat to political stability in the world that I don't think we've come close to grasping yet."

A central theme of "Plan B" is that it's not too late to save the planet -- if we act now.

That optimism sets Brown apart from eco-pioneers like Gaia guru James Lovelock, who has concluded it's too late to reverse the devastating effects of climate change.

"He might be right, and he's not the only one who thinks that," Brown said. "I have to hope there's a chance we can turn it around. Otherwise there's no point. Even if we lose it's better to go down fighting than just standing there."

(Editing by Andrew Roche)


Read more!

UK Women's Institutes members reduce rubbish

WI do their bit for the environment
Charles Clover, The Telegraph 6 Mar 08;

Members of the Women's Institutes have reduced the amount of household rubbish they put out each year to 18 stone (118 kg) compared with the national average of 152 stone (970kg), according to figures published today.

WI members were already doing much better than the national average, putting out an average of only 23 stone of rubbish a year when they got involved in a four-month initiative in which they joined an eco-team.

This was thought to be because many WI members did their own cooking so they did not buy so many ready meals which come in lots of packaging.

Those who joined the eco-teams still managed to reduce that amount by 22 per cent mainly by recycling more than they did before.

Ruth Bond, chairman of the National Federation of Women's Institutes public affairs committee, said: "These are fantastic results. Our members have shown that through a concerted effort we can reduce our impact on the environment and therefore decrease out household's contribution to climate change."

Joy Evans, of Hagley, Worcs, who was on one of the eco-teams, said: "The trick is to think about what you are buying and recycle everything you possibly can.

"Don't buy veg with packaging on it. Buy it from the local shop where there is no packaging at all. My shopping habits have changed since I have been in the eco-team. I shop much more locally."

She takes the plastic bags she does use back to the supermarket.

Jill Glover of Little Chalfont, Bucks, said: "I think WI members are generally more aware. We have campaigned on environmental problems for years."

While on an eco-team she discovered a way of recycling Tetrapak cardboard containers at her local Tesco. "Only I don't shop there," she added.

The WI eco-teams also tried to cut their output of carbon dioxide from household heating and electricity. They were above the national average of 469 kg per month when they started at 491 kg a month. This they managed to reduce to 421 kg a month on average by turning switches off, taking equipment off standby and using low-energy lighting.


Read more!

Middle classes 'more immediate threat than climate change'

Roger Highfield, The Telegraph 6 Mar 08;

The relentless rise of the middle classes presents a more immediate threat to developing countries than climate change, says the Prime Minister's chief scientist.

As an increasing proportion of people rise out of poverty, a surge in investment in modern agriculture and irrigation will be essential if global food security is to be achieved and to avoid huge hikes in the cost of food, says Prof John Beddington, Chief Scientific Adviser, who was speaking at the Sustainable Development UK conference in Westminster.

He says that there had already been references to how "a perfect storm" was brewing for agriculture as a result of many factors - increasing food and energy prices, a shift to non food crops, climate change, the rise in the world's population - expected to reach 9 billion by 2050 - water supply issues and alleviating poverty.

But he warns that of these factors it is the rise of the middle classes that most concerns him, since they leave a much bigger footprint on the planet's resources, as they demand high-value agricultural products and processed food compared with the desperately poor.

Prof Beddington believes that this factor has been relatively neglected and will have more immediate effects than either climate change or the burgeoning overall world population.

The World Bank estimates that, as the economies of China and India boom, the number of households in developing countries with incomes above £8,000 per annum will rise from 352 million in 2000 to 2.1 billion by 2030. Meanwhile, the global population will surge from 6.5 billion to around 8.5 billion.

So in the short term, the world needs to invest in agriculture to cope with a crisis in energy and food production, to make better and more efficient use of water, concludes Prof Beddington, a mathematical biologist at Imperial College London who has done work in fields such as chaos theory,

The strain is already showing in the food supply, which is at an all time low. Since 2005, world agricultural production has started to lag behind population growth and the resulting rise in demand for energy, and as the middle classes change from pulses and grains to eating more meat, will put huge pressure on irrigation and agriculture. Chicken, pigs and some beef are fed on grain, so the global demand for grain will rise along with the need for water.

At the same time, the world's food resources are at an all time low, the demand for cereals for biofuels is rising, and world energy demand is projected to soar by over half by 2030.

In his talk, Prof Beddington refers to a report by Joachim von Braun, Director General, of the International Food Policy Research Institute that points out how low-growing supply, low stocks, and supply shock at a time of surging demand for feed, food, and fuel have led to drastic price increases, "and these high prices do not appear likely to fall soon."

Higher food prices will cause the poor to shift to even less-balanced diets, with adverse impacts on health in the short and long run. "Business as usual could mean increased misery, especially for the world's poorest populations. "

Another pressure is global urbanisation, Prof Beddington says. Cities are now home to half of the world's 6.6 billion humans and by 2030 that urban fraction will rise to 60 per cent as nearly 5 billion people will live in cities of the projected global population of around 8.5 billion,. This is likely to put a huge strain on resources, particularity water supplies.

The UK also needs to maintain if not grow the capacity for food production, as the population is projected to rise from 59 million to 70 million by 2030, although there has been a decline in agriculture and food sciences in our universities.


Read more!

Greening of CeBIT fails to revive shrinking IT fair

Georgina Prodhan, Reuters 6 Mar 08;

HANOVER, Germany (Reuters) - Europe's biggest information technology fair went green this year. The problem was that there weren't many people around to notice.

CeBIT 2008 was a slimmed-down, serious affair, cut back to six days from seven. Formerly sprawling exhibits were corralled into order by theme and publicity stunts banished to the weekend that now comes at the end of the show, not the middle.

The idea was to turn dwindling exhibitor and visitor interest into a virtue by using the lack of gadgety distractions to create a business-like arena where managers could get on with meeting, greeting and checking out the competition.

The result was an atmosphere free of the chaos of previous years but also devoid of excitement, casting a feeling of desertion over the vast trade-fair grounds in the northern German city of Hanover.

"We decided to do product launches globally at CES," said Michael Langbehn, in charge of PR and marketing in Germany for electronics maker Panasonic (6752.T: Quote, Profile, Research), referring to the huge annual consumer electronics show held in January in Las Vegas.

"Then there's IFA, which is a must," he added, meaning the August/September consumer gadgets fair in Berlin that has drawn electronics makers and the German public away from CeBIT.

"And then consider the BRIC countries, which also have their own fairs that are growing."

Like most exhibitors who still elect to come to CeBIT -- this year there are 5,845 of them, 5 percent down from last year -- Panasonic is using CeBIT to explain its less glamorous business-system products to potential clients.

Talk of "solutions" of all kinds -- vertical, digital and security -- abounded at the fair.

Cisco (CSCO.O: Quote, Profile, Research) was one of the few to talk about the problems demanding these solutions as it launched a new Internet router to help cope with a surge in monthly data sent over the Internet to 29 exabytes by 2011 -- equivalent to 144 times all the world's printed matter.

TREE-HUGGERS

CeBIT organizers declared the theme of this year's show to be the environment and built a "green village" to house companies peddling products to boost corporate energy efficiency and reduce toxic waste.

"CeBIT Goes Green -- Big Time" was the main headline of the official CeBIT News on Wednesday, recognizing that "green IT" is a trend impossible to ignore as both energy costs and climate-altering carbon emissions soar.

Microsoft (MSFT.O: Quote, Profile, Research) Chief Executive Steve Ballmer, by far the highest-profile speaker at CeBIT, conformed with the trend by announcing a deal with German energy provider Yello Strom for technology to display electricity consumption on a home PC.

But most journalists were only interested in quizzing him on Microsoft's campaign to buy Yahoo (YHOO.O: Quote, Profile, Research) in a bid currently valued at $42 billion.

The information and communications industry has overtaken aviation in terms of carbon emissions believed to cause global warming, accounting for just over 2 percent of emissions, according to research firm IDC.

The picture is complicated, however, by the hidden environmental cost of transporting electronic parts around the world to assemble them where labor is cheap as well as the fact that IT can cut the need for travel to face-to-face meetings.

Environmental group Greenpeace promised a hard look at the green claims of electronics manufacturers, driven more by a need to cut costs than a desire to save the planet.

At a sparsely attended news conference, it singled out products from Apple (AAPL.O: Quote, Profile, Research), Sony Ericsson (6758.T: Quote, Profile, Research)(ERICb.ST: Quote, Profile, Research) and Nokia (NOK1V.HE: Quote, Profile, Research) for praise while cautioning, "It's not enough just to offer a green computer for the tree-huggers."

Greenpeace's "could do better" verdict on the industry -- following a gadget survey severely limited by manufacturers' willingness to cooperate -- could apply to the new-concept CeBIT as a whole.

CeBIT continues in Hanover until Sunday.

(Editing by Quentin Bryar)


Read more!

Energy for internet equal to CO2 emissions of airline industry

Second Life avatars and Brazilians: the same carbon footprint
Aurelia End, Yahoo News 6 Mar 08;

What do an avatar on Second Life and the average inhabitant of Brazil in the real world have in common? Incredibly, they both use the same amount of electricity.

It is perhaps not a fair example as the average virtual being in the online community is not active all the time, but the statistic does show that all that time the rich world spends online has an impact on the environment.

And how. Providing energy to work the Internet needs the equivalent of 14 power stations, which in turn cough out the same amount of harmful carbon dioxide emissions as the airline industry, research has estimated.

This does not even include all the emissions created by making PCs, mobile phones and PDAs and shipping them around the planet. If you add the energy required to recycle them -- not that that many are recycled -- the industry has quite a footprint.

It is with this in focus that CeBIT, the world's largest technology fair, opened its doors this week in Hanover, Germany with 5,500 exhibitors showing off the smartest, coolest -- and this year the greenest -- gadgets.

With oil and gas prices pushing up energy bills, a main motivation is also cutting down the costs for consumers and businesses.

IBM, for example, devoted large parts of its stand at CeBIT, which runs to March 9, to showing how its new servers use less energy.

Vast farms of servers made by IBM and others are used to power the Internet, and it is these gas-guzzling data centres of immense size and energy consumption that drive Second Life and indeed the entire Internet.

Siegfried Behrendt, a researcher at Berlin's IZT institute, calculates that downloading his daily newspaper uses the same amount of electricity as running a washing machine.

German IT firm Strato, meanwhile, reckons that looking for something on Internet search engine Google requires as much energy as an energy-efficient light-bulb uses in an hour.

This won't show up on your monthly electricity bill though, because most of the energy required for these actions takes place in a server somewhere on a data farm.

And consumption is growing. A study commissioned by US microchip maker AMD at Stanford University in the United States calculated that between 2000 and 2004 data farms' energy use doubled.

At this rate, in less than a quarter century the Internet will consume as much energy as the whole of humanity does today, Gerhard Fettweis from Dresden University in Germany believes.

Between now and 2010, "everything is possible. Either nothing changes, and the consumption of data centres grows 50 percent. Or real efforts are made, and a lowering of 50 percent is conceivable," Fettweis told AFP.

Real efforts were on show at CeBIT, raising hopes that innovation will find a way to lessen the IT industry's environmental impact.

Data centres produce a huge amount of heat but the rooms they are in also have to be kept cool to avoid overheating.

IBM -- which also operates server farms on behalf of other firms -- wants to capture that heat and use it to power air conditioning to keep things cool.

And software giant Microsoft has a data centre near Quincy in the United States -- right next to a hydro-electric plant, providing its servers with renewable energy.

Another solution is so-called virtualisation of servers, a technique whereby special software turns spare capacity on the server to function as multiple computers.


Read more!

World Food Programme chief warns EU about biofuels

Yahoo News 6 Mar 08;

The UN agency in charge of alleviating world hunger warned the European Union on Thursday that the fast-growing use of biofuels is driving up food prices for the world's poor.

"The shift to biofuels production has diverted lands out of the food chain," World Food Programme executive director Josette Sheeran told lawmakers at the European Parliament in Brussels.

"Food prices such as palm oil in Africa are now set at fuel prices," she added.

Sheeran warned that booming food prices were hurting the WFP's "capacity to respond to hunger" by increasing its operating costs, which have risen by 40 percent since June 2007 alone.

The price of many food commodities has soared worldwide to record levels over the last year due to booming demand in fast-growing Asian countries as well as the increased use of biofuels.

Although Sheeran attributed some of the price increase to market speculation, she also said that "structural factors are part of today's high prices."

"It may be a bonanza for farmers -- I hope it is true -- but in the short-term, the world's poorest are hit hard," she said.

The 27-nation EU aims to ramp up its use of biofuels in coming years after the bloc's leaders set tough renewable energy targets last year.

They committed to increase the EU's renewable energy use by 20 percent by 2020, compared to 1990 levels, with biofuels to make up 10 percent of all transport fuels used by then.

However, since EU leaders fixed those targets in March last year, concerns have risen about possible negative effects from biofuels, including their impact on food prices and the environment.

UN Sees More Hunger, Unrest Over Food Inflation
PlanetArk 7 Mar 08;

BRUSSELS - Record high food prices and resulting inflation are set to continue until at least 2010, fuelling a "new hunger" across the globe and anarchy on the streets of poorer nations, a top UN official said.

Josette Sheeran, executive director of the United Nations' World Food Programme, said the world's economy "has now entered a perfect storm for the world's hungry" caused by high oil and food prices and low food stocks.

"Our assessment is that the current level will continue for the next few years ... in fact rise in 2008, 2009 and probably at least until 2010," she said on a visit to Brussels on Thursday where she met European Union officials.

Her visit came on a day that oil, gold and copper surged to record highs as investors fleeing a weak dollar piled into commodities.

Sheeran said food prices were rising due to a combination of soaring oil and energy prices, the effects of climate change, growing demand from countries such as India and China and use of crops to produce biofuels.

"This is leading to a new face of hunger in the world, what we call the newly hungry. These are people who have money, but have been priced out of being able to buy food," she said.

"Higher food prices will increase social unrest in a number of countries which are sensitive to inflationary pressures and are import-dependent. We will see a repeat of the riots we have already reported on the streets such as we have seen in Burkina Faso, Cameroon and Senegal."


FOOD GAP

Over 25,000 people die from hunger or a related illness every day across the world, with one child dying every five seconds.

The UN aid official was in Brussels seeking help in bridging a $500 million dollar "food gap" created by soaring commodity costs which have increased by around 40 percent since 2007.

The WFP is currently drawing up a list of 30 countries which they believe are "most vulnerable" to the current food inflation crises such as Afghanistan where $77 million is needed to feed an additional 2.5 million people.

"Our budget shortfall for 2008 means that at the moment we have to decide do we provide 40 percent less food or do we reach out to 40 percent less people. This is unacceptable," Sheeran said.

Along with extra funding, she said one solution would be to increase food production by using more land for agriculture and reducing the amount of land set aside for biofuels.

The EU last year set itself a target for biofuels to account for 10 percent of fuel used by transport in the bloc by 2020.

But critics have recently questioned whether the plan needs to be reviewed in the light of concerns about the impact of biofuels on food supplies and whether they really contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

"Governments need to look more carefully at the link between the acceleration in biofuels and food supply and give more thought to it (biofuels policy)," Sheeran said.

"We are not seeing any benefits to small farmers, particularly in the less-developed world. This land could be better used."

Speculative investment in commodities markets in products such as grains and cereals, which has helped fuel the price surge, is not a short-term phenomenon, she said.

"This is not a short-term bubble and will definitely continue," Sheeran said.

(Editing by Michael Roddy)


Read more!

US sewage-based fertilizer safety doubted

John Heilprin and Kevin S. Vineys, Associated Press Yahoo News 7 Mar 08;

It was a farm idea with a big payoff and supposedly no downside: ridding lakes and rivers of raw sewage and industrial pollution by converting it all into a free, nutrient-rich fertilizer.

Then last week, a federal judge ordered the Agriculture Department to compensate a farmer whose land was poisoned by sludge from the waste treatment plant here. His cows had died by the hundreds.

The Associated Press also has learned that some of the same contaminants showed up in milk that regulators allowed a neighboring dairy farmer to market, even after some officials said they were warned about it.

In one case, according to test results provided to the AP, the level of thallium — an element once used as rat poison — found in the milk was 120 times the concentration allowed in drinking water by the Environmental Protection Agency.

The contaminated milk and the recent ruling by U.S. District Judge Anthony Alaimo raise new doubts about a 30-year government policy that encourages farmers to spread millions of tons of sewage sludge over thousands of acres each year as an alternative to commercial fertilizers.

The program is still in effect.

Alaimo ordered the government to compensate dairy farmer Andy McElmurray because 1,730 acres he wanted to plant in corn and cotton to feed his herd was poisoned. The sludge contained levels of arsenic, toxic heavy metals and PCBs two to 2,500 times federal health standards.

Also, data endorsed by Agriculture and EPA officials about toxic heavy metals found in the free sludge provided by Augusta's sewage treatment plant was "unreliable, incomplete, and in some cases, fudged," Alaimo wrote.

EPA-commissioned research by the University of Georgia based on the Augusta data was included in a National Academy of Sciences report and served as a linchpin for the government's assertion that sludge didn't pose a health risk.

In his 45-page ruling, Alaimo said that along with using the questionable data, "senior EPA officials took extraordinary steps to quash scientific dissent, and any questioning of EPA's biosolids program."

Benjamin H. Grumbles, EPA's assistant administrator for water programs, said Thursday that the judge's order underscored the significance of what he called strong national standards on sludge rather than undercutting the giveaway program.

"This unfortunate instance of poor recordkeeping and biosolids sampling techniques on the part of one plant reiterates the importance of our national biosolids program," Grumbles said in a written response to AP questions about the ruling.

About 7 million tons of biosolids — the term that waste producers came up with for sludge in 1991 — are produced each year as a byproduct from 1,650 waste water treatment plants around the nation.

Slightly more than half is used on land as fertilizer; the rest is incinerated or burned in landfills. Giving it away to farmers is cheaper than burning or burying it, and the government's policy has been to encourage the former.

Alaimo's decision was a bittersweet victory for McElmurray, whose silos and dairy barns sit mostly empty since his herd was wiped out. He contends the cows were done in by grazing on sludge-treated hay for more than a decade, beginning in 1979.

Interviewed before the ruling, McElmurray crossed his arms, scowling at the empty pastures and idle equipment where his prize-winning herds once grazed here in eastern Georgia. "This farm never would have looked like this if we hadn't used the city's sludge," he said angrily.

The city of Augusta recently settled a lawsuit with him over the dead cows for $1.5 million. Another nearby dairy farmer, Bill Boyce, won a $550,000 court judgment against the city on his claim that sludge was responsible for the deaths of more than 300 of his cows.

The deaths of McElmurray's and Boyce's cows in the 1990s and their suits against Augusta raised a red flag with officials at EPA, which since 1978 had been promoting the use of sludge as a fertilizer.

In 1999, the agency awarded a $12,274 grant to the University of Georgia to study the problem. That research would result in a study published in 2003 in the Journal of Environmental Quality finding that the city's sludge was safe and that EPA's regulations were working.

Cities' sewage and industrial pollution had spewed untreated into lakes, rivers and oceans until 1972, when Congress passed the landmark Clean Water Act.

Back then, cleaning up waterways was the first target of the newly created EPA. The agency oversaw a multibillion-dollar grant program that Congress set up to help cities and counties build wastewater treatment plants that would filter out pollutants.

Alaimo, citing data from an environmental engineer hired by McElmurray, found that the Augusta plant was sending out hundreds of truckloads of sludge daily with dangerously high levels of cadmium, molybdenum and chlordane.

The engineer, William Hall of Atlanta, had been a project manager at seven Superfund cleanup sites and had extensive experience with toxic chemicals and heavy metals. His tests found polychlorinated biphenyls or PCBs in the Augusta sludge at levels 2,500 times higher than the EPA standard, thallium levels 25 times the legal limit, and arsenic levels twice the government's health standard.

William Miller, a University of Georgia soil scientist who co-authored the 2003 study commissioned by EPA, stands by the conclusions it drew on how much sludge had been applied to McElmurray's and Boyce's land and the composition of it.

But in a draft of the paper obtained by The Associated Press, he wrote a note by hand saying the authors should "fess up" that they didn't know those things.

"Now, we didn't really know exactly how much sludge and we didn't know the quality of sludge," Miller told the AP in an interview. Despite the discrepancies, he maintained the study was valid. "It does not include fake data," he said.

Boyce told the AP that in January 1999 he informed Georgia dairy regulators and EPA that tests he had ordered on the milk from his cows had come back showing high levels of thallium, molybdenum and cadmium.

A top state official alerted the Food and Drug Administration, but Boyce said no one ever told him to stop selling his milk or mentioned a possible threat to public health.

"We were a little startled," Boyce recalled. "They concluded that our permit was good, and we could continue to sell milk. So we did."

EPA lists thallium as a toxic heavy metal that can cause gastrointestinal irritation and nerve damage, but the agency has no standard on the metal's presence in milk. Neither does the Agriculture Department, even though it regards thallium as one of the most dangerous agents of potential bioterrorism against the nation's food supply.

State and EPA officials followed up by testing Boyce's milk, but he said they wouldn't share all their results with him or McElmurray. There is no evidence that those officials took any further action. Boyce said he decided finally to reveal the milk contamination to the AP to illuminate a broader issue.

"The real problem was the state and federal regulatory agencies did not do their jobs," he said, adding that EPA and Augusta officials "tried to say we were just a disease-infested herd. Well, that's just a bunch of bullhockey."

Charles Murphy, then head of Georgia's dairy program, said he notified FDA's Administration's office in Atlanta of Boyce's contaminated samples. "I know I talked to them some, shared some of that information with them," he recalled. "I don't think they sent anybody out."

Murphy said he was persuaded by evidence provided to him by Boyce and McElmurray to seek broader state testing of dairy cows, but there wasn't enough money.

FDA officials in Atlanta and Washington said they had no record of Murphy's account.

But over the Super Bowl weekend in 1999, two senior EPA officials, Robert Bastian and Bob Brobst, huddled with the two dairy farmers and their lawyer, Ed Hallman, to talk about sludge.

"They showed us some data," Bastian recalled. "I don't ever remember seeing any milk data."

Boyce and McElmurray insist they shared all of their data with the two EPA officials, including separate tests they ran on milk pulled from store shelves in Charleston, S.C. That milk, which came from other farms in the Southeast, suggested more widespread contamination, they said. It had heavy metals similar to those found in Boyce's milk.

There are no records that anyone became ill because of milk tainted with heavy metals or other contaminants that could have come from sludge.


Read more!